howard froelicher
Meatball hoagie was delicious… The sauce was Italian and warming… Feel it on your ribs… Flavors fresh and it didn’t taste like a frozen pattie..
Pizza is a good pizza… It’s what I expect for a mom and pop country pizza shop…
Recommend meatball hoagie with pizza sauce
… moreAV
My son out of nowhere asked if we could get Sun Valley. I haven’t had Sun Valley in maybe 2 or 3 years. Not for any negative reason, but it used to be on my way home and isn’t anymore. I had also heard that the prices went sky high. I got a medium pizza and it was basically the same amount that I would pay for Larosa’s, but it was way better. I asked for extra pepperoni and asked if they could put it on top of the cheese, which they said no problem at all. I also asked for it well done which they cooked it perfectly. Crisp pepperoni, crispy crust. It was awesome! And again, I don’t think the price was too bad at all. They are back in the rotation! Next time we’re getting Hoagies!!!
Lastly, there was a guy and a girl both working who were really nice. I really appreciate it. Highly recommend.
(Edited for grammar)
New Edit (Jan 2026)-I have recently read that Sun Valley has been sold and now has new owners. I have not eaten there since, but not for any negative reason, just haven’t had a chance to order it lately. So fingers crossed that they don’t change anything….I’ll edit with an update after the next time I go there.
… moreS D
We ordered cheese bread and a large cheese pizza with pepperoni. We ordered the food about 45 minutes until closing time. The food wasn’t good. It was bland. We were thinking maybe the food was so bad since it was close to closing time? Either way we won’t be ordering again.
… moreTanya DeLeone
This was our first time trying Sun Valley Pizza. It was delicious! The thin crust was very tasty. The sauce just a little sweet and the toppings yummy! Overall, we’ll definitely be ordering again!
… moreJenny Cummins
The pizza is delicious. Steak hoagies not so much. Way to much sauce. When I unwrapped it I had to scrape off à ton of sauce to add to the mess in the foil full of sauce
… moreJamie starr
The hoagies were delicious. The pizza not so much, but will go back.
… moreTHOMAS HILL
First time going to Sun Valley pizza and it was very delicious. Highly recommended.
… moreHolly Bowman
Not nearly has good as the original now with different owners. Wayyyy to much sauce on pizza and hoagie.
… moreNick Hoffman
Pizza, and everything else, here is always awesome! Been here several times and they are always courteous and friendly. Orders are always correct. Toppings always loaded. Take out only. Highly recommend this place!
… moreGinny Woolridge
Amazing pizza and friendly employees! Highly recommend making this a repeat menu item for the week
… more