Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Jersey Mike’s, a fast-casual sub sandwich franchise with more than 2,500 locations open and under development nationwide, has a long history of community involvement and support. Started at the Jersey Shore in 1956, Jersey Mike’s serves authentic East Coast-style subs on fresh baked bread – the same recipe it started with over 60 years ago. The company’s mission is to bring its customers the highest quality, freshest made sub in the industry and give back to the communities in which it operates.
New Jersey–based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 340 New Castle Rd Suite 2, Butler, PA 16001
Phone: (724) 602-4114
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sub and Sandwich Shop in Butler, Pennsylvania – Jersey Mike’s
340 New Castle Rd Suite 2 Butler, PA 16001 An image of a telephone receiver (724) 602-4114 Store Hours: Open 7 Days: 10 AM – 9 PM
Jersey Mike’s Subs | Butler PA – Facebook
Jersey Mike’s Butler is open for pickup and delivery orders! Place an order for delivery or pickup through our app. Orders can also be placed through third …
Jersey Mike’s Subs – Menu
Mike’s Hot Italian. Ham, salami & pepperoni with melted provolone cheese. Topped with grilled onions, lettuce, tomato and Hot Chopped Pepper Relish.
Last Updates
Reviews
Logan Bish
Jersey Mike’s has one of the best subs I have ever had. They have a variety of options on their menu, and they even have gluten free!! They are so much more special than other sub shops because of their “mikes way” that they put on their cold subs. Whatever is in those juices makes me the happiest person ever. You can tell when you take your first bite that they use quality ingredients. The service is always great, considering how packed they usually are! So to round it off, don’t listen to the other bad reviews, because Jersey Mike’s is a great place to fill you up and brighten your day!!
… moreS Frankum
Beyond amazing, food is only 50% of the experience the other 50% is the dining experience. Kamren, Doug, Vanessa, Brendan, Kelsey, and Zach was all wonderful, professional, just overall an amazing staff and jersey mikes is truly lucky to have such a great crew representing them! I saw no one on their phones everyone was doing something important and nothing but a truly amazing experience they made me feel welcomed and thanked me for my order, updated me on my orders progress and even told me to drive safe on my way out, I saw nothing but smiles and professionalism! Truly can’t wait to go back to this location specifically!! I eat out very frequently and It was truly a pleasure to have this experience I’ve never had a better dining experience then tonight with them!!
… moreEric Lewis
Sandwiches are delicious but above that the staff is exceptional! Every single time we visit this Jersey Mikes, each staff member has a smile on their face and they genuinely seem happy to make subs for us. This type of customer service is so rare that I felt compelled to review the store online.
… moreCarson Bish
If you haven’t stepped into Jersey Mike’s yet, you’re missing out on a culinary masterpiece hiding in plain sight. I ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch, and let me tell you—it was nothing short of spectacular.
The chicken was tender and juicy, perfectly grilled to lock in that smoky flavor. The bacon added a savory crunch that balanced beautifully with the creamy, tangy ranch dressing. Every bite was layered with freshness, from the crisp lettuce to the warm, pillowy sub roll that held it all together like a work of art.
What really sets Jersey Mike’s apart is the experience. The staff greeted me with genuine smiles, the atmosphere was welcoming, and the sandwich was crafted with care as if they were serving it to family.
This isn’t just a sub—it’s a destination meal. If you’re local, do yourself a favor: skip the ordinary and flood through those doors. Your taste buds will thank you, and you’ll wonder why you didn’t come sooner.
… moreThe chicken was tender and juicy, perfectly grilled to lock in that smoky flavor. The bacon added a savory crunch that balanced beautifully with the creamy, tangy ranch dressing. Every bite was layered with freshness, from the crisp lettuce to the warm, pillowy sub roll that held it all together like a work of art.
What really sets Jersey Mike’s apart is the experience. The staff greeted me with genuine smiles, the atmosphere was welcoming, and the sandwich was crafted with care as if they were serving it to family.
This isn’t just a sub—it’s a destination meal. If you’re local, do yourself a favor: skip the ordinary and flood through those doors. Your taste buds will thank you, and you’ll wonder why you didn’t come sooner.
zakee arrasheed
THIS STORE STOLE MY MONEY!!
