Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: MAYFAIR SHOPPING CENTER, 20-2020 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725
Phone: (631) 670-6479
Website: https://www.mayfairbagelcafe.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bagel Toasterie
… MAYFAIR BAGEL CAFE 20-2020 Jericho Turnpike, MAYFAIR SHOPPING CENTER Commack, New York 11725 (631) 670-6479 · [email protected] · Get directions. Monday.
Mayfair Bagels | Commack NY – Facebook
Mayfair Bagels, Commack. 100 likes · 110 were here. Bagel Boss in Mayfair shopping center is proud to announce the opening of Mayfair Bagels. Come in to…
Up Close: Mayfair Bagels | ET Week Media Group
A family-run shop bringing hand-rolled charm—and community spirit—to every bite … Mayfair Shopping Center 20-2020 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY …
Reviews
Dogan Kumova
“I definitely recommend Mayfair Bagel Cafe! It’s one of the best bagel spots in Commack. Everything is incredibly fresh and delicious. The place is spotless and the atmosphere is very welcoming.
The staff is especially friendly and their attention to customers is truly commendable. One customer mentioned the service from an employee named Ken, noting that he went out of his way to make sure their order was perfect and made them feel at home. It’s also known that the founders, Rose and Jay, prepare every order with the same care they would for their own family.
Mayfair Bagel Cafe stands out not only for its great food but also for its warm and hospitable environment. Customers often say things like ‘The food is incredible, the service is amazing.’
With its friendly staff, fresh products, and cleanliness, this is definitely a place you have to visit.”
… moreThe staff is especially friendly and their attention to customers is truly commendable. One customer mentioned the service from an employee named Ken, noting that he went out of his way to make sure their order was perfect and made them feel at home. It’s also known that the founders, Rose and Jay, prepare every order with the same care they would for their own family.
Mayfair Bagel Cafe stands out not only for its great food but also for its warm and hospitable environment. Customers often say things like ‘The food is incredible, the service is amazing.’
With its friendly staff, fresh products, and cleanliness, this is definitely a place you have to visit.”
Theuniverseismelanin
Great location, clean and well stocked. Bagels were fresh and soft. Prices need some work. Pack of hash brown Patties are less than $4 in the supermarket for a pack of 8 or 10. So charging $1.99 for one I would say is unreasonable. Staff was very nice and receptive. Lots of potential for this place. I would go back again to see what has changed with prices, but until then princess deli it is.
… moreEmilia Goncales
I definitely recommend it to everyone, the store is so clean and food is amazing ! Noor is absolutely amazing too! She’s always so sweet, hardworking, and full of positive energy. No matter how busy it gets, she stays kind and helpful to everyone. You can tell she really loves what she does — she’s the heart of this place! Thank you, I think this store will be my sec home now
… moreJOSEPH P.
Very good quality bagels with generous amounts of toppings/seasoning. The Bagel has a nice crunch on the outside while being soft on the inside. Cream cheese was very fresh. We purchased vegetable and plain. Plenty of variety and friendly service
… moreWilliam O
Big improvement over the bagel toastery. I don’t know what they change. Food seems to be better. Service is great. It’s very clean. I hope they survive here
… moreDevin Ulingadi
bro, this joint sucks… ordered from here with expectations that it’d be the same food and customer service quality as the farmingville location, but it straight up wasn’t.
i legit said soft bacon and a toasted roll, and went home and opened up burnt bacon and an untoasted roll
GO TO THE FARMINGVILLE LOCATION!!!!
you won’t regret it.
… morei legit said soft bacon and a toasted roll, and went home and opened up burnt bacon and an untoasted roll
GO TO THE FARMINGVILLE LOCATION!!!!
you won’t regret it.
Tufan K
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5-Star Featured Review: Mayfair Bagel Café
Our family visited Mayfair Bagel Café this past Sunday morning for a quick breakfast, and it turned into the perfect start to our day. The café is bright, inviting, and impeccably clean—exactly what you hope to find on a weekend morning.
Service & Atmosphere
Rose, the owner, is outstanding. She personally greets customers, oversees the kitchen, and pays attention to every detail. You can feel her dedication to quality and hospitality from the moment you walk in.
Food Highlights
• Bagels: Large selection, always fresh. Warm bagels come out every hour, which makes such a difference.
• Omelet: Fresh greens, cooked to perfection, light yet flavorful.
• Pancakes: Our kids loved them—fluffy, golden, and with a true homemade taste.
• Muffins: Rose surprised us with homemade muffins, a thoughtful touch that made our morning even sweeter.
Why We Loved It
• Impeccably clean and organized
• Friendly, hands-on owner who truly cares
• Fresh, high-quality ingredients
• Warm bagels served hourly
• Perfect place for a cozy family breakfast
Final Thoughts
Mayfair Bagel Café is more than just a breakfast stop—it’s a weekend ritual waiting to happen. We left full, happy, and already planning our next visit. Thank you, Rose, for making our Sunday morning so special!
⸻
… moreOur family visited Mayfair Bagel Café this past Sunday morning for a quick breakfast, and it turned into the perfect start to our day. The café is bright, inviting, and impeccably clean—exactly what you hope to find on a weekend morning.
Service & Atmosphere
Rose, the owner, is outstanding. She personally greets customers, oversees the kitchen, and pays attention to every detail. You can feel her dedication to quality and hospitality from the moment you walk in.
Food Highlights
• Bagels: Large selection, always fresh. Warm bagels come out every hour, which makes such a difference.
• Omelet: Fresh greens, cooked to perfection, light yet flavorful.
• Pancakes: Our kids loved them—fluffy, golden, and with a true homemade taste.
• Muffins: Rose surprised us with homemade muffins, a thoughtful touch that made our morning even sweeter.
Why We Loved It
• Impeccably clean and organized
• Friendly, hands-on owner who truly cares
• Fresh, high-quality ingredients
• Warm bagels served hourly
• Perfect place for a cozy family breakfast
Final Thoughts
Mayfair Bagel Café is more than just a breakfast stop—it’s a weekend ritual waiting to happen. We left full, happy, and already planning our next visit. Thank you, Rose, for making our Sunday morning so special!
⸻
Ryan Fox
23 dollars for two bacon egg and cheese on a roll and a buttered roll is crazy, food was decent but can’t justify these prices
… moreAntonis K.
Solid bagel shop, very clean, good atmosphere with nice radio playing overhead. Food is always prepared fresh and tastes delicious. 5 stars!
… moredaniel bene
Normally don’t complain about pricing because I understand that everything has gone up. But $10 for a hungry man that has one deli slice of ham. Exactly 2 strips of bacon and one sausage patty cut in half is absolutely ridiculous.
… more