Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 33926 State Rte 3, Carthage, NY 13619
Phone: (315) 493-0304
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Whistle Stop Tavern | Carthage NY – Facebook
Bar and Grill. Full bar menu. Dine in or take out. Live music on weekends. Restaurant · $ · (315) 493-0304. . Follow. Details.
Order Whistle Stop Tavern – Carthage, NY Menu … – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Whistle Stop Tavern at 33926 State Route 3 in Carthage. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Whistle Stop Tavern – 3, Carthage, NY, 13619 – MapQuest
Whistle Stop Tavern is a cozy establishment nestled in the heart of Carthage, NY, offering a welcoming atmosphere for locals and visitors alike.
Reviews
Jesse Reinhold
Stopped in for a burger, learned this place is set up similar to a dive. You will seat yourself, there really aren’t any tables, 1 or 2, bur the bar is the main seating area. The burgers were good concepts but still middle of the road, they didnt knock my socks off, but I still enjoyed them. I got the king burger, medium, with onion rings. I was told by the locals that the wings were really what make this place shine not the burgers so when I go back that will be the next play. Also there really weren’t any menus just about, you will have to ask or just look before you go. Decent beer selection and they have darts if you’re into that.
… moreAnthony Cerone
I ordered through DoorDash for pickup and I definitely was disappointed the pizza was undercooked and the nachos weren’t great cold and missing toppings the biggest issue I have here is the pizza how do you undercook a pizza by over 10 minutes WHENEVER YOU COOK A PIZZA CHECK THE UNDERCARRIAGE it’s not rocket science I called and complained and they remade the order yes I’m grateful for that but honestly still wasn’t fully cooked the cheese wasn’t fully melted on the pizza and the undercarriage still wasn’t great I’ve had more than 1 instance like this and it’s aggravating because it’s such mistakes that shouldn’t be made just get a cook that knows how to cook or retrain them that’s probably best bet and I mean that respectfully it’s just ridiculous that you pay $40 for crappy food I would recommend just checking your food before leaving
… moreSelena Reyes
Food is cold, tasteless, they added beans as a substitution, didn’t have half of what was promised at the order. Lava cake is cold.
… moreCarol Swem
The King Burger was sooo good, also the Captain Nemo. Side of chips and queso
… moreBen Vallejo
Burgers, pizzas, wings.
For drinking and eating, prime location.
I expected the menu to look a little different with all the traffic they get but being its a bar that knows how to actually make what’s on the menu, it’s good.
… moreFor drinking and eating, prime location.
I expected the menu to look a little different with all the traffic they get but being its a bar that knows how to actually make what’s on the menu, it’s good.
Jazmin Garcia
Amazing wings and such a great atmosphere to be in with friends and to drink! Staff is always friendly!
… moreIrene White
We got the veal parmigiana tonight. It was amazing! The veal was so tender, and sauce was very flavorful. I highly recommend it.
… moreJohn N Gretchen Carson N Marston
Our First charity ride! We did 150 amazing miles
It was a beautiful day !!
… moreIt was a beautiful day !!
Sean Dardis
Friendly staff with fast service. Had The Classic Smash, and very glad I did, along with draft beer that tasted like it came from very clean lines. Friendly locals (staff and fellow customers alike) kindly greeted this out-of-town face and made for that much more of a nice experience. Will gladly drop in again next time I’m in the area.
… moreJason Pierce
We’ve tried many items off the menu and everything has always been delicious. Would highly recommend giving it a try if you haven’t.
… more