A.g. Kabat
Great bagels and bagel sandwiches. There was a line but goes fast. A little bit of outdoor seating. They had coffee that was hot but nothing special. I highly recommend for a good bagel. I had the everything with the garlic herb and it was loaded with fresh dill- amazing! Everyone in the family was happy with their combinations. There are not too many great bagels around here there are top notch!!
… morePhil Rowe
Great little bagel shop, fresh bread, local garlic and some other tasty treats.
Would definitely recommend.
10 of 10. No notes.
… moreEmily Showers
Nothing else to say besides this is one of my favorite bakeries I’ve ever been to. And like it or not, the demand shows others have caught on too! Aka make time to get there early on weekends before they sell out! Even if the bagels are out, everything is simply delicious—from the bread to the sandwiches to the cookies, even the pre-made lattes! Always make a stop, or two, to Cultured when I’m in Door County and you’d be a fool not to too.
… moreKarlie Groves
A great breakfast spot! Don’t be intimidated by the line, it moves quick!
You can tell these people know how to make bread. Sandwiches, bagels, cream cheese, and loaves available. A bit of seating inside and out. Can’t wait to come back!
… moreSrah Denk
It feels sacrilegious to not buy bread when visiting cultured, but dang does Mattea and the crew make good food. The bowl they have is my favorite bite after a long hike! Bread, bowls, bagels, kimchi- the things she creates are so thoughtfully and well made.
… moreEric Aune
Best bagels west of NYC? Probably! Fantastic sourdough too.
Friendly, hustling staff were eager to help with menu suggestions and quick service.
The bagels and cream cheeses are so fresh and flavorful you’d swear they were made to order. Wow, worth a stop! Get there early for the best chance at all the daily baked goods.
… moreMichele Westphall
Soo happy they are open on off season. The inside was cozy and the staff helpful.
The sweet bagel seemed too pretty to eat.. but it went down well.
The Foccaia was used for our dinner and also turned into eggs in a basket for tomorrow breakfast.
L9ve it all
… moreZoe
10/10 no notes, Cultured is doing an incredible job. Everything we got was delicious, the bakery is super cute, and in a solid location right outside downtown Sister Bay. Loved the open faced bagel sandwiches – hard to find a good bagel in Wisconsin. Cultured nails it!
… moreSusan Collins
Wonderful small business. The service and prices are great. They offer fantastic bread, bagels, and coffee. We got the olive parmesan focaccia bread. YUM!
… moreKelsey Weddig
I come to Cultured EVERY time I come to visit home from New York! Their kitchen is hustling day in and day out, and they keep the atmosphere lively. I love that they switch up menu options, so it’s like a surprise every time I go. I don’t know what’s in the chocolate chip cookies, but GOD they are some of the best I’ve had.
As a local, seeing a small business boom up here is what we all want, even if it means going and running out of food at times. It happens, and we never go down the route of positing bad reviews to degrade the business. It’s BUSY up here! For people visiting busy Door County… expect it to be busier than you think and plan ahead. That’s what trip planning is for, after all
Thanks team for the amazing eats and being a focal point in the community!
… more