Social Profile: 
![]()
… View more
Ice Cream Social specializes in artisanal ice cream handcrafted in house by Chef Rob McCue. We are a family owned and operated business and pride ourselves on the quality and creativity of our product. Aside from our 64 flavors of ice cream, we also have a menu of vegan flavors to choose from, including an almond milk soft serve. For the health conscience individuals, we carry an Only 8 frozen yogurt in three rotating flavors as well as vanilla and chocolate fat free soft serve. For those thirsty customers, we have hand blended shakes, egg creams, floats, malteds and sodas. Try our specialty cakes for any occasion. We custom design each cake to meet your needs. Don’t forget our traditional and no sugar added chocolates!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1153 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725
Phone: (631) 543-7501
Website: http://www.icecreamsocialli.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Ice Cream Social – Homemade Ice Cream Long Island
ICE CREAM SOCIAL specializes in artisanal ice cream handcrafted in house by celebrated James Beard Chef Rob McCue.
Ice Cream Social (@icecreamsocialli) · Commack, NY – Instagram
Handcrafted, artisanal ice cream by celebrated James Beard Chef Rob McCue and custom cakes by master designer, wife Christine. SCOOP HOMEMADE
Ice Cream Social | Commack NY – Facebook
Ice Cream Social specializes in artisanal ice cream handcrafted in house by Chef Rob McCue. We are a family owned and operated business.
Product
Reviews
B.R. Hubbard
Excellent local spot for legit homemade ice cream with classic and some rotating unusual special flavors (maple & bacon, blueberry crumble) There aren’t too many non-chain ice cream shops around in the area anymore, but this is definitely one of them! A decent selection of vegan options as well.
… moreVictoria Gaffney
Ive had ice cream from them before, always excellent but laat night i tried the coconut cream pie ans my husband had the caramel apple pie. Both had actual pie crust chunks in them. Thick, cream, full of flavor. I had been hoping for a peppermint mocha seasonal flavor but I didnt leave disappointed.
… moreJude Principio
I left 5 stars because this ice cream is the best around by far & the service is great!! Now I’m going to complain!! So if you have the best ice cream around, you have to assume people will travel for it, like me (Brentwood)…. Therefore if you advertise closing at 9pm, please BE OPEN at 8 pm!!! Twice now I decided to blow my diet and have ice cream, driving there for nothing, & winding up at Bascon n Robbin’s.
… moreAmber
I just got back home from getting ice cream and I decided to look on their website out of curosity. I noticed that one of the vegan ice creams that I purchased contains gluten and I have a gluten allergy. I specifically asked the young Girl which vegan ice cream flavor wasn’t gluten free and she goes ” the one with the cookie or the prezel one” however she did not say anything about the toasted almond flavor. I called and double checked and the only thing she can say is Sorry! There needs to be labels so customers can see which ones are and aren’t gluten free because this young girl didn’t know anything as she had to ask her coworker. Don’t you have any ingredient list somewhere so the employees can look and not say ” I guess??” Because that is what she said initially when I asked her. And if you are going to offer vegan ice cream, you should also offer vegan milk, vegan whipped cream and toppings! Do better, Social ice cream! If you cater to people with food restrictions/ dietary restrictions, you should inform your staff so they are knowledgeable. $23 down the toilet, literally!
… moreJanice F
Excellent find that stands out from the usual chains. Great variety of flavors (the chocolate dipped matzoh had a nice chewy texture to offset the ice cream). Nice to see all the great vegan flavors as well.
… moreDonna Castelblanco
Tried the vegan cherry vanilla and my partner had the vegan banana oreo and vegan vanilla. Very delicious! Vanillas tasted like marshmellow. Clean ice cream shop. Kind staff!
… moreFeta Maniac
Looking for a Small batch, hand crafted, masterfully prepared, delicious, indulgent, ice cream? Get here, you won’t be disappointed!
… moreAli Romanelli
Every single time I come here for cookies and cream ice cream it is sold out. Is this not a flavor on your classic menu because that’s absolutely ridiculous you never have it and then everyone says there’s no more in the back. This is attempt #3 coming and you’re out of it.
… moreJ R
Unfortunately not a great place. Went 3 weeks in a row (tradition is getting ice cream on Sundays) 1st week it was alright nothing special notice ice cream was a weird consistency,nice staff. 2nd week noticed the ice cream tubs that had been melted and frost bitten over was still there and untouched from the week prior. Came a 3rd time and saw the same 2 melted ice cream tubs frost bitten over and their chocolate ice cream worst consistency. Decided we weren’t going back. Couple weeks later the kids want ice cream sandwich saucer things I didn’t want to drive all the way to carvel so I went there to find all of them were frost bitten and the SAME MELTED ICE CREAM TUB in the section where they scoop it for you… I walked right out and drove to carvel… Always try for yourself you may like it but I personally go to a lot of special ice cream spots and they normally have more fresh stuff.
… moreFamily SV
The ice cream here is absolutely delicious! We’ve ordered two birthday cakes from them. The artistry was stunning! You can taste the quality of the ingredients and the fact that it is homemade! Service is always friendly! Whether at the main shop or at a pop up. It is owned and operated by a local family too!
… more