Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Craving a slice of New York right here in Fort Collins? Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta, born from a beloved Denver street corner in 1984, brings over 40 years of pizza passion to your plate. We’re not just a restaurant; we’re a Colorado tradition, crafting authentic, hand-made pizza daily using simple, high-quality ingredients. Taste the difference dedication makes with every bite of our signature NY style pizza and delectable pasta dishes. Experience the legacy!
Local counter-serve chain that’s a take-out/delivery staple for NY-style pies & other Italian eats.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2550 E Harmony Rd, Fort Collins, CO 80528
Phone: (970) 372-2335
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta Harmony Rd – Order Online
Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta Harmony Rd. 2550 E Harmony Rd, Fort Collins, CO. Change location. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 2550 E Harmony Rd, Fort Collins, CO.
Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta | Find a location
Select a location from Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta and order online. Get the best prices and service by ordering direct!
Harmony Rd – Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta
… party, Anthony’s catering delivers. Order Catering. Dine-In, Pickup or Delivery. 2550 E Harmony Rd. Fort Collins CO 80525. 970-372-2335. DAILY 11A – …
Reviews
Wendell
We tried Anthony’s for the first time and it definitely won’t be our last. The pizza was done perfectly and was so delicious! I was a little hesitant to order delivery from here because they just get ok reviews. I am very picky on even eating pizza and if it’s worth it. And it is worth it here!
I like that you can choose how done you like your crust, I’ve never seen that as an option at any pizza place. I like mine lightly done and they cooked it perfectly. We got sausage, ricotta with olive oil and garlic. We also got a side of meatballs, which were killer and a side of marinara. Everything was so delicious and this will be our go to delivery pizza place.
… moreI like that you can choose how done you like your crust, I’ve never seen that as an option at any pizza place. I like mine lightly done and they cooked it perfectly. We got sausage, ricotta with olive oil and garlic. We also got a side of meatballs, which were killer and a side of marinara. Everything was so delicious and this will be our go to delivery pizza place.
SC Photography
As a New Yorker, I approach pizza with muscle memory and scars. I don’t expect miracles outside the five boroughs—but I do expect effort. What I got from Anthony’s Pizza was something closer to indifference.
I ordered a Margherita through DoorDash, hoping for balance, restraint, maybe even a whisper of reverence. Instead, it arrived like an afterthought. Sauce hastily ladled onto dough with no conversation between the two no simmered depth, no seasoning that suggested someone tasted it before sending it out the door. It felt assembled, not made. The kind of pizza where momentum replaces intention: throw it on, keep it moving.
And that’s the painful part. Pizza isn’t complicated, but it is sacred. When done right, it’s generosity in edible form. Here, it was transactional. As if the dish’s history its decades as a pillar of working-class cuisine—had been quietly forgotten.
Then there were the wings. I wish I could say more. But honesty demands restraint. They tasted like something liberated from a wholesale freezer, thawed just enough to survive heat, then grilled and sent off with a shrug. No char worth mentioning. No seasoning that lingered. Just protein, heat, and the sense that no one along the way asked, “Should this be better?”
What makes this more disappointing is Fort Collins itself a city full of thoughtful food, good beer, and people who deserve better than this version of pizza culture. Especially when places like Tony’s Pizza exist and prove that guidance, craft, and care are right there for the taking.
This isn’t anger. It’s sadness. Sad that a dish so simple, so historically rich, can be reduced to routine. Pizza should feel like someone cared. This didn’t.
… moreI ordered a Margherita through DoorDash, hoping for balance, restraint, maybe even a whisper of reverence. Instead, it arrived like an afterthought. Sauce hastily ladled onto dough with no conversation between the two no simmered depth, no seasoning that suggested someone tasted it before sending it out the door. It felt assembled, not made. The kind of pizza where momentum replaces intention: throw it on, keep it moving.
And that’s the painful part. Pizza isn’t complicated, but it is sacred. When done right, it’s generosity in edible form. Here, it was transactional. As if the dish’s history its decades as a pillar of working-class cuisine—had been quietly forgotten.
Then there were the wings. I wish I could say more. But honesty demands restraint. They tasted like something liberated from a wholesale freezer, thawed just enough to survive heat, then grilled and sent off with a shrug. No char worth mentioning. No seasoning that lingered. Just protein, heat, and the sense that no one along the way asked, “Should this be better?”
What makes this more disappointing is Fort Collins itself a city full of thoughtful food, good beer, and people who deserve better than this version of pizza culture. Especially when places like Tony’s Pizza exist and prove that guidance, craft, and care are right there for the taking.
This isn’t anger. It’s sadness. Sad that a dish so simple, so historically rich, can be reduced to routine. Pizza should feel like someone cared. This didn’t.
Haylie Nguyen
Amazing pizza and even better service! The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh and flavorful, and everything came out hot and fast. Andres was an incredible server—super friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. He really made the whole experience even better. Can’t wait to come back!
… moreShawn Logan
I recently visited Anthony’s Pizza and had a fantastic experience! It’s a cozy spot with a great vibe, and I opted for the pizza by the slice. The pizza has that classic New York flavor—perfectly crispy crust and the perfect balance of toppings. You can tell they really know their pizza here. The customer service was top-notch, with friendly and attentive staff making me feel right at home. Plus, the restaurant was spotless, which made the whole experience even better. Highly recommend it if you’re in the mood for some delicious, authentic pizza!
… moreeric b
Mu recent visit to Anthony’s Pizza in Fort Collins was wonderful. You can always count on delicious pizza here. However, the memorable part of this visit was being helped by a lovely young lady named Soren. Soren was absolutely delightful! She greeted us with the warmest smile, was helpful and so sweet. I highly recommend this place and when you go, I hope you’re lucky enough to have Soren be there!
… moreBraden Russell
Anthony’s was a great experience. I’ve loved in Fort Collin’s for almost 2 years and I can’t believe I haven’t discovered this place until recently. First off this location was very clean and offered a great welcoming energy when we entered. Andres and his coworkers were extremely nice and accommodating to my families allergies and special requests for pizza toppings because we all are picky and want something different! I won’t be going to any other pizza place from now on and will definitely be a regular at Anthony’s from now on.
… moreJoshua Greenleaf
Stopped by Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta in Fort Collins and had a great experience. The food came out hot and tasted awesome.
Andres was super helpful and gave really great service. He was friendly, quick, and made sure we had everything we needed. Definitely coming ba
… moreAndres was super helpful and gave really great service. He was friendly, quick, and made sure we had everything we needed. Definitely coming ba
Kristen Wilbanks
I went to Anthony’s a few days ago. I heard about it from a friend. I received the best customer service from a gentleman by the name of Sam. I couldn’t believe how wonderful he was in his service. He was kind and thoughtful. I had pepperoni pizza and it was so good! The ingredients are fresh and the crust was amazing! Again Sam’s Customer Service was above and beyond! I will be returning to Anthony’s and recommending it. Thank you, Sam.
… moreTyler Trevillian
I rarely make trips to Fort Collins yet I always find myself coming back to Anthony’s Pizza. The food is always prepared with the utmost care by the employees and the happiness and smiles I get from the servers makes it even better. Every time I go, I always ask for the same server… Andres. I can happily say that his customer service and willingness to be at work with a smile always brings me back.
… moreLawyers GunsMoney
The pizza looked horrible when I opened the box. Unappetizing, mis-shapen and not quite the 18 inch size promised. I decided to see if my hunch about the size shortfall was correct and turns out the pie was closer to 16 inch. Unfortunately it was also very undercooked and tasted horrible. Do not recommend.
… more