Brandyn Rubeck
Mr. Pizza making some killer za. Crust is an amazing. Bubbly, crunchy, chewy, flavorful. If you got a good crust that’s all you need. The Margarita is my personal favorite, but their whole menu has a worth trying. Never had a bad experience here. Always fresh and flavorful. Keep up the killer work y’all!
… moreDimitri Simones
The pizza was great definitely above most in the area. But the highlight for me was specifically the pepperoni probably the best pepperoni I’ve ever had.
… moreMichael Shiffer
The best pizza in the area. Thin, nice char, good crunch on the crust. The dough is what makes it special. The cupped pepperoni is also a delight. Gave 3 stars for atmosphere but what do you want for an order to go place. Without a doubt the highest quality and best tasting pie in town. Also super friendly staff.
… moreClarice L
Mr. Pizza lives up to the high ratings. Space has a bench to wait for your order and two high top tables if you want to dine in. We ordered a margarita pizza and ate standing at the high top. Pizza was made to order and ready in about 10 minutes. High quality ingredients had great flavor. Crust was crisp and good chew. Decided to order a slice of the Sicilian pepperoni to try too and it was also delicious. Sicilian dough reminded me of focaccia bread. Would absolutely come back.
… moreivan
I don’t usually leave reviews for pizza places, but this was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The crust, sauce, and garlic-infused olive oil came together perfectly. Would definitely make the drive from Providence to order again.
… moreKen D
As it stands- the best pizza in westerly, hands down. I am a thin crust new haven style pizza fan- and this is the closest thing to it. Excellent pizza. My new go to in town.
… moreChris Benamati
This is a quality pizza place with homemade ingredients. I was impressed with the perfect crust, doughy on the inside but nice and crispy on the outside. The flavors were amazing…tried a white pizza and a pair of traditional pizzas and all were top notch.
… moreBruce Provencher
This is a takeout review. All food is eaten promptly in the vehicle. I ordered fries and a pepperoni pizza. The fries were very nicely done, crispy and fresh. The pizza was excellent. A nice light crust, great sauce, beautifully cupped pepperoni, and a very nice sauce to cheese ratio. And a very pleasant young lady handling the counter. On a scale from 0-10, I would rate this 9.5.
… morerobert schmitz
We can’t get out of the parking lot! It’s so good, a teaser slice is quickly turning into the whole pizza. Definitely making this a regular for pizza night!
… moreEllie Sullivan
An unbelievable pie! I couldn’t even make it out of the parking lot without trying a bite. It was my first time trying their pizza, so I went classic with half mozz and half pepperoni. The New Haven char, the sauce, the cheese, all phenomenal. I will 1000% be back. ❤️
… more