Chanil Jung
I had such a great experience at TOASTED. The bagels are perfectly fresh with a wonderful chewy texture, and the spreads are delicious without being overwhelming. The coffee pairs beautifully—smooth, bold, and not bitter. The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere feels cozy yet modern, making it a great spot to relax or catch up with friends. Definitely one of the best bagel and coffee spots around—I’ll be coming back often!
… moreAlan Wong
Calling your bagel place Toasted is the equivalent of calling your pizza place reheated, but they do it right here of toasting the bagels whole as the default.
Holy crap are there pickled red onions here, making it a bit out or balance but easy to remove.
The best thing here is the sweet bagels. Turkish inspired the combination of labneh, honey, dates or pears and crushed walnuts is astoundingly good and well balanced.
The flight of open faced bagels is really cool, letting you try most of their menu in one go.
… moreIrene F
We read the good reviews and decided to give this place a try. We were kind of disappointed with the taste of the bagels though. They were bland and we didn’t like the dense bagels and the texture even after toasting. All I could taste with a bite was the doughy bagel. Will not go again.
… moreNatasha Saad
Seriously so good. Its very pricey, but its really filling. One of the best bagels I’ve had, and its 100% Halal. Lattes were ok but the bagels are the main show
… moreSarah Abdulsalam
Super cool place, friendly staff and fresh bagels.
The menu is not your regular bagel options, every menu item has an interesting ingredient that you wouldn’t expect on a bagel but the flavor blends so well. If you like plain boring bagels, they got that too.
It’s halal too so cleaner meat options.
Their turkey pesto bagel was phenomenal, planning to come back to try more varieties.
… moreAmmara T
I was super excited to try this place once I heard about it and came in the morning expecting fresh bagels but they were honestly dry and the everything bagel was really salty! The toppings overall were good and we tried the salmon bagel and the pesto turkey but definately room for improvement. I’ve lived in NY so know good bagels and these have so much potential to be better. I’m all for supporting a local business and hope they continue to work on their bagels and have more options like Gluten free.
… morezaahira hassim
Toasted is a cute bagel spot. We enjoyed the bagels and variety of nice fillings. The bagels and ingredients are fresh.
… morePaige
The food was DELICIOUS. I got the chai rose latte, which I will absolutely be back for! I also got the Turkey pesto peach bagel which was super yum! I love the addition of the (canned)peach for sweetness. My husband got turkey bec which he said hit the spot and he loved the flavor of the Turkish coffee served in a cute cup and saucer. I hate to say anything negative about the atmosphere because the actual restaurant area was very cute with plants and brass decor. The sitting area which is a shared space with other restaurants was very clean but had a basic, modern, cold, food court vibe with metal chairs. There are nice big windows though. Maybe when it gets busy it feels more cozy. We came early in the morning on a mid week day and it wasn’t very busy. I wished they had some flowers in the window sill or something. The main important thing is the food, location and service is great!
… moreFelix
I had a super juicy Italian pesto peach bagel. I really liked it. Service was also friendly and quick. Was a little confused when I walked in and everything was super dark but apparnetly it’s sharing the location with another restaurant which was closed.
… moreNora Elbeheiry
I ordered the Turkey Pesto Peach on an Everything bagel and the Cardamom Honey latte. Both were so delicious! The bagel was a 10/10. I will definitely be coming back to try more of the menu.
Also it was a busy morning for them and it was only a two person team yet all orders came out quickly and perfectly made. They would bring your order to you and clean tables off. Super friendly staff! (And they play good music)
… more