Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 199 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735
Phone: (516) 586-5600
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Papa’s Pizza and Pasta: Home
The best pizzeria in Farmingdale by far. Their pies and slices are massive … One of the best pizza spots in New York. The pizza is so delicious. Next …
Papa’s Pizza – Farmingdale, NY – 199 Merritts Rd – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-10:00 PM; Shop address is 199 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735199 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735; (516) 586-5600.
Papa’s Pizza | Farmingdale NY – Facebook
We hope you all enjoy the 4th! Place all regular & catering orders today! 516-586-5600 Farmingdale, NY
Reviews
Jt Katyal
This was absolutely incredible. Portions are HUGE. Orlando provided excellent service. The Spaghetti with Meatball was a huge hit. I do wish they included one more meatball to make it 4 instead of 3 but my god the meatballs were so tender so fresh and absolutely delicious. I had one bite of the penne ala vodka cause I was stuffed but even that was delicious. I literally got about 5 meals out of these two. Absolutely incredible top to bottom. I would definitely eat this again. I cannot wait to try more of the menu. Shout out to the entire staff. This is a spot that should not be slept on at all. I will be a recurring customer and make sure I bring everyone I know to try this place. I opted in for the bogo, called ahead and asked respectfully if they can give me one of each instead of two of the same things and Orlando took great care of this and without hesitation said no problem he’ll do this. This is the type of service and food you expect from places and they absolutely crushed it. Beyond thrilled with this. Btw I also asked everything to be “spicy” in Italian terms this is “crushed red pepper” in every dish which they fulfilled as well. Things like that and paying attention to detail make restaurants go a long way. I’m very impressed with this place.
… moreAdam Lombardi
Big shoutout to Papa’s Pizza in Farmingdale! Cozy vibes and seriously tasty slices. The grandma margherita is crispy perfection, and the plain slice is a hit with my kids. Plus, they still make an awesome small pie to-go. Love that they’re open late and the prices? Nice and reasonable. I’ve enjoyed everything so far. Definitely check out this gem! Highly recommend! ✨
… moreRyan Smith
I stop here every couple weeks as I do deliveries in the area for other businesses. And the staff is always so friendly and the food is good and HOT. Regular slice hits different!!! Definitely a regular customer
… moresheldon lamoury
I visited papas pizza a few months ago when I was visiting my parents in New York and man this place was so good. So this week my parents were visiting me in Texas and I asked them to bring some stuff from papas back to Texas for me. Man it was so good. I called a few days earlier and spoke to the owner Orlando and he was very nice. I told him my parents would be packing the food to bring it on a plane for me and he had everything ready nice and packed up for them. He even called me and explained to myself and my parents how to keep it Fresh since they were flying out the next day!! And boy it was still soo fresh. The food was a hit for all my friends in Austin Texas as I always brag about NYC pizza and pizzeria food. We had Buffalo chicken rolls, sausage and pepper rolls, chicken rolls, pepperoni pinwheels and spinach pinwheels , oh and the rice balls. They were gone within minutes of me reheating them. I can’t wait to visit my parents again so I can go back to papas pizza!! And I’ll be sure anytime someone comes to visit me in Texas they bring some food from thetr as well for me .
… moreAnthony Martucci
I’ll start out by saying In 40 years on this earth I’ve eaten a lot of chicken parm and this is the best hero I’ve ever had. Great cutlet and phenomenal sauce. Pops is definitely Martucci approved
… moreJina Yoon
Finally a legit pizzeria on the Island!! As a born and raised Queens girl who moved out East nearly 10 years ago, it’s been a battle to find anywhere comparable to Lucia’s… but Papa’s takes the prize. And I might even add that they are better!
… moreDispatch a
i know good italian food when i eat it and this place is it, ive ordered food 3 times getting pizza and the chicken parm and ill be a customer for life. The rice balls are delicious as well, they are friendly and you can tell the quality of the food is superb
… moreGina R
So many pizza places in Farmingdale but I still haven’t found a good cheese pizza I like until we tried Papas.. I ordered a small one along with the large Grandma pie and I thought the cheese pizza was delicious.. the new owner of the shop is a very nice man, great service delicious food and the place was very clean . I highly recommend giving it a try
… moreBasil Puglisi (basilpuglisi)
This was a nice suprise, a solid tradition pizza and a quality chicken roll.
Grabbed this on a UberEats deal and was suprised its a solid pie and good garlic knots. I not sure the garlic crust upgrade was worth it, but the Chicken Roll was solid.
I not gonna rave and say it was one of my favorites, but I will definitely patronage this location again, deal or no deal.
… moreGrabbed this on a UberEats deal and was suprised its a solid pie and good garlic knots. I not sure the garlic crust upgrade was worth it, but the Chicken Roll was solid.
I not gonna rave and say it was one of my favorites, but I will definitely patronage this location again, deal or no deal.
Jace Reading
Ho-Lee WOW! I am currently doing the Keto diet and so I ordered the Meat Lovers with Alfredo Sauce on Cauliflower crust and it was seriously the greatest food I’ve eaten since I arrived in Long Island from Utah a week ago. The atmosphere was inviting and the service exceeded my expectations! I cannot wait to return! Do yourself a favor and go get yourself some phenomenal pizza from Papa’s Pizza!
… more