Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in New Philadelphia, OH, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best New Philadelphia pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in New Philadelphia or stop by 1315 4TH ST NW for carryout to order the best pizza in New Philadelphia, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1315 4th St NW, New Philadelphia, OH 44663
Phone: (330) 364-2900
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Johns 4th St Nw | Papa Johns New Philadelphia, OH
Call Papa Johns 4th St Nw at (330) 364-2900 for more information or to place a catering order today. How do I join Papa Johns Rewards? Earn Papa Dough to use …
papa johns stores in new philadelphia, oh
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in New Philadelphia, Ohio to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa John’s Pizza | New Philadelphia OH – Facebook
We took our NEW pan pizza to WTUZ and got the official Conley stamp of approval Now it’s your turn to try it — grab a 1-topping pan pizza for just $11.99! We …
Last Updates
Reviews
Rob Winger
I just wanted to order a quick pizza for a late night meal. I got online and ordered a special, medium Hawaiian thin crust for about $10. When I picked the pizza,up about 20 minutes later, I was pleasantly surprised that they had included a sample of 5 different flavors of garlic dipping sauces. That, plus the hot pepper plus special dry seasoning packet made this one of the best pizza deals ever. Pizza was tasty and the thin crust was crispy on the bottom and edges like I prefer. I hope they continue with this kind of offer.
… moremichelle cicero
Excellent! Generous with the toppings. Was delivered fast, and the pizza and cheese sticks were still hot. This was the first time I’ve ordered from Papa John’s, and I’m planning on making this my “go to” pizza
Okay, I have an update. I called and ordered my pizza and boneless wings. I told the person taking my order that I was using a coupon, which was, a large 5-item pizza, or specialty pizza for $14.99. She said okay. Took my order, I went through the drive through to pick up my order. I got home and instead of honoring my coupon, it’s on their website, instead of charging me with the coupon, I was charged $7.00 more. I called them, they first said to come back and show them my coupon and they will accept it. I asked if they could apply the overage to my next order. No, they (the manager) needs to see it on my phone. Then I’m told that they don’t have a coupon like that. Now, I need not show them the coupon on my phone, because they only take coupons if you order online. Well, they accepted my coupon on previous orders. So, the pizza and chicken wings were good, I feel that they should own up on the coupon or give me money off on the next order. So, because of this, I’m not sure I’m going to order from them again. It’s the principle of the thing. I tip them $4.00 when they deliver, plus they add another $4.00 for delivery. I thought that I could save the $8.00 by picking it up. I guess I was wrong.
… moreOkay, I have an update. I called and ordered my pizza and boneless wings. I told the person taking my order that I was using a coupon, which was, a large 5-item pizza, or specialty pizza for $14.99. She said okay. Took my order, I went through the drive through to pick up my order. I got home and instead of honoring my coupon, it’s on their website, instead of charging me with the coupon, I was charged $7.00 more. I called them, they first said to come back and show them my coupon and they will accept it. I asked if they could apply the overage to my next order. No, they (the manager) needs to see it on my phone. Then I’m told that they don’t have a coupon like that. Now, I need not show them the coupon on my phone, because they only take coupons if you order online. Well, they accepted my coupon on previous orders. So, the pizza and chicken wings were good, I feel that they should own up on the coupon or give me money off on the next order. So, because of this, I’m not sure I’m going to order from them again. It’s the principle of the thing. I tip them $4.00 when they deliver, plus they add another $4.00 for delivery. I thought that I could save the $8.00 by picking it up. I guess I was wrong.
Bruce hillbilly Barthalow
I love their pizza . Now the wings, not so much. I guess, I like a crispier wing. The containers the wings came in tipped and leaked, so be careful. This particular Papa John is a drive thru, so very little interaction. But they’re friendly.
… morekathleen cabrera
Ordered a pizza at 11pm had it delivered there was so much cheese and sauce in it the dough was raw. Called and was told by the manager that they would have to replace it another time cause they close in 5 minutes – sorry I don’t get to eat but apparently their Friday night plans are more important than ensuring the customers are taken care of
… moreJustin Huff
Waited 45 plus minutes in line waiting on a pizza because they wouldnt move person in front of me ahead got pizza and was disgustingly cold which wasnt a suprised since it was done when I got there before the 45 minute wait
… moreMyrna Cramblett
2nd time ordered there and BOTH times were BAD. So no more of product…crust soggy, very little sauce, pepperoni…. bad
… moreHiedi B.
I dashed there. Showed up they said it was going to be another 15 minutes. We waited over 30 and when they brought it out and was barely warm
… moreCory Mckain
Took way longer than they said it would, pizza wasn’t cut and there was no garlic butter or pepper in the box. And when I called in they were very dismissive.
… moreAlina Torres
I was at the drive thru, picking up my pizza. The lady hands me my pizza but forgot my extra dipping sauce… Again. As I try to ask her for my dipping sauce, she closes the window and walks away. Their food is good, but their service is trash. I usually don’t leave reviews, but this isn’t the first time this has happened.
… moreJames Young
They took 45 minutes to make the food but said it would be 10 minutes. I don’t mind waiting but I don’t like being lied to about time.
… more