Mama Mimi
My daughter and I love new dining experiences; we took a trip down to Social Circle today to eat at Critters Outdoor Pizza. We ordered a 10-in pepperoni pizza and a garlic bread along with all of the sauces on the side.
The garlic sauce is really good, the possum sauce is an amazing garlic alfredo and of course we all know Mike’s hot honey.
The pepperoni pizza and the garlic bread were both absolutely delicious! I love the thin crust and ingredients to the edge. Cookie, our server was great!
Overall an amazing experience and we do plan on coming back!
… moreKayla Ann
The food is amazing but the service was awful. We waited over an hour for an appetizer. We got there a little after 6pm and didn’t get out until 8pm. The entrees should have come out together but they didn’t. I know people will say well that’s the kitchens fault, not the servers but a table who sat beside us got in after, got their app and their pizzas and left before our pizzas came out. The server said it was only her second day serving but did not communicate with us not once, and she avoided our table most the night sending her trainee to do table visits the rest of the night. Not once did a manager come by. Customer service is everything and it’s lacking. Please do better because the food is amazing. Prioritize your customers.
… moreLisa Anne
Awesome place! I can’t wait until it warms up to enjoy the patio space! Great staff! My first time there (I didn’t catch her name) but the young lady at the counter was so, so very helpful and has great energy! I had several questions being my first time so great experience in the door!
NEW menu so I’ve addd pics to help others. I was able to enjoy a beverage while I waited. It only took ~15mins which was great! She did say they are working on a fountain as well as beer taps so yeah!
The pizza was reeeaally good! Thin crispy crust (I love)…(there is also a GF/cauliflower option for those who may need it), toppings had a MUCH better flavor than “the chains.” I’ll be back for sure!
… moreEmily Dailey
We went here tonight for a quick dinner. They were so so welcoming. The food was super good and the drinks were priced well! The personal pan pictured is the 10 inch Otters Holding Hands pizza, it was super yummy!
The outdoor space is a great place to enjoy a pizza and I few drinks! Would definitely recommend.
… moreDomonique Campbell
What a cute little place with amazing customer service and just all around friendly vibes. Since I moved to Georgia from Jersey I’ve been looking for a place that has some decent thin crust pizza and I surely found it. I can’t rate what the “sit down restaurant” experience would’ve been because I only just walked in and ordered to go but in that brief interaction I had with the young lady that greeted me I felt really welcomed (I only regret not remembering her name). Pizza wise I literally couldn’t even take a picture of the whole thing because when I saw it I didn’t wanna wait to taste and before I knew it half was gone . Overall great brief and friendly experience I will definitely be going back
… moreGay Boassy
Ordered a large margarita with additional cheese, got it home and hardly any cheese!! Crust was delicious but ya know, I wanted CHEESE! So disappointing. Staff is always very nice!
… moreAnn Young
We get take out all the time here. If you are looking for Domino’s or Papa John’s type pizza, this is not for you. If you want thin crust type, this is the place. I like the char on their pizzas. It goes well with the out of the box toppings. HOWEVER, if you want a cheese or pepperoni or something more classic, order that and ASK FOR LESS OR NO CHAR! They are always happy to oblige.
I’ll be honest, when they first opened there was some inconsistency, but we’ve had no issues anymore. This is a go to place for us now. Highly recommend.
… moreGeo
Tried for the first time tonight. 20” pep, sausage, mushrooms, and extra cheese. Pizza was very good! Crust is very good, and the service was exceptional. Will definitely be back!
… moreJohn
We just happened to stop in while a 5 yr old girl was having her birthday party, and she invited 30 of her friends. Lots of kids, piñatas, unicorns and loud music. Seriously, the pizza was good and the vibe could have been different. Just timing on our part.
… moreJake Stockton
I ordered 2 pizzas and 2 cheese breads. I paid extra for 2x cheese on the pizza. I didn’t even get regular cheese topping! The cheese bread and pizza were so good last time. This is absolutely horrible. When we called to complain the owner told the associate that this was fine for cheese bread and 2 times extra cheese on the pizzas. Not sure where they’re used to buying pizza but clearly isn’t anywhere worth getting it! DO NOT BUY PIZZA FROM CRITTERS!!! WORST pizza and cheese bread I have EVER seen. HERE ARE SOME PICTURES! This is the paper thin cheese bread and the two extra cheese topping pizza!!!! And they refused to make it right. Don’t buy pizza here!
… more