Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Classy chophouse with a sizable bar turning out steaks, seafood & martinis in an old-school setting.
Hours
| Sunday | 3–10 PM |
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4310 Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY 11558
Phone: (516) 432-5155
Website: https://www.jimmyhayssteakhouse.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Jimmy Hays Steakhouse Restaurant, A Traditional Steakhouse in …
4310 AUSTIN BLVD. ISLAND PARK, NY 11558. 516-432-5155 516-889-3766. GET SOCIAL …
Jimmy Hays Steakhouse | Island Park NY – Facebook
Jimmy Hays Steakhouse is celebrated for their unwavering support for the local community and their delectable dishes. With their incredible food and welcoming …
Jimmy Hays Steakhouse (@jimmyhayssteakhouse) · Island Park, NY
6265 Followers, 765 Following, 370 Posts – Jimmy Hays Steakhouse (@jimmyhayssteakhouse) on Instagram: “4310 Austin Blvd. Island Park, NY 11558.
Reviews
Mr T
Pretty nice place, was very impressed with how they greeted me, manager was very nice to me greeted me and said good night, and he gave me a big booth for just myself which made me feel valued, and I’m younger so it rarely happens when I go to high end places. The server was a little shy but he was very professional throughout my visit. Unfortunately they didn’t have many nonalcoholic options which I wasn’t thrilled with, however everything went smooth and the pacing of my food was perfect but they did rush me on dessert which I understood since it was almost 10:00 PM at the time. The calamari was pretty good overall, my steak was pretty good but a little rough, and my dessert was good, just could do without the nuts or whatever they put on it. A little pricy 160$ per person after tip without any drinks at all for all courses and a side of creamed spinach, but they did respect me and remained professional which I was pleased with, since I drove almost an hour to get to this place. Will come back again in future with family one day.
… moreJay Lucena
Jimmy Hays Steakhouse is truly exceptional.
From the moment we walked in, the staff made my family feel completely at home. Our server was outstanding—attentive, patient, and genuinely kind. They struck that perfect balance of professionalism and warmth, making sure we were comfortable without ever feeling rushed.
What really impressed me was how great they were with kids. They went out of their way to make my little ones feel included and relaxed, which made the entire experience even more enjoyable. The atmosphere is inviting, the service is top‑tier, and the food speaks for itself—everything was cooked perfectly and served with care.
Jimmy Hays is the kind of place that turns a simple dinner into a memorable night. An amazing experience all around.
Starting at the Valet and coat check all they through the Maitre D and The Server definitely coming back they handle my big sometimes loud family with a baby perfectly A must.
… moreFrom the moment we walked in, the staff made my family feel completely at home. Our server was outstanding—attentive, patient, and genuinely kind. They struck that perfect balance of professionalism and warmth, making sure we were comfortable without ever feeling rushed.
What really impressed me was how great they were with kids. They went out of their way to make my little ones feel included and relaxed, which made the entire experience even more enjoyable. The atmosphere is inviting, the service is top‑tier, and the food speaks for itself—everything was cooked perfectly and served with care.
Jimmy Hays is the kind of place that turns a simple dinner into a memorable night. An amazing experience all around.
Starting at the Valet and coat check all they through the Maitre D and The Server definitely coming back they handle my big sometimes loud family with a baby perfectly A must.
Tommie Gaston Jr
Excellent service!!! Excellent staffing!!!!! Chris was an awesome hostess, and Mr. Higgins was an amazing waiter. The crab and corn chowder was delicious and the lamb chops were cooked to perfection. My sister had the chicken salad with pork chops and she was truly amazed. The entire staffing was professional and courteous, I’m so happy I came here for dinner…thank you.
… morekorra dale
Excellent Brooklyn steak spot—Jimmy Hays delivers on quality and vibe! Food was strong: dry-aged ribeye perfectly charred, tender, and flavorful with great crust, lobster bisque rich and creamy, creamed spinach velvety, and truffle mac indulgent. Steaks cooked exactly to order.
Service was attentive and professional—great recommendations and timing. Atmosphere is classy and cozy—dim lighting, warm wood, upscale without being stuffy—ideal for date night or celebrations, though it can get buzzy when full.
Solid choice for a special steak dinner!
… moreService was attentive and professional—great recommendations and timing. Atmosphere is classy and cozy—dim lighting, warm wood, upscale without being stuffy—ideal for date night or celebrations, though it can get buzzy when full.
