Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Located in the beach community of Surf City/Topsail Island, NC this family owed pizzeria and wine bar will impress your taste buds! The Renna Family moved from Long Island, NY in 2019 where they owned a famous pizzeria in the Hamptons for 25 years. Whether you dine in or take out from Margherita Pizza Co, you will feel like you are apart of their family. Locals and vacationers alike will enjoy exceptional wood-fired pizzas, salads, and desserts made of fresh and healthy ingredients along with high end wine and beer collections. Stop by and say Ciao!!! Please double check our website for hours of operation – MargheritaPizzaCo
Address and Contact Information
Address: 112 Charlie Medlin Dr Unit A, Surf City, NC 28445
Phone: (910) 803-2253
Website: http://www.margheritapizzaco.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home | Margherita Pizza Co| Wine Bar|Wood Fire| GF| Salads …
Margherita Pizza Co is a family owned business with Homemade pizza dough … Welcome to Margherita Pizza Co * Surf City, NC You are about to meet a new …
Margherita Pizza Co. | Surf City NC – Facebook
Margherita Pizza Co., Surf City. 1182 likes · 4 talking about this · 170 were here. Wood-Fired Pizza, Salads, Desserts, Wine, Beer, GF, Healthier…
Margherita Pizza Co
Located in Triton Village Shopping Center in Surf City, this family owned pizzeria and wine bar will impress your taste buds!
Reviews
Steve Grenier
Upscale and elegant atmosphere, perfect for the concept of high end wood fired pizza and wine bar. Service and food taste were good with some different options you don’t see at a typical pizza place, like the vodka sauce pizza and white 4 cheese pizza. The flagship margherita pizza was basic compared to these full of flavor options. Also, the Tiramisu was fantastic!
This was exactly as advertised even if a little overpriced and we got what we expected, almost.
Our table of 4 ordered 4 pizzas and they were warm not hot. It was pretty disappointing to see so many staff yet the pizza wasn’t hot. The taste almost made up for it but there is a difference when pizza cools down. It became soggy and the crust harder to chew. Not sure why it came out like that since it wasn’t that busy.
Also, we split checks and a glass of wine was on the wrong check. And it was not the wine that was ordered. So it took 3 tries to get it corrected. The server was nice enough but still just a hassle.
If the pizza wasn’t served hot and we didn’t have the check mix up, would be a 5 star for me!
… moreThis was exactly as advertised even if a little overpriced and we got what we expected, almost.
Our table of 4 ordered 4 pizzas and they were warm not hot. It was pretty disappointing to see so many staff yet the pizza wasn’t hot. The taste almost made up for it but there is a difference when pizza cools down. It became soggy and the crust harder to chew. Not sure why it came out like that since it wasn’t that busy.
Also, we split checks and a glass of wine was on the wrong check. And it was not the wine that was ordered. So it took 3 tries to get it corrected. The server was nice enough but still just a hassle.
If the pizza wasn’t served hot and we didn’t have the check mix up, would be a 5 star for me!
Randy Tomblin
Got to sit at the chefs pass and speak with Lorenzo while he was tossing dough. Extremely kind family, great atmosphere, and delightful food. We are very excited to come back and try more. The Puttanesca Pizza & Margherita (neither pictured because we devoured them too quickly) were great. Extremely fresh and quality ingredients, even higher quality people!
… moreT Tan
We had takeout from Margherita Pizza. Our first time. We weren’t able to place an order by phone so had to drive to the location. Our order was Lorenzo’s famous garlic bread, San Gennaro pizza, plain cheese pizza (NY Style), Pure Leaf sweet tea and cannoli. While waiting, I realized it was a good thing we showed up to place the order. The restaurant was so noisy that the server wouldn’t have been able to hear me. The garlic bread was good. The plain cheese pizza could be a little lower in price since it had no toppings. The San Gennaro didn’t have any onions or peppers. I could taste the sausages but didn’t see any. Don’t get me wrong. It was spicy and had flavor, but lacking in ingredients. Overall, the order was tasty but overpriced. Since they have a website, they could set up an online ordering system. I do not recommend placing any order by phone.