I ordered A Chicken cheesesteak with extra cheese, I did not see any cheese on my sandwich Nor did I taste any cheese on my Sandwich, But I paid for extra cheese!
The chicken steak Was Dryer than Ah Ginger Ale From Canada! I will never spend my money @ this location again , The entire night crew needs to be retrained or Terminated, I was highly Disappointed
… moreI ordered A Chicken cheesesteak with extra cheese, I did not see any cheese on my sandwich Nor did I taste any cheese on my Sandwich, But I paid for extra cheese!
The chicken steak Was Dryer than Ah Ginger Ale From Canada! I will never spend my money @ this location again , The entire night crew needs to be retrained or Terminated, I was highly Disappointed
Susan B
The Butler shop at Benevan Square is the best one we’ve been to! All the guys are friendly, and personable. The food is always fresh and the place is clean. We’ve been to several other shops that didn’t have the same atmosphere and friendly folks. We’d recommend this delicious grub to anyone!
… moreAmber B (#Detailz)
Our new favorite place to grab a bite in Butler! If you like fresh subs and sandwiches I highly recommend Jersey Mike’s.
Fresh cut meats and everything is made/cooked to order. Much better quality than Subway or Fire House.
We have ordered both cold and hot sandwiches and in different sizes, we have not been disappointed. Love the fact that you can get a mini, regular or giant size. A gaint size is easily shared between two people. The bread is always fresh, light, and airy.
Depending on how busy they are (during lunch or dinner rush), the orders can take a little while. Take into consideration that everything is cut and made to order. I personally have never waited too long for my order but I will gladly wait for good quality food. If you are in a rush and don’t have 10/15 minutes to wait for your food, maybe this isn’t the place for you.
The prices are fair but can be on the high end depending on what you order. I personally am glad pay for good quality/fresh food.
The staff has always been friendly and efficient during our visits. Always makes us feel welcomed and valued.
Lastly, we love the loyalty program. Because who doeant love free stuff?
… moreFresh cut meats and everything is made/cooked to order. Much better quality than Subway or Fire House.
We have ordered both cold and hot sandwiches and in different sizes, we have not been disappointed. Love the fact that you can get a mini, regular or giant size. A gaint size is easily shared between two people. The bread is always fresh, light, and airy.
Depending on how busy they are (during lunch or dinner rush), the orders can take a little while. Take into consideration that everything is cut and made to order. I personally have never waited too long for my order but I will gladly wait for good quality food. If you are in a rush and don’t have 10/15 minutes to wait for your food, maybe this isn’t the place for you.
The prices are fair but can be on the high end depending on what you order. I personally am glad pay for good quality/fresh food.
The staff has always been friendly and efficient during our visits. Always makes us feel welcomed and valued.
Lastly, we love the loyalty program. Because who doeant love free stuff?
Raymond
Less then impressed and I never got to the food.
3 for sure maybe 4 people working.
7 minutes standing in line listening to the only person who is not walking around trying to be invisible,
Talk to a guy who had ordered, looking at videos on the customer’s phone.
The place looks like it belongs on a back ally.
… more3 for sure maybe 4 people working.
7 minutes standing in line listening to the only person who is not walking around trying to be invisible,
Talk to a guy who had ordered, looking at videos on the customer’s phone.
The place looks like it belongs on a back ally.
Epicnoob dean
Great new sub shop super friendly staff!! Isaiah was our prep tonight and super awesome subs!!!!! Two regulars will feed a family of four easily. Will be back for sure!!
2024 update – have been back over and over the last two years and never disappointed. Staf stays friendly and energetic regardless of the time of day and everything is always clean and fresh. Great job everyone!!!
… more2024 update – have been back over and over the last two years and never disappointed. Staf stays friendly and energetic regardless of the time of day and everything is always clean and fresh. Great job everyone!!!
Megan Macurak
The two young employees who waited on us gave us wonderful customer service, so friendly. We were greeted when we came in and received prompt service plus the food was delicious!
… more