Aaron Fenrick
Had our wedding cake made here, it turned out way better than we could have imagined! Best Mexican Bakery hands down. We have been going here for years and will continue to! Thank You Very Much!
… moreLindsay T
This is my FAVORITE restaurant in all of Wisconsin. The pancakes have moved to the top of my charts. Especially the blueberry. We went everyday for 3 weeks while I was in town. I ordered the chicken and steak fajitas and a blueberry pancake everyday. The team there is all amazing I looked forward to seeing them every day. I love that they have coca cola products also. I cannot wait to get back there. Get there early they are only open until 2:30 every day.
… moreSarah Bennett
I asked for a vanilla cake with no filling and I had a picture of how I hoped it would look. In the picture we just wanted the bottom part. Well they did an amazing job making it look just like the picture and the cake tastes amazing. Thank you!
… moreJelena Predaina
Tasty pastries and moist tres leches cakes make this Mexican bakery one of my all-time favorites!! As a bonus, they are so reasonably priced that the average item is under $1! They have a variety of pastries, many filled with fruits like pineapple, that make for a great, quick breakfast or mid-day treat. They also offer donuts, croissants, and various rolls/breads. All that being said, their tres leches cakes are so good & moist with the fresh strawberry filling being my favorite! They also offer a variety of other fruit fillings including mixed fruit options. They have great hours but the selection can become thin so it’s best to arrive early while the baked goods are fresh out of the oven. I’ve always experienced friendly customer service here, plus they are generally very accommodating. I only found that a couple of our cake orders were not made with the exact filling or design discussed, but other than that I highly recommend it!
… moreStephanie
Poorly run business. Called to order a cake for our wedding. Spoke to the owner who advised me to text him some pics for ideas of how I wanted the cake to look. Never heard back from him. Tried to call them and was left on hold for 20 minutes. We ended up getting a cake from another bakery. The day of our wedding he calls me back to ask if I still need the cake…? Very unreliable
… moreRebecca Pierce
The cake looked amazing and tasted good but they did not give us a box to put it in to travel and did not say in advance there was no box
… moreBen Borgert
TL;DR: Perhaps I was just unlucky, but all the pastries I had were incredibly dry; like they had been sitting out for multiple days already and were mostly flavorless to boot. I took only ended up taking a single bit out of each pastry I purchased and tossed the rest because they were so bad. Really disappointing… at the very least avoid going here on a Sunday,
Experience:
Was in the area for vacation and had a serious urge for doughnuts and pastries before my very long drive home; saw the reviews for Jerry’s Bakery and got excited to satiate my sweet tooth. Boy was I in for disappointment.
Atmosphere/Storefront:
As you walk in you are surrounded by pastries of all kinds. Great selection, definitely something they have going for them. The bakery is self-serve so you grab a tray and some tongs and start grabbing what you want, but here in is the first challenge: knowing what your picking. There are NO labels on anything! No prices, no names of pastries or what fillings they may or may not have so if you aren’t super familiar with all pastry types, you’ll be doing some guessing.
Food:
I bought 6 different types of pastries to keep the drive home interesting and paid about $10 for all of it; not cheap, but perfectly reasonable for what was expecting to be some great pastries. Every single pastry was the worst version of that pastry I’ve ever had. None of them were particularly flavorful, and all of them (except the Churro) were so dry they crumbled when I tried to eat them, and the Churro was squishy and flavorless. Just an entire waste of money.
Service:
The woman at the checkout counter was perfectly pleasant, but being that this is a self-serve bakery, she was also the only experience with service so there’s not much to talk about.
Overall if I’m ever back in the area again, I’ll know to avoid Jerry’s Bakery.
… moreChris Gipson
Jerry’s has the best steak omelets in town. Very good breakfast and nice portion size. Highly recommend
… moreDebra Ryko
Great family restaurant, highly recommend their Door County Salad! Friendly staff Always great food and service! Support local! Also check out the fabulous bakery offering fresh breads, rolls, sandwich breads and fabulous selection of cookies made fresh! Friendly people, I highly recommend! Also yummy Tres Leche cakes!
… moreHelen M Bouhl
The sheer amount of pastries was overwhelming. The staff was very friendly. I explained to them that I thought they had to get up at 2 a.m. to make all the pastries they had. I also told them that I had never been there before. They were gracious enough to help me purchase everything.
… more