Amber Dico
Just tried this place for the first time. Being from NY/NJ I am difficult to please, but I was pleasantly surprised! I got smalls since I was not sure what to expect but I am regretting that decision. I tried the hot honey with cupping pepperoni pie and it was fabulous! I love cupping pepperoni and the hot honey is not overwhelming just adds a hint of heat and sweetness. Yes, it had some grease to it but I like grease on my pizza so was just added flavor. The crust was a perfect thickness, thin but could stand up to the weight of toppings. The caesar salad pie…and absolute must! So delicious. Chicken was flavorfuland the lettuce was fresh amd crisp. They did not skimp on the parmesan. My boyfriend and I fought over the slices. Will definitely try more from here. There are a couple small tables to eat at, but probably more of a take out spot.
… moreMatt
First time at this location, and I was very impressed. Eddie at the counter was great and very personable. The pizza was awesome, and I’ll definitely be back for more. I’m especially curious to try the meatball parm next time.
… moreMatt Brown
Ordered two large on DoorDash. Only sharing cause it’s very difficult to find good pizza in Greenville and this is priced and reviewed like it hits the mark. No need to comment beyond the photos…really wanted it to be good, would have settled for okay. I’m sure they are a nice local family and I’m glad their business is doing so well.
… moreBianca Beltran
Was in town, and stopped by here! The pizza was absolutely delicious! The service was great too! Thank you so much! We are 30 mins away but this place is definitely worth the drive, will be back soon! Thanks!
… moreWilliam Coxe
Best Pizza in Greenville! We had the mushroom and truffle oil and it was perfect. The Greek salad was awesome and we got to meet the owner. This place is clean and perfectly cooked thin crust with fresh ingredients. This is not the old Tony’s greasy cheesy! Do yourself a favor and run not walk…..
… moreDavid Hanor
Delicious pizza and ready faster than expected for take out. The Washington Heights pie pictured along with small cheese and garlic knots.
The garlic knots are *garlicky*
Glad to have them in the neighborhood!
… moreAlisha Smith
Olivia’s Pizza is basically a New York pizza miracle that somehow landed in our town. Thin, crispy crust that snaps just right, sauce that dances on your tongue, and toppings so good they should have their own fan club.
Eating here is like folding a little slice of NYC into your hand. Iykyk I love NY Pizza so it’s got some competition for winning over my taste buds and it has done just that.
… moreApril Rowe
We just had the best experience at the new Olivia’s Pizza on S. Pleasantburg! We got the white pizza and the absolutely delectable Washington Heights pizza (cupped pepperoni, fresh basil, parmigiano, and EVOO). The crust is perfectly thin and crispy with just the right amount of softness. A DoorDash guy came in to pick up some pizza to deliver, and the owner gifted him two slices just to try. I thought that was so sweet! Also, I didn’t realize that there was nowhere to sit yet, but they brought us a table and tablecloth so we could sit down and enjoy our pizza. He also gave us a free order of cannoli. I am a cannoli snob, and I can tell you they are crispy and delicious! Try them out!
… morerachel gonzales
Literally so good. We love doing the make your own pizza and get what we want on our halves. comes hot and delicious every single time.
… moreC Hustle
Pizza has always been great. Last night we also ordered 2 Tiramisú and for some reason, the lady finger part was EXTREMELY Salty. Just as if someone confused sugar for salt in the making. Couldn’t eat it
… more