Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 214 NY-59 Unit 2, Airmont, NY 10901
Phone: (845) 547-2565
Website: http://mamamiassuffern.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Mama Mia’s Pizzeria | Suffern: Suffern Pizza
Mama Mia’s Pizzeria in Airmont, NY offers a tremendous selection of traditional Italian food, ranging from savory pasta dishes to homemade pizzas.
Mama Mia’s Pizzeria – 214 NY-59, Airmont, NY 10901 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Airmont, NY! Mama Mia’s Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Mama Mia’s Pizzeria Restaurant Deli – The Ultimate Pizza …
Discover Mama Mia’s Pizzeria Restaurant Deli, where fresh, delicious pizza and a warm atmosphere make every meal unforgettable. Located in Airmont, NY, …
Reviews
Jim Leaskey
Typical NY strip shopping pizzeria. Each one I visit is unique in it pizza toppings, but the interior is 70’s and 80’s decor.
Now about the pizza. Can’t ever go wrong with bacon, chicken, and ranch. Plenty of toppings and the 2nd cook just give the crust the strength to support the trip to your mouth. No fork or folding it in half required.
Now the second slice, chicken marsala? Who in the world does that to pizza? But let me tell you when he told me what it was I did not hesitate. There is no doubt better on pizza than pasta. Still can’t stop talking about it. Hats off to the proprietor of this pizzeria for their creativity.
The best part of the experience was to see the locals come in, and they didn’t even have to order. A simple hello and the usual from behind the counter followed by a head nod.
I highly recommend it, and I would return, but too many other pizzerias to visit
Checked the box for me.
… moreNow about the pizza. Can’t ever go wrong with bacon, chicken, and ranch. Plenty of toppings and the 2nd cook just give the crust the strength to support the trip to your mouth. No fork or folding it in half required.
Now the second slice, chicken marsala? Who in the world does that to pizza? But let me tell you when he told me what it was I did not hesitate. There is no doubt better on pizza than pasta. Still can’t stop talking about it. Hats off to the proprietor of this pizzeria for their creativity.
The best part of the experience was to see the locals come in, and they didn’t even have to order. A simple hello and the usual from behind the counter followed by a head nod.
I highly recommend it, and I would return, but too many other pizzerias to visit
Checked the box for me.
james luski
Stopped in for takeout today. Been here once before a couple years ago. 7 different pizzas were displayed in the case as well as garlic knots, calzones and Jamaican beef patties. 4 additional pies were in the oven. I opted to try 2 of those: a CBR slice and a chicken Parmesan slice. $13.99 for 2 slices and 2 soda cans. There were 13 tables in this dimly lit, old school wood decor shop, a dessert case, soda case and 3 tvs. The slices had a somewhat flimsy crust with a doughy (maybe sourdough) flavor. The CBR needed more ranch dressing, the chicken and bacon were on point though. The chicken on the Parm slice was crisp but most fell off with the sauce as I picked it up. Sauce was sweet, perhaps marinara and both were very large.
… moreDustin Mckean
Mama Mia’s is an absolute winner. Always fresh ingredients and delicious food. Leo the owner is always there to help as well. Highly recommend. Keep up the good work
… moreJeff Cooper
Well, the area is just sad these days and their business is obviously not booming but when I went in at dinner time, absolutely zero pizza was even remotely warm. So order ahead and take it out
… moreAlana Smith
So yummy, we were starved and wanted to get back on the road to head into the city. This was perfect! Ordered 2 slices and tuna sandwich. Cost $23
… moreD.S. Mitchell
Really enjoyed the pizza!! Maybe not the NY “Slice” that I had anticipated… but delicious and huge portion nonetheless. Service was SUPER FRIENDLY!
… moreDavid Kimble
Up visiting my mother in good Sam’s and came here for a pizza the pizza was amazing
… moreAby Mathew
What a change in attitude and customer service once you think you have established! They started modestly and the community supported them especially during the pandemic. I have been customer too. Services were ok especially when the guy (owner) was taking the order or serving. However, I ordered a pizza few days back on the phone and I confirmed twice to make it half pepperoni and half onion and green peppers. They messed up the order! When I asked about it the lady who took the order was defensive and confrontational. When I requested to speak to the owner (guy) who I have met several times, she informed me that she is then owner and that’s her husband! She will not even admit the mistake in the order nor was customer friendly. I can see the attitude taking them down the hill!
… moreYonky Doodle Dandy
Pizza tastes just like the local Kosher types, this doesn’t taste ‘Italian inspired’. Especially the Margherita pie, the sauce is too sweet, lacks flavor aside from that, the pie was under baked too, not just that, they chopped the basil rendering them mostly tasteless. I’ve had the regular slices they sell, and somehow that’s higher quality than the specialty pies? I’ve worked in pizzerias and the quality control here is non existent. I doubt they taste the food.
… morebrittany clarke
Terrible customer service. Delivery people come with no change and then have an attitude about it. ( so if you’re getting delivery, don’t pay with cash because they don’t even have $12 change ) . The employees I spoke with over the phone are always kind. The delivery driver made it my problem that she didn’t come with at least $12 change. Extremely rude.
… more