Social Profile: 
![]()
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Your local Bay Shore Subway® Restaurant at 1750 5th Ave brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6 sandwiches, wraps, and salads, ordered quickly in the app or online, through convenient delivery, in-restaurant dining, or curbside pickup. We’re proud to offer a fresh alternative to typical fast food with fresh-cut veggies, tasty proteins, fresh-baked bread, and delicious cookies. We’re also here for your catering needs. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.
Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Subway ® 39 Bay Shore Road
Discover better for you sub sandwiches at SUBWAY 39 Bay Shore Road in Bay Shore NY. View our menu of sub sandwiches, see nutritional info, find restaurants, …
Subway Locations in Bay Shore, NY| Subs, Sandwiches, Salads
1490 5th Ave Bay Shore , NY 11706 Westfield South Shore We’re Open – Closes at 9:00 PM 1701 Sunrise Hwy #Fc2/Food Court Bay Shore , NY 11706
SUBWAY at 1750 5th Ave Bay Shore NY
Your local Bay Shore Subway® Restaurant at 1750 5th Ave brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6″ …
Reviews
Nat
I went into this Subway, I come here about every two weeks and am known here. I get the same order every time and when I came in today, the manager (I believe) said someone had picked it up. I just got out of work and there is nobody else who would pick it up. Other than providing any support or resolution, she goes “it’s a big order, I will not redo it.” She continues with phrases like “it is not my problem.” She gave me such a problem in order for me to get the food I paid for when it was their mistake and they gave it to someone else, they should’ve been checking people who picked up have the order confirmation. I believe she only started making my order when they realized THEY had made a mistake. This is unacceptable and very rude considering I did not do anything wrong, and the manager handled it horribly. If I hadn’t been persistent, my problem would not have been solved nor would I have gotten a refund. Regardless of how I was treated, I still said thank you and have a good day, only to receive silence from the manager and a sorry from one of the employees (the only one trying to be kind and help.) I did not mind waiting for my order to be remade but the way it was handled was horrible. This situation caused others to leave the store after the staffs attitude, a customer even apologized on THEIR behalf. The staff needs to be trained on customer service, especially the manager. I will never come back to this Subway again.
Moral of the story: do not order online here unless you are willing to risk the order being given to someone else and having to fight for your food.
… moreMoral of the story: do not order online here unless you are willing to risk the order being given to someone else and having to fight for your food.
George Mikhaeil
Even though it was very late at night I got great and fast service and the sandwich tasted great especially because of the melted cheese which was so perfect. The only star I took off is because of the parking. Considering there’s many other stores with probably a lot of costumers each, the subway would only have around 3 or 4 spots so its a bit small.
… moreMarisa Turturro
I come to this Subway fairly often, but unfortunately my experiences with the staff are consistently negative. Every time I go in, the ladies behind the counter seem to have a very bad attitude. I’ve been met with eye-rolling, rudeness, and an overall unwelcoming vibe. The food is fine, but customer service really impacts the experience, and this location definitely needs improvement in that area.
… moreMarc Gatewood
I’ve been to this location multiple times, and unfortunately the customer service is consistently poor. The women working here always seem to have attitudes and come across as rude, which makes the experience uncomfortable. I’m always polite when ordering, but it doesn’t feel reciprocated.
… moreKai
this location has the absolute best tuna. the bread is always fresh. The 1 woman who is always working whenever I come in is always friendly, always has a smile and is a joy to be around. she always treats everyone with kindness.she is a very hard worker and deserves a promotion. I would absolutely recommend this location.
… moreFausto Collado
The ladies are always very attentive and professional. All equipment are always clean and when they prepare my food they are very hygienic.
… moreCynthia Amaya (‘The Angel’)
Main female worker “Sammy”always has a very poor attitude when. Especially with coupons! Everytime anyone is in line with coupons she has “comments and expressions” towards the other female worker and treats the customer a particular way.
Update 2years later- place is better kept and spanish female employee is sooo much nicer. She is very friendly and bread is fresh and sandwiches are made better and not as stingy as before.
This franchise should look into who they have “in charge” as from the reviews I’ve read … I’m not the only one.
One goes in to have lunch/dinner not to get looked, treated and judged a certain way.
Months ago I came here and the same worker yelled at the customer and was being very PARTICULAR on what she could put on her sandwich and told her bluntly she wasn’t welcomed there and could go to a different Subway. Very poor customer service on the evening.
I came here today just because it’s the closest one to my house and was not craving fast food…. If you have a choice … Go elsewhere
… moreUpdate 2years later- place is better kept and spanish female employee is sooo much nicer. She is very friendly and bread is fresh and sandwiches are made better and not as stingy as before.
This franchise should look into who they have “in charge” as from the reviews I’ve read … I’m not the only one.
One goes in to have lunch/dinner not to get looked, treated and judged a certain way.
Months ago I came here and the same worker yelled at the customer and was being very PARTICULAR on what she could put on her sandwich and told her bluntly she wasn’t welcomed there and could go to a different Subway. Very poor customer service on the evening.
I came here today just because it’s the closest one to my house and was not craving fast food…. If you have a choice … Go elsewhere
Tiffany
The ladies here are sweet and they know my order by heart. Every time I come here they already know what I want and they always make my sandwich heavy!! The place is clean and the ingredients are always fresh and clean!!!
… moreYusef
I do uber eats and usually get a lot of of orders from this particular subway around 9-10 and I must say they are always giving me the best costumer service their was this women and a boy and they always have the orders done before I even get there to pick it up and the environment is very good and peaceful.
… moreDylan
Very friendly with us we have been coming here for years now there quick and very attentive to what we need the two ladies who are always here are the best.
… more