Address and Contact Information
Address: 40 Orange Turnpike, Sloatsburg, NY 10974
Phone: (845) 753-6438
Website: http://www.cooperstavernny.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Related Web Results
Cooper’s Tavern – Sloatsburg, Sloatsburg, NY
Welcome to Cooper’s Tavern, a place where Irish hospitality meets elevated pub fare. From hearty plates to perfectly poured pints, every visit is an …
Coopers Tavern Sloatsburg (@coopers_tavern_ny) – Instagram
5.5K+ followers · 78 posts · Gaelic – Craft- Gastropub Now Open for dinner 3pm daily 40 Orange Turnpike, Sloatsburg, NY open daily from 11.30 click bio link …
Cooper’s Tavern. | Toast
Cooper’s Tavern. 40 Orange Turnpike. Sloatsburg, NY 10974. Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant …
Reviews
Deb Clif
Locals, like me, have been anxiously waiting for Coopers to open up and it did not disappoint. They tastefully took our old hang out joint and turned it into an updated masterpiece.
We were a party of 13, and they were able to accommodate every need we had. We were WOWed by their amazing cocktails, and loved every bite of their food. We had almost everything, soups, salads, sandwiches, and entrees, with not one bad review from our party of 13.
Service was extraordinary, drinks and food came as it should, in a timely manner.
Can’t wait to hang out outside in the warmer months as they expanded and upgraded most of the outside area.
Complimentary valet parking was quick and needed as the weekends are busy.
My only question is will they bring back music?
… moreWe were a party of 13, and they were able to accommodate every need we had. We were WOWed by their amazing cocktails, and loved every bite of their food. We had almost everything, soups, salads, sandwiches, and entrees, with not one bad review from our party of 13.
Service was extraordinary, drinks and food came as it should, in a timely manner.
Can’t wait to hang out outside in the warmer months as they expanded and upgraded most of the outside area.
Complimentary valet parking was quick and needed as the weekends are busy.
My only question is will they bring back music?
Lux
Cooper’s Tavern—All Dressed Up With Nowhere to Go
Cooper’s Tavern occupies a massive 6,000-square-foot space near Harriman State Park, and from the moment you walk in, it’s clear someone spent serious money on the place. The atmosphere is polished, the space is impressive, and if you look hard enough, you might mistake it for the kind of Irish gastropub that actually delivers on the “gastro” part.
We started with the crispy Brussels sprouts, which were legitimately fantastic—easily the high point of the meal. Then things took a turn.
I ordered the CT Smash Burger with bacon, which was…fine. Above average at best, which is a generous way of saying it tasted like every other smash burger you’ve had in the last two years.
My family got the pan-seared salmon and the beef and Guinness pot pie. The salmon was mediocre at best—overcooked, under-seasoned, forgettable.
The pot pie was average, which in a place billing itself as elevated pub fare is basically a polite way of saying “why bother?”
Dessert was a chocolate lava cake that arrived looking photo-ready but tasting like it had been shipped in from a Sysco warehouse and microwaved with hope.
And the service? Let’s just say our server seemed personally offended that we showed up.
Here’s the thing: Cooper’s feels like someone did the math on Sloatsburg—large space, limited competition, captive audience near the park—and decided atmosphere would be enough to carry subpar execution. The bones are there. The location is solid. But when you’re charging gastropub prices and delivering Applebee’s-adjacent food with service that suggests the staff would rather be literally anywhere else, you’ve got a problem.
This place has all the ingredients to be excellent, but right now it feels like a cash grab aimed at people who don’t have better options nearby.
If they tighten up the kitchen, train the front-of-house, and start taking the “gastropub” label seriously, Cooper’s could be great. Until then?
Save your money and drive somewhere that actually cares.
… moreCooper’s Tavern occupies a massive 6,000-square-foot space near Harriman State Park, and from the moment you walk in, it’s clear someone spent serious money on the place. The atmosphere is polished, the space is impressive, and if you look hard enough, you might mistake it for the kind of Irish gastropub that actually delivers on the “gastro” part.
We started with the crispy Brussels sprouts, which were legitimately fantastic—easily the high point of the meal. Then things took a turn.
I ordered the CT Smash Burger with bacon, which was…fine. Above average at best, which is a generous way of saying it tasted like every other smash burger you’ve had in the last two years.
My family got the pan-seared salmon and the beef and Guinness pot pie. The salmon was mediocre at best—overcooked, under-seasoned, forgettable.
The pot pie was average, which in a place billing itself as elevated pub fare is basically a polite way of saying “why bother?”