… morejoe amigo
I’ve been to this place maybe 10 times over the years, but no more. Unfortunely, I got take out. If I had seen the pizza prior to getting home (8 miles away), I would have sent it back. It was almost tasteless with little or no toppings. A picture is worth a 1000 words. First picture below is what I ordered from menu, and second is what I found when I opened the box at home. There was no resemblance. I won’t be back. It was a small pricey pizza to begin with.
In response to owner
Your statement proves my point. The pizza I got had no resemblance to what I ordered. I stand by everything I said .So, how many days of receipts did you check…ie, you claim no such orders.Assuming I came last night, is it possible whoever took my order wrote it down wrong or misunderstood me, again since you claim no such order. It’s pretty sad you think there exists an ulterior motive here. You could easily have said “perhaps there was a mixup with the order” as opposed to attacking me for my honesty and trying to degrade me.
And Thomas A goes by nickname Joe Amigo
… moreIn response to owner
Your statement proves my point. The pizza I got had no resemblance to what I ordered. I stand by everything I said .So, how many days of receipts did you check…ie, you claim no such orders.Assuming I came last night, is it possible whoever took my order wrote it down wrong or misunderstood me, again since you claim no such order. It’s pretty sad you think there exists an ulterior motive here. You could easily have said “perhaps there was a mixup with the order” as opposed to attacking me for my honesty and trying to degrade me.
And Thomas A goes by nickname Joe Amigo
Ken W
Delicious thin-crust pizza but a little skimpy on the toppings for a $21 individual sized pie each. Just under $100 with two glasses of wine and a split Caesar salad and tip. Not recommended for folks on a budget.
… moreAbi Turner (Buzbuz9)
The pizza was yummy and they had good unique pizzas. The crust was super yummy and we enjoyed everything we had. They also had good tiramisu.
… moreDiane Veneziale
We came here on date night and it was a great experience. We sat at the bar with a clear view of the wood oven to watch the cooks. My husband ordered an Italian beer and I ordered a sangria. We enjoyed our drinks! One of the best sangrias I have had, included cut up strawberries and grapefruit.
For an appetizer, we ordered Diane’s Chicken Meatballs, it was melt in your mouth delicious! The sauce and cheese were a great addition to the juicy meatballs. We also ordered a Caesar Salad, it was so large, could feed 3 people. It was a good quality cheese and croutons. It did not too much dressing.
We both ordered personal pizzas, queen margarita and NY cheese with mushrooms added. This is the best pizza I have had in this area by far! It’s thin crust, wood oven cooked to perfection.
For dessert, we split the cheesecake with Caramel drizzle on top with whipped cream. It was so good and melt in your mouth!
Our waitress was friendly and took our order and checked on us at the right time. She was pleasant with each request we had, extra side of sauce, extra plates, and a box to go with leftovers. She was smiling and professional.
I would highly recommend! Great atmosphere, great food, great service!
… moreFor an appetizer, we ordered Diane’s Chicken Meatballs, it was melt in your mouth delicious! The sauce and cheese were a great addition to the juicy meatballs. We also ordered a Caesar Salad, it was so large, could feed 3 people. It was a good quality cheese and croutons. It did not too much dressing.
We both ordered personal pizzas, queen margarita and NY cheese with mushrooms added. This is the best pizza I have had in this area by far! It’s thin crust, wood oven cooked to perfection.
For dessert, we split the cheesecake with Caramel drizzle on top with whipped cream. It was so good and melt in your mouth!
Our waitress was friendly and took our order and checked on us at the right time. She was pleasant with each request we had, extra side of sauce, extra plates, and a box to go with leftovers. She was smiling and professional.
I would highly recommend! Great atmosphere, great food, great service!
Emma
Everytime I come here I get the BEST food and the absolute best service! My favorites are the white pizza, the eggplant pizza and the meatballs app. Sitting at the pizza bar is the best spot.
… moreeric svenson
Really good Neapolitan pizza. High quality ingredients and San Marzano tomatoes. Crust is perfect and holds up when you pick up a slice. A gem in surf city NC!
… moreSean Smith
Rare you get NY pizza taste in NC, one of the best if not the best pizza I’ve had since I’ve been in NC. Lived in NC for almost 20 years, from NY man this hit the spot. Packed on a Friday night but the service was great, thanks Meghan D .
… more