Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 103 NJ-71, Spring Lake, NJ 07762
Phone: (732) 359-7611
Website: https://www.bennyspizzanj.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Pizza Restaurant | Traditional Italian Food Spring Lake, NJ
Benny’s Pizza & Restaurant has been serving classic Italian dishes and pizza to residents and guests of Spring Lake, NJ and the surrounding shore towns for …
Benny’s Pizza – SPRING LAKE, NJ 07762 (Menu & Order Online)
Order Now. 0. Collapse Menu. Icon Legend. Icon Legend. Your cart is empty. Close Cart Checkout $0.00. Powered by Menufy © 2026.
Benny’s Pizza Spring Lake Heights, NJ | Pizza Restaurant & Delivery
Benny’s Pizza & Restaurant is an authentic pizzeria in Spring Lake Heights, NJ. Order a pizza or delicious traditional Italian dish for delivery, dine in, …
Reviews
Sarah
Bennys has always been a favorite of mine growing up as I have always been received with great service and even better amazing food but sad to say after my experience I will no longer be ordering from here. Went in to pick up an order and was received with nothing but hostility. I was just there trying to get some drinks pay for my order and leave but the workers gave me the dirtiest looks, looking at me and my boyfriend up and down like we don’t belong. Whatever I brush it off at least I was excited to enjoy my meal. I get home and open up my cheesesteak and why is there barely any meat at all. The flavor for the meat was good like always but no where near enough to enjoy, all I could taste was the bread and mountain of lettuce. They have really stinged out since the last time I ordered from here, sad to see what has become of the place and devastated to part ways with my childhood favorite restaurant. Hopefully with this review the owner puts effort into bringing this place back up like before.
… moreCash Dosby (hotswaphdd)
Great spot. One of my favorite lunch spots to stop in grab some slices and a root beer at. Like how they put out different pies daily. Their Detroit and Margherita and of course plain ate my favorites so far. Been going at least once every two weeks and always have a great lunch. Thanks Benny’s!
… moreBrooklyn Rentals
$15 for this. Barely any meat, onions, or peppers. Most bland cheesteak I ever had
… moreMelissa Aronsson
Have had Bennys a few times via door dash. Great food! I especially am a fan of the chicken Francaise with veggies mashed potatoes side salad and bread! Delicious and I think portioned enough for 2 if you also get the avocado salad! Yum!
… moreRobert Solano
Ordered linguini seafood FRA-DIAVOLO (DIABLO) damn it, so good, so taste. The best part, A NATIVE MEXICAN AS A COOK. I recommend this pizzzeria to all of you.
… moreSamantha Rubino
Two times in a row I’ve gotten extremely sick from this place. The first time I thought maybe just a coincidence. No. First time was penne with Alfredo sauce and grilled chicken. Deathly ill that night. Second time was their “specialty wrap” grilled chicken, mozz, spinach, and onions. Violently ill in shop rite 30 minutes after eating it. No coincidence. I’m thinking it’s the chicken, who knows. Beware !!!
… moreAmber M
Pizza by the slice mostly lived up to our expectations as New Yorkers! Good variety and very fair price! Staff was friendly and kind, we loved that they had homemade sodas and soda water too! Would definitely come again for beach lunch!
… moreChris Melino
Service was fast and easy very friendly. Pizza was tasty and cooked well, cheese fries with whizz little skimpy but ok. Would go back.
… moreRobert M.
We are staying at a B&B in Spring Lake and the front desk recommended Benny’s Pizza. Well let me tell you, they definitely were correct. We ordered dinner and the meals, mussels, garlic bread were excellent. It so good we went back for lunch the next day. The salads with grilled chicken was just as good. The Margareta pizza was outstanding. Wish they were closer to us in North Jersey.
… morePaige Chapman
We have been ordering from here for years now. Every. Single. Time…we are greeted with a smile and a thank you for being a customer. The food is delicious, made with all fresh ingredients at a very good price. You feel at home instantly where the owner makes you feel like family. I tell everyone how great Benny’s Pizza is. Don’t miss out.
… more