Dessert was a chocolate lava cake that arrived looking photo-ready but tasting like it had been shipped in from a Sysco warehouse and microwaved with hope.
And the service? Let’s just say our server seemed personally offended that we showed up.
Here’s the thing: Cooper’s feels like someone did the math on Sloatsburg—large space, limited competition, captive audience near the park—and decided atmosphere would be enough to carry subpar execution. The bones are there. The location is solid. But when you’re charging gastropub prices and delivering Applebee’s-adjacent food with service that suggests the staff would rather be literally anywhere else, you’ve got a problem.
This place has all the ingredients to be excellent, but right now it feels like a cash grab aimed at people who don’t have better options nearby.
If they tighten up the kitchen, train the front-of-house, and start taking the “gastropub” label seriously, Cooper’s could be great. Until then?
Save your money and drive somewhere that actually cares.
Justintimeforbrownies
Was iffy with the other reviews but went to see for myself . Staff was extremely attentive and nice . The food was really good ! Not the best French onion I’ve ever tasted but I’m spoiled by going out to eat consistently. Ordered the smash burger and fries 10/10 the taste was fantastic. Also had the French dip sliders and the spinach / artichoke dip which were both perfectly executed. Absolutely recommend.
… moreMC
Tonight was a soft opening. Smash burger & sweet potato fries were delicious. Buffalo wings were also very good. Tried the Old Fashioned & it was a bit too sweet for my liking. Overall, pretty good date night & I will be coming back.
… moreD Cruze
Such a good time! The food was delicious, service was amazing, loved the lighting and the atmosphere! Drinks were so good, and all of the food was delicious too— whether you get ramen, a burger, or just fries, it was all so good! Our server was soo nice, we all loved him! I didn’t catch his name but he did a great job and was very kind. All of the staff was so kind and came to check on us a lot. Valet on one side and normal parking on the other, the valets were super nice as well. I could go on and on about this place.. I highly recommend! Please go try it and support this new lovely place! Lowkey kind of expensive for my liking but a few cheaper options and also so worth it.
… moreJulie McGovern
Had the best experience here. Wings, French Onion Soup, and Chicken Pot Pie were incredible! I’m so impressed. The atmosphere was great and service was awesome!!!
… moretori may
My new favorite place!!! Cozy bar vibes with comfort food, great music, and great service! Love that they have valet too! Will be back again next Friday!!
… moreJohn H
We had a great experience at Coopers Tavern this past weekend. The food and drinks were delicious our waitress Kelsey was attentive and our food and drinks came out very fast! The pork belly bites and herders pie was my favorite. I also enjoyed the “Rhodes” roast pork hero. We will definitely be returning in the future!
… moreRob Owen
Twas a Tuesday night, and most places are dead. Not so with Cooper’s Tavern! Parking lot was half full when we arrived ~5:30ish, and only got busier (but not packed). VERY well staffed with smiling employees who clearly enjoy their jobs and are well looked after by the management. Both owners were wandering through the dining area(s) and bar, chatting up customers, etc. For a place that’s only been open a month, it’s a well oiled machine.
The food was superb, with the sole exception of the wings – good, but forgettable. The Spinach/Artichoke dip might be the best I’ve ever had, including the puffy-yet-crisp toast points. The crispy brussels sprouts were well seasoned but not at all greasy, and the flat bread pizzas were just extraordinary (highly recommend the Bee Sting!)
Beer selection is not bad, though I’d love to see a couple more ciders on tap – given the increasing availability of great local NY cidery’s, I’d expect to see something other than just Angry Orchard.
Prices overall were quite reasonable. Four strapping lads managed 5-6 rounds and beers and several rounds of shared plates, while still somehow managed to stay under $250!
Overall, Cooper’s is a locals joint that would encourage one to become, well, local…
… moreThe food was superb, with the sole exception of the wings – good, but forgettable. The Spinach/Artichoke dip might be the best I’ve ever had, including the puffy-yet-crisp toast points. The crispy brussels sprouts were well seasoned but not at all greasy, and the flat bread pizzas were just extraordinary (highly recommend the Bee Sting!)
Beer selection is not bad, though I’d love to see a couple more ciders on tap – given the increasing availability of great local NY cidery’s, I’d expect to see something other than just Angry Orchard.
Prices overall were quite reasonable. Four strapping lads managed 5-6 rounds and beers and several rounds of shared plates, while still somehow managed to stay under $250!
Overall, Cooper’s is a locals joint that would encourage one to become, well, local…
Berk
That pizza was awesome, and the waitress was super patient and courteous. We totally dug the cozy vibe and the changes they made to the place. Prices were fair, too.
… more