Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Holey Moley Bagel Shop is your go-to spot for classic and adventurous bagels, sandwiches, and breakfast. Located in the heart of Orange Park, Florida, this cozy and inviting bagel shop boasts an atmosphere that’s as vibrant as its menu. From traditional favorites to unique and creative bagel flavors, Holey Moley Bagel Shop is the perfect place to start your day or satisfy your lunchtime cravings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1177 Park Ave #14, Orange Park, FL 32073
Phone: (904) 375-0113
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
order.holeymoleyparkavenue.com
Related Web Results
Holey Moley Bagel Shop – Orange Park, FL 32073 (Menu & Order …
Online ordering menu for Holey Moley Bagel Shop. Holey Moley Bagel Shop (Park Ave) in Orange Park, FL, is a cozy spot serving up fresh, hand-rolled bagels …
Holey Moley Bagels
Order Online! You can now order directly on our website! Try it today! Order Now.
Holey Moley NY Bagels – Orange Park, Fl
Experience New York Bagels Now in Orange Park!
Last Updates
Reviews
Sheila Arismendi
Hands down best-tasting bagels in Jacksonville! The staff is super welcoming and the New York vibe just adds something special to the whole experience. Honestly 10/10 new favorite breakfast spot.
… moreMichelle Smith
I LOVE this place! I’ve always been curious about it so my husband and I decided to give it a try and I kid you not, I’ve been back almost every day since! The bacon egg and cheese on a poppy seed bagel has become my current hyper fixation meal. As a New Yorker, this is the closest I’ve come to finding a sandwich that reminds me of home. I believe it’s a local family run business and you can tell they’re passionate about what they do. The customer service is truly on point they’re always so kind and friendly. Thank you Josh and Leo!
… moreTani Brady
Holy delicious! Best bagel I’ve had in a long time. So fresh and big too. From the minute I walked in, I cld feel it was a good place …lovely friendly greeting, nice display case, and a great variety of specials. I had the poppy seed with sausage, egg & cheese w a coffee and a plain Asiago bagel to take home, for $12.50, they had a special on so he took off an additional $1.76. The team is so nice and you can see it’s paying off, whilst I was there, they had a constant stream of customers coming in… I was there at 10.30am on a Tuesday and it was v busy. We are lucky to have something this good in OP, my friend had told me about it for months – she was right it really is delicious!
… moreJ S
What a fantastic experience. They were able to customize & build me a delicious veggie sandwich. Definitely A+ overall.
… moreMargaret Meier
Josh was an amazing host at our recent visit for a business meeting. Will definitely return and highly recommend. Everything is so clean and pleasant. The food was delicious as was the coffee.
… moreLaura Shimer
The food was yummy. I have a gluten allergy but they made me bacon and eggs which was perfect. My wife enjoyed her NY bagel sandwich and the coffee … Yummy.
If they made GF bagels we would be in heaven.
… moreIf they made GF bagels we would be in heaven.
Ashley fuller
Absolutely AMAZING!!!! If you’re from the Jersey Philly area and love chopped cheese and pork roll this is the spot ! The service is amazing every thing is so fresh cooked to perfection!!! It’s like a little piece of home in Florida ! 5 stars all around great food great people great atmosphere!
… moreAnnie
The BEST bagels I’ve had in Florida yet! Store bagels are so hard to chew, but these ones are so soft, and the cream cheese is incredible! They have such good choices! We got several different kinds. Pizza Tuscan bagel with pesto cream cheese, jalapeño Asiago bagel with chives cream cheese, the rainbow with funfetti cream cheese, and the everything bagel with jalapeño cream cheese, and EVERYTHING was absolutely delicious!! And the owners are unbelievably kind! We will definitely be back!!
… moreTatyana Jones
I wanted to give this place a 5-star soooo bad but missing a topping that was paid for is less than ideal. The bagel was absolutely delicious and the service was phenomenal. I loved the ambiance. Definitely don’t regret anything about my experience here. My bagel was mistakenly made with cheddar instead of gouda which was fixed quickly and the worker even asked if I wanted to keep it. I only dropped the star when the new bagel came back without the lettuce I paid extra for but the cheese was correct! (They are a bit pricey I might add) I didn’t want to waste a second bagel though so I ate my meal and left. It was an honest mistake and I still would recommend this to everyone I know because that bagel was 1000% awesome! Coming back soon
… moreNokk
I went into this bagel shops because I saw the big “NY BAGELS” sign… These are not NY bagels, the bagel shop made a mockery of NY bagels. As soon as I open the bag of bagels, guess what I saw… PLASTIC. These bagels are not worth $9.50. The bagels were very hot almost microwaved, these bagels tasted and felt store bought.
… more