Sheila Boes
My daughter had one of the best Italian subs she’s ever had there, from the fresh bakery bread to the delicious meat, variety, toppings and dressing. I took one bite and said I know we’re going to be coming back here cuz she’s going to love this. And when she was halfway done with it, she said, We’re coming back here! The chicken added to my yummy Greek salad was freshly grilled with a very nice flavor too. It was definitely restaurant quality, food, not just a pizza place that also threw together the sandwich or a salad just to have something else on the menu! Great staff, friendly and warm.
… moreHarrison Edwards
I have always been a hater of Hawaiian Pizza. I have no idea how they make theirs taste so amazing, but it will be a regular purchase moving forward.
Deena, one of their owners was super informative and helpful.
You need to try Sergio’s – the new ownership has greatly improved quality and flavors.
… moreCynthia jean Poitra
Their pizza is phenomenal! And their gluten free pizza is by far the best I’ve ever had!
Good gluten free pizza is not easy to find. Amazing staff, chill atmosphere. Definitely going back!
… moreKimberly Martin
If you’re looking for consistently delicious pizza in Barrington, Sergio’s Pizza is the place to go. From the moment you walk in, the casual, family-friendly vibe makes you feel right at home. The staff is warm and attentive, whether you’re dining in or ordering delivery. A true neighborhood favorite that never disappoints. Highly recommended!
… moreM. Robertson
My husband and I were visiting the Chicago area from Canada. We had a chance to stop in to Sergio’s Pizza in the suburb of Barrington. Sergio’s has a casual sports-bar feel and it’s owned and operated by a local couple. I love that! We had already tried a “world-famous” deep dish pizza at the Giordano’s conglomerate and we are not fans. At Sergio’s we wanted something different and the owner suggested we try their extra thin crust. We ordered a 16 inch pizza so we could have leftovers. Well, we didn’t have leftovers because we couldn’t stop eating, it was that good. The owner was even impressed to notice our empty platter! The crust was perfectly done, crispy enough to pick up and not be floppy but not so well done to have a hard crunch. Their sauce is also delicious but with a flavour that doesn’t overpower the toppings. It was one of the best pizzas we have ever had, and I REALLY like pizza. They have converted us to extra-thin crust pizza lovers! I wonder if they deliver to Canada??
… moreSzczepan Swiderski
1st time order here
Ranch not house made its from bottle.
Calamari so DRY! It tasted from bottom freezer.
Pizza was 4 of 10
… moreJoyce Royster
Pizza was soooooo good. Great pizza sauce & crust was perfect, not soggy. Staff was extremely polite & answered my questions that I had because of my food allergies. We definitely will be going back there again.
… moreMatt Logerquist
This place is awesome got one of the best slices of pizza I’ve had in a long time! Also the crust is always perfect!
… moreLouis Salas
My only complaint is that I didn’t know about this place sooner. Not too fancy, very casual. Deena was so nice and down to earth. She made me feel like family that was visiting rather than a customer. I had a taste for stuffed cheese pizza . Epic cheese and flakey crust did not disappoint. Will I be back? 100% Without a doubt!!! Highly recommend.
… moreDaniel Sava
Stopped by last night another great thin crust sausage and green pepper pizza!
Thank you Deena and John
… more