4.4 – 150 reviews • Deli
Local Italian Deli with a café specializing in gourmet sandwiches with the finest most trusted Boars Head meats and cheeses, that can also be brought by the pound, we have a large selection of Homemade salads and the very best bread from Brooklyn delivered 3 times a week, we have our homemade cheesecake, freshly filled cannolis made fresh to order A large selection of Italian cookies, , pastas you can’t find anywhere else,
We’re also happy to introduce our pizza & Italian specialties in our new addition,
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
Menu Photos
sarabellasdeli.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Ali Kefeli
Beautifully toasted New Yorker. Inside of the bread taken off. Sesame seeds on bread. Great service, smiling people. Good music, pizza smells throughout. Hidden gem we didn’t know about. They get my prized 5 stars. Recommended.
… morePaula Nardone
Been in SC for 3 months, from NYC. Sarabellas has the best, most authentic NY pizza. Their staff is so friendly and helpful. Had square, regular and grandma slice, as well as took home some food from their deli. Everything was so fresh and delicious. Fresh cannoli as you order…unbelievable!!! Can’t wait for next trip into North Myrtle to have their food again. NY pizza at its best. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED!!!
… moreOne Salty Beach
Went in early and had a full selection of slices ready . Friendly quick service , fairly priced and a great slice .
Had a cheese and reminded me of LI / NY pizzeria . Had the grandma to which was tasty and filling .
Will be back to get a whole pie or to just sneak a couple in while out and about .
Tried Anto’s in Conway and was impressed – Sarabella’s was just as impressive . Glad they are here .
… moreTraci Clark
Great deli!!! Meat is sliced specifically for your order. Crab and shrimp salad was very good with huge shrimp! Tiramisu was out of this world!!!
… moreAmber McCormick
This place popped up on my FB feed from Myrtle Vegas so we thought we’d give it a try. It did not disappoint! Ready made pizza by the slice or order from the menu. So many options to choose from plus a huge selection of desserts. Can’t wait to go back and try something else.
… moreEvan Rowlinson
This place is pure class. Didn’t know what to expect from an Italian deli in Myrtle Beach, but this place is a true NYC/Italian deli. Got the Spicy Italian on a roll and macaroni salad. Mac Salad was phenomenal. 5/5 would recommend to anyone looking for a sandwich in Myrtle.
… moreLaura Belles
I’m so glad I found Sarabella’s. I used to travel to Long Island often for work and have really missed the amazing Italian deli that I always visited. I’ll be back often and hope to edit this review from 4 stars to 5 stars. For my first visit I got the Italian Hero. It was delicious but extremely cold. I mean really really cold. I loved the bread and the flavor was perfect. If it had been a takeout order, I’m sure the temperature would have been fine by the time I got home. Maybe next time I’ll request it to be toasted. The employees were all very friendly and the service was great. The place was immaculate. Can’t wait to return and try the pizza and some of the take home meals.
… moreKaren Kroneberger
Ok so we’ve been getting Publix cold cut sub which isn’t bad But, googled last night best Italian Cold Cut in north Myrtle Beach and Sarabella’s came up, read the reviews and even read where the macaroni salad was good and have not found that in the 11 yrs we have been down here. We are originally from Md but that really doesn’t matter anyway I got the Italian Cold Cut sub on a delicious seeded roll and some macaroni salad which both were absolutely delicious! I believe this the best I have ever had even from up north! Anyway I don’t usually leave reviews but when you finally find something that hits all the marks I just had to share!!!!
… moreCynthia LaFleur
I love Sarabella’s for the deli/pizza, but my catering experience was not great. I stopped in days ahead of time to order a full tray as recommended based on our servings the Orichetta/sausage/Broccoli Rabe. I also ordered a half tray of stuffed shells. I was told that my original pick up time the deli would be closed but they could help me in the pizzeria. I stopped in 15 minutes before the “deli” close, and was told, I thought you were going to be here 45 minutes later? No worries, still going with it…I took the shells home, “which just needed to be warmed”. The shells were completely frozen, and nothing that could be served as planned.
So, still going with flow, agreed to come back 1/2 hr. later for the Orichetta/sausage/broccoli. The dish was cold because the pasta had to be cooled down, and the sausage was nothing like
I had ever had in this dish; chunks of
what resembled kielbasa…at least the broccoli rabe was genuine! In a pinch, with a house full of Thanksgiving
company, I nuked it before serving, added olive oil to make it marginally edible. We ended up throwing most of it out. Extremely disappointing.
… moreDawn Guillemette
After walking the dog we stopped in for lunch. We ordered the Italian Sandwiches and ate at their tables outside with our dog. The staff were ultra friendly and the food was AMAZING!!! This little gem has everything you could want for a delicious Italian meal and they prepare everything for you! It’s perfect!
We’ll definitely be stopping by again!
… more … View more