Solid choice for a special steak dinner!
Angelique Dos Santos
I just want to say that everything was amazing. I went yesterday with my family for my grandma’s 73rd birthday and she said it was the BEST birthday she’s had so far. The hospitality is top tier..as soon as we walked in the door, everyone was so nice, warm, and were all smiles. Food came quickly, food was hot. Literally nothing to complain about. This is now her favorite steak house. I want to thank the staff for making her day so special. 10/10 I do highly recommend
… moreMor
Place is great!
The only thing,
Appetizers – There is no big variety for people that not eating sea food.
But if you want really good hight quality steak,
And good sides- this place is highly recommend!!!
Service is great!
… moreThe only thing,
Appetizers – There is no big variety for people that not eating sea food.
But if you want really good hight quality steak,
And good sides- this place is highly recommend!!!
Service is great!
Paul Oliveri
This is a double review. Most importantly, don’t go on a Friday or Saturday night. I believe the less busy the greater the attention. So last night 12/19, was my birthday dinner. I ordered the 14oz ribeye. Without exaggerating it was at least 1/3 fat. I’m a steak eater so I know a good ribeye has nice fat marbling, but for $95 I cut off $30 worth. When I showed the waiter he blew it off by saying “well, that’s a ribeye”. I ordered it medium because of our last experience. Now I said a double review because we were there 2 weeks prior as invited guests. My wife and I shared the bone in ribeye for 2. I like medium rare and my wife likes medium. The waiter said he could do both in one steak. I never heard of this being done. Of course it came rare and medium rare. So since we were guests we tried to enjoy it. Back to last night. So I ordered mine medium thinking it’ll hopefully come medium rare, which it did. My wife had a shrimp dish which she enjoyed. Now here’s why I gave 2 stars for service. We wanted to enjoy our drinks before ordering. I expressed this to the matre’d as well as the waiter. He told us he’d take the order but wouldn’t put it in until we were ready. So we said ok. But of course before being 1/2 way thru with our drinks they delivered our appetizers and 15 minutes after that our entres. As usual, the bread came during our drinks and the crumbs were all over the table throughout the meal. As a New Yorker and a steak eater, I’ve been to the best steak houses. I NEVER had this experience where I had to OVER ORDER my steak in hopes of it coming the way I like it. Wherever I went, if I ordered medium rare it came medium rare.
Lastly, the valet, is nuts. As we pulled up, we witnessed the valet parking a car in reverse going so fast it made us nervous. We expressed our concern and his reassurance was to say that he parks them all the same. To summarize, service was better on a weekday but the steak was equally bad on a Friday. So I always use the 3 strike rule. 2 strikes for the restaurant and 1 for the valet equals 3. Obviously, sorry but we won’t be back.
… moreLastly, the valet, is nuts. As we pulled up, we witnessed the valet parking a car in reverse going so fast it made us nervous. We expressed our concern and his reassurance was to say that he parks them all the same. To summarize, service was better on a weekday but the steak was equally bad on a Friday. So I always use the 3 strike rule. 2 strikes for the restaurant and 1 for the valet equals 3. Obviously, sorry but we won’t be back.
Elaine Edelstein
Went for the 1st time, wonderful experience! The food ,the service ,our waiter Andres, even getting a chance to speak with Jimmy Hays, and the connection of the restaurant of my childhood-McClusky’s seen on menu ,and explained the family connection! It was a wonderful experience from the minute we walked in ! Quality of the food and genuineness.
… moreZack T
Can never go wrong at Jimmy Hays, No matter what steak you choose you cannot go wrong , every steak they make is absolutely amazing . The Gorgonzola bread is by far the best G bread out there. Side dishes are delicious as well, I recommend the sautéed spinach. They have valet parking right when you pull up to the front
Door. Staff and service is very professional, this is a high end steak house. 10/10 recommend
… moreDoor. Staff and service is very professional, this is a high end steak house. 10/10 recommend
michael Vitelli
Booked Christmas Eve after MANY visits to this restaurant. Lobster bisque soup is good the younger woman seating people …. Not so good.. Anytime she seats us it seems we looked up and down with disgust than sat in the worst seat in the place.. The rude manners from the younger woman in the front is unprofessional and made my date feel uncomfortable on many occasions. We will NT be returning based on our past experiences with this person.
… more