Denise Soto
We ordered pizza, after a previous unsatisfactory experience, only because it was a fundraiser. I ordered at 3:45 and, when my husband arrived at 4:45, he still had to wait 10-15 minutes. Because the pizza had obviously been sitting, it was completely dry and cold by the time it got home. And this is not even a traditional Margeurita pizza. On top of that, I had to pay 3.5% for using my credit card. That should be a cost of doing business for a vendor especially since they use Paymentech through Chase and I have a Chase card. I will not be returning.
… moremike taylor
I really really wanted to like this place, the food I ordered was great, however the food I ordered and didn’t receive is not so good, I ordered fried ravioli never got it, ordered rice balls never got it, instead I got jalapeño poppers which is nothing close… so sad, I wanted to be a repeat customer can’t trust this joint.
… moreAaron Glading
Great place to eat good pricing good service fast deliver best pizza around
… moreCatherine Mathews
I love their pizza here! But the watched the girl in the front touch food with her bare dirty hands.
… moreTerri Brucato
I have been a regular customer for years. Even went when it was owned by someone else. Lately the food is terrible We used to order eggplant parm. Now it is so greasy and not worth eating. Gave them several chances since then. Again, food is not worth it. Tonight my pizza is burnt to a crisp and my calamari is so tough I feel like I’m chewing on rubber. Needless to say I wasted $25 on horrible food. I’ve voiced opinions to the owner previously but he is tough almost to the point of not caring about the quality of his food. . I’ll be going elsewhere.
… moreThomas Gay
I love this place, order from here all the time. Nice and thin not too much dough, sauce isn’t too sweet, probably the closest you’re going to find in this area to New York City pizza. Awesome prices. Thanks for picking up the slack when I don’t feel like throwing something together!
… moreSheila
Ordered the Jumbo 18” pizza thinking that didn’t sound so big. I believe the slices must be 18” each, because the box was the largest pizza box I have ever seen. The delivery timeline given was over an hour but arrived well before that. We used the Slice App to order to the Mountain Creek Townhouses and the driver met me in the parking lot. He was very nice and courteous.
The jumbo pie was delicious. I can’t believe a bunch of 7 year olds finished their slices and some even wanted more. The grandma pizza was also excellent.
… moreAntonio Ricci
To start off, I wanted to give this place a chance and see them succeed so I ordered at least 6 or 7 times from here hoping the quality of the food would be better than the last time. The pizza is way too thin and tasteless, that includes their specialty pies as well. Every time I ordered pizza from here it was under cooked. Ordered a chicken wrap and it was the smallest wrap I have ever seen and did not come with fries. When people order food they want to be fed. Not still be hungry after they eat.
… moreBob Verga
I have been living in Sussex County for over 20 years and this is by far the best pizza I have ever had up here. I am thrilled to have a pie that is as good if not better than what I get in NYC where I work. I go at least once a week. Just great!
… moreSarah Nicolas
Best pizza is Sussex County. If you haven’t ordered from here you are missing out of authentic favor paradise. Don’t forget to say hi to the owner “Aaron” who works day & night to serve the residents of Sussex and provide top notch service and quality food you can’t resist. Be sure to read all the weekly specials as well as fundraisers they support for the community.
… more