Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2822 Brower Ave, Oceanside, NY 11572
Phone: (516) 536-5460
Website: https://mariospizzeriaoceanside.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Mario’s Pizza – Oceanside, NY – 2822 Brower Ave – Hours, Menu …
Hot Heros · Shrimp Hero. With tomato sauce. $16.50 · Veal Cutlet Hero. With tomato sauce. $15.95 · Veal Cutlet with Peppers Hero. $16.75 · Veal Cutlet with …
Mario’s Pizza – Family-Owned Italian Pizzeria | 43 Years Serving …
Mario’s Pizza has been serving Oceanside, NY for 43 years. Fresh ingredients, traditional recipes, and family-owned quality. Order online or call (516) …
Mario’s Pizza | Oceanside NY – Facebook
Perfect for the crew, the couch, and every touchdown celebration. Tap to order now and make your watch party legendary! 2822 Brower Ave, Oceanside …
Last Updates
Reviews
Lorraine Zinga
We had a great experience our first time at Mario’s last night!! The star of the show was the Grandma Pizza!!! The sauce was delicious and the crust had the perfect crunch!
We also had the Chicken Vodka Parm pinwheels and they were just as delicious!! The chicken was tender, and the vodka sauce full of flavor. If you haven’t tried the garlic knot pizza it is a Must for all garlic knot fans.
Don’t forget to try an eggplant roll, packed full of eggplant and cheese yumminess!!!
The staff is friendly and happy to make everything we wanted!
Can’t wait to go back!!!
… moreWe also had the Chicken Vodka Parm pinwheels and they were just as delicious!! The chicken was tender, and the vodka sauce full of flavor. If you haven’t tried the garlic knot pizza it is a Must for all garlic knot fans.
Don’t forget to try an eggplant roll, packed full of eggplant and cheese yumminess!!!
The staff is friendly and happy to make everything we wanted!
Can’t wait to go back!!!
Eric
So l use to go here as a kid and it seems like nothings really changed since the last 10 years! It’s a pretty small place, the decor is not that appealing, just very dull looking.
I ordered the chicken parm with pasta. I really wanted spaghetti but the guy said it would take too long and gave me penne pasta instead. I was kinda bummed about that. I got it to go and they packed it in 2 separate containers, which made it annoying to eat it separate like that. The pasta tasted microwaved/reheated. But the chicken parm was actually really good! The guy at the register was really nice aswell.
Service was quick probably because they weren’t that busy, but beware, this is the goto spot for the high schoolers during the afternoon and after school hours so it can get pretty packed. But in the summer it’s not that bad of a crowd.
I’ll probably eat here once in awhile but it didn’t blow me away.
… moreI ordered the chicken parm with pasta. I really wanted spaghetti but the guy said it would take too long and gave me penne pasta instead. I was kinda bummed about that. I got it to go and they packed it in 2 separate containers, which made it annoying to eat it separate like that. The pasta tasted microwaved/reheated. But the chicken parm was actually really good! The guy at the register was really nice aswell.
Service was quick probably because they weren’t that busy, but beware, this is the goto spot for the high schoolers during the afternoon and after school hours so it can get pretty packed. But in the summer it’s not that bad of a crowd.
I’ll probably eat here once in awhile but it didn’t blow me away.
Ulrika W
My boyfriend and I have become regulars at this point because the pizza is so damn delicious!! The sauce is sweet and garlicky, the dough is a beautiful blend of crispy crust and soft, the garlic knots are not greasy and taste delicious, and the chicken roll is equally tasty. Next we’ll have to start trying the food and see if it keeps the same quality. Been to many other pizzerias, but this is the one and only for us now. Also, the staff is so nice and friendly, and accommodating to your preferences. Prices are very good for the quality you get.
… moreCara Dolan
I recently had the pleasure of trying this pizza, and it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly baked—crispy on the outside with just the right amount of chew. The sauce had a rich, tangy flavor that balanced beautifully with the cheese, which was melted to golden perfection. Each bite was satisfying and packed with flavor. Simple, classic, and delicious—just the way pizza should be.
Highly recommend if you’re craving something reliably tasty.
… moreHighly recommend if you’re craving something reliably tasty.
Lynn Stefaniak
Tonites pizza dinner my family ordered from Mario’s
We ordered a vegetable pie, plain cheese pie and a Greek salad
The food came fast , hot and delicious
The salad and pizza very fresh.
Great food !!!
… moreWe ordered a vegetable pie, plain cheese pie and a Greek salad
The food came fast , hot and delicious
The salad and pizza very fresh.
Great food !!!
Alison Werner
Mario’s has delicious pizza and dishes and are always coming up with new slices to try. This is a family business who takes pride in their food and service! If you haven’t already go check them out. You will not be disappointed!!
… moreBrian Dolan
This has been one of my favorite pizza places for over 20 years. It’s family owned and they do everything from the pizza to the dinners perfectly. Glad to see they’re still going strong! I can’t recommend this place enough.
… moreJariel Nunez
Mario’s Pizzeria is one of the best pizza places around. The crust is nice and crispy, and the sauce tastes fresh and homemade. The workers are super friendly, and the service is fast. If you want good pizza made with fresh ingredients, Mario’s is the place to go!
… moreCharles Cardona
Have been enjoying Mario’s for close to 8 years since moving to the area. Love their pizza and so excited for the revamped menu. It’s a family
favorite of ours especially since they are a long standing family owned business on LI!
… morefavorite of ours especially since they are a long standing family owned business on LI!
Pamela Soto
Their regular pie is fantastic, the people are very friendly, service is fast. They recently went through a facelift and inside is much brighter and feels bigger. We’ve been coming for many years and will continue to go back.
… more