Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Snug, easygoing seafood counter-serve with outdoor seating, offering crab cakes & lobster rolls.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 90775 Old Hwy Unit #6, Tavernier, FL 33070
Phone: (305) 440-3650
Website: http://whatthefishrolls.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
What The Fish Rolls – Rolls and more
90775 Old Highway Tavernier Unit #6 Monroe County, FL 33070 305.440.3650 … Florida Seasoning, Cocktail Sauce, Lemon Wedges Read More. Cruditos From The …
What The Fish Rolls & More | Tavernier FL – Facebook
Tacos, rolls, and ocean strolls Fresh fish tacos and crispy calamari rolls served with a sea breeze in the Florida Keys. Pull up, grab a bite, and let the …
What The Fish? Rolls and More – Florida Keys
What The Fish Rolls in Islamorada serves up fresh, local seafood with a creative twist, featuring hand-crafted rolls, tacos, and tropical flavors.
Reviews
Tegan Kendall
Amazing food! I had the lobster roll and my husband had the fish tacos, both were decently sized portions which tasted amazing. We went on New Year’s Eve and even though they were quite busy, the customer service was still amazing and we didn’t wait that long for our food. The owner/ manager? From Rome was very kind and helpful explaining the menu. Will definetly return here when I next visit the keys.
… moreRaphael Ortiz
If you’re looking for an amazing, well prepared lobster roll in the Florida Keys this is the place to go. Friendly service, casual, laid-back atmosphere and dockside tables. The lobster roll and the GRILLED calamari arugula salad are seafood bliss!! This “secret spot” is 10 out of 10.
… moreGreg Patronite
Passionate and friendly and
owner serving a great variety of fresh seafood rolls. Nice and roomy outdoor seating with the view of the boats in the waterway. A basic selection of beer and wine is also available. Great spot for a relaxing lunch.
… moreowner serving a great variety of fresh seafood rolls. Nice and roomy outdoor seating with the view of the boats in the waterway. A basic selection of beer and wine is also available. Great spot for a relaxing lunch.
Gigi Lopez
Fresh seafood! They literally walked to a fish market next door and pulled a live lobster for me. Everything is fantastic here. Even the tacos. Their calamari was also great. The breading wasn’t that thick bread you’re use to… more like a light dust of crispness that just makes their calamari and other fried options delicious.
… moreJeff Firestine
We have been coming to the Keys since 2021 and this is a must stop for our family. Alex is so friendly and the food is amazing! Shrimp roll is amazing and the lobster comes fresh from the market next door.
… moreJodie Andrews
This is such a nice place. Owner is lovely and the lobster roll is incredible. You pay a bit more here for the lobster but it is so worth it. Parking as well and a lovely deck.
… moreCedric Poupy
As a French person with high expectations when it comes to quality and originality, I was absolutely not disappointed. Both the welcome and the food were excellent—this was truly a wonderful experience that will satisfy even the most demanding guests. To top it off, the place itself is really charming.
… moreSarah Milnor Nipper
Service was great,place was clean. Our table had tacos with local fish , New England style rolls with local fish. Small little shaded eating area on the dock was perfect. Everyone enjoy their food but 1 person at our table felt the fish roll could of used something like onion and cilantro or a really seasoned sauce. We all shared a basket of fries and they were really good.
… moreChadandAmy Pfortmiller
Right next door to fresh fish market, so it has to be good. The fish plate and fish tacos with Mahi Mahi were excellent! Watched 5 manatee in the water next to our table. Just excellent.
… moreemma peña
A hidden gem in Islamorada that you simply can’t miss.
The food is absolutely spectacular — incredibly fresh fish prepared with a Caribbean touch that makes every bite unforgettable. We tried the ceviche, the catch of the day grilled to perfection, the lobster roll, and the fish fingers… everything was simply sublime!
The owner personally came to our table to recommend the daily catch and shared details about where each fish was sourced, which made the experience feel even more special.
The atmosphere is relaxed and charming, with wooden tables by the water, soft background music, and such warm, personal service that you truly feel at home.
Definitely a place we’ll return to — and one I highly recommend!
… moreThe food is absolutely spectacular — incredibly fresh fish prepared with a Caribbean touch that makes every bite unforgettable. We tried the ceviche, the catch of the day grilled to perfection, the lobster roll, and the fish fingers… everything was simply sublime!
The owner personally came to our table to recommend the daily catch and shared details about where each fish was sourced, which made the experience feel even more special.
The atmosphere is relaxed and charming, with wooden tables by the water, soft background music, and such warm, personal service that you truly feel at home.
Definitely a place we’ll return to — and one I highly recommend!