Social Profile: 
![]()
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Your local Newcomerstown Subway® Restaurant at 578 N College St brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6 sandwiches, wraps, and salads, ordered quickly in the app or online, through convenient delivery, in-restaurant dining, or curbside pickup. We’re proud to offer a fresh alternative to typical fast food with fresh-cut veggies, tasty proteins, fresh-baked bread, and delicious cookies. We’re also here for your catering needs. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.
Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 578 N College St, Newcomerstown, OH 43832
Phone: (740) 498-8481
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
SUBWAY at 578 N College St Newcomerstown OH
Discover better for you sub sandwiches at SUBWAY 578 N College St in Newcomerstown OH. View our menu of sub sandwiches, see nutritional info, …
Subway Locations in Newcomerstown, OH| Subs, Sandwiches, Salads
Subway Locations in Newcomerstown 578 N College St We’re Open – Closes at 10:00 PM 578 N College St Newcomerstown, OH 43832
the Official website of the Village of Newcomerstown, Ohio – Subway
Address: 578 N. College Street Newcomerstown, OH 13832 ; Directions ; Phone Number: 740-498-8481 ; Categories: Places to Eat.
Reviews
Grandma Meg
Our son had unknowingly left his ID card there two weeks ago. He finally remembered that it might be there. Sure enough, they had put it safely away and had it ready for him when we arrived. Protein bowls and BMT sub were delicious as always… Thanks, to all of you at Newcomerstown Subway for taking good care of us!
… moreBill Taylor
Asked for 2 subs to be tosted and they were not and a pizza sub and meatballs sub is not tasty cold I also tried a bowl and everything was cold glad we were going home and had a microwave and they forgot to put it the chocolate chip cookie we love having the businesses in the area and appreciate the extra option but that’s 2 wrong orders in a row so it’s damonds subs from now on hopefully we will get a good sit down restaurant in town one day and hopefully subway will find people that take pride in their work I’m not saying don’t go there just double check and make sure that you have what you ordered
… moreKellieandLogan Givens
Did a online order through their app… order was supposed to be picked up and delivered at 610pm its now 820pm and im finally getting my order after the dasher contacted me, this is the 3rd damn time this has happened tried to give that subway benefit of the doubt they failed and if it is their system that is not communicating with dash they need to rethink about taking any orders on their app. This WILL be the LAST TIME i will order from the app…. not impressed and good luck trying to contact someone at the store they don’t answer… if i was the store manager i would be completely embarrassed and ashamed… try harder newcomerstown subway u just lost my business…
… moreJohna Richard
I ordered 2 dozen cookies on Friday and paid for them to be picked up on Saturday after 2. Got there. No one was there and the store was closed. I’m very upset. And I will be going to get my money back.
… moreAmanda Bissett
A little disappointed this time. One guy made all the subs while I was in there while everyone else just stood around. My disappointment comes from the quality of the cookies I bought. The raspberry cheesecake cookie is my absolute favorite but the cookies were so burnt I couldn’t eat them. Both the raspberry cheesecake and the new Reese piece’s cookies were burnt.
… moreChristina Patterson Jones
This subway is by far the best as far as quality made subs and all foods on menu ,it’s the cleanest, and fastest service place ,I usually go in the evening so kudos to the staff. 10 outta 10.anx and if you order a dozen of Oatmeal Raisin cookies you can ask for a little crispier cookies love it. Newcomerstown Ohio. #1.
… moreCMF Baker
We walked in when and were greeted by an older woman who decided her best way to spend her time was bossing around a younger kid who was already doing the work. She’d interrupt her to tell her to do what she was already doing. Then this woman proceeded to destroy the sandwich that I ordered completely ripping the bread all the way down the length of it and in multiple spots across wires. When I pointed it out she smuggly said what and continued rapping it. She was the worst mannered woman ever. We will never return to this location again.
… moreRolland Kerr
Ordered online. App said my sub was paid for and ready for pickup. Store claims they didn’t get my order. My bank shows Subway paid $6.99. Do NOT eat at this scam restaurant. I’m filing with the Better Business Bureau and every social media platform. All they had to do was make the sub I paid for.
… moreAnthony Russell
This subway used to have great employees but the dinner time employees I’ve had the last few visits have been terrible the girl could not focus or listen to anything that the customers have told her and the guy kept wandering around the store aimlessly the subs were messy and cold by the time they got around to putting toppings on them. Please do better.
… moreMountain Man
This location has some pretty great employees, but my complaint would be that the drink machine is often down for EXTENDED periods of time. This forces you to buy a bottled drink, and it costs more than the fountain drinks, and you get less. They could at least match the fountain drinks prices until they get the machine fixed considering I’m paying more for less by being forced the upcharge for an bottled drink with my meal. It’s not the first time this new machine has been down for a long period of time. At least make some sweet tea… How long does it take to fix a drink machine???? Come on, Mr. Owner. You’re charging enough in this town, how about taking care of things like this a little quicker?
UPDATE::: Over a month and a half later AND THE DRINK AND ICE MACHINE ARE STILL DOWN!!! POOR MANAGEMENT/OWNERSHIP.
… moreUPDATE::: Over a month and a half later AND THE DRINK AND ICE MACHINE ARE STILL DOWN!!! POOR MANAGEMENT/OWNERSHIP.