John “SEVEN” Malkin
Pizzeria Roma stands as a beloved local institution, thriving under owner Kristina Finefield since 2013, with pizza recipes and a legacy that harken back to Monical’s Pizza roots. The menu playfully forbids anchovies (‘Nope nope nope!!’), but wholeheartedly embraces The Works on thin crust—a dreamy, crispy spectacle reminiscent of Monical’s original style.
Add in made-to-order chicken wings and signature cheese sticks (think bubbly, golden, cheesy bread, not fried stix), and you’re in for a full Italian-inspired feast. Gluten-free pizza fans are also in luck: reviews and celiac diners rave about the crispness and safety of their pies, and the staff takes extra care with dietary needs. The setting is cozy and family-friendly (be on the lookout for Loring Finefield hand-tossing pies!), Order the large thin crust The Works, wings, and cheese sticks and see why locals choose Roma as their pizza night headquarters
… moresteve hurley
Great pizza place in LeRoy. Excellent crust, great sauce and the toppings are pretty good. Its a little pricey but definitely worth it for the great tasting and we’ll prepared pizzas and breadsticks. Definitely return every couple of weeks
… moreTemple Thomas
we tried both the thin crust and the pan version of the pizza. Wasn’t that crazy about the pan version it could have been crispier and the dough itself could have been a little bit thicker they were definitely very sparse on the pepperoni topping outside of that it was pretty good. The thin crust was awesome nice crispy bottom good shoe to it and the sauce had the perfect amount of spice and tanginess
… moreEric Powell
Best pizza I’ve had in years. Friendly and accommodating staff. And, one Sunday I got the same pizza from Monical’s in Gibson city and Roma‘s and did a taste test for fun. The winner by a long shot was Pizzeria Roma.
… moreMike Kara Spinner
Order was taken quickly but once our food arrived no one returned to the table until the check was brought. Price on check did not match the menu… we paid a substantial amount more than the menu priced it at. Pizza was undercooked, extremely salty, not cut all the way and no utensils were provided to serve it with or eat.
They gave us a tiny cup of water and apparently that does not come with free refills because after we drank the first one we had nothing to rinse the salt out of our mouths with.
We ordered breadsticks which appeared to have been cooked earlier in the day and reheated in the microwave
Really nothing positive to say about anything we experienced
… moreGregg Clarkson
Pizzeria Roma is a fantastic spot for anyone who loves authentic, flavorful pizza. The crust is perfectly crisp, the toppings are fresh, and the sauce has just the right amount of zest. The staff was friendly and welcoming, creating a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere that made the whole experience even better. We also tried their garlic knots and a salad—both were excellent. It’s clear they put care into every dish. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Pizzeria Roma delivers top-notch quality. Can’t wait to come back!
… moreFiona Thomas
The pan pizza is good but I definitely am a fan of the thin crust. Crispy and delectable and the sauce is just the right blend of savory and sweet.
… moreKerry Mann
Perfect perfect perfect Pizza! Amazing lunch special! Pleasant dining experience. Clean and cozy place. The service was good, but maybe slower than you might like. Will definitely return to experience more of the menu.
… moreMichelle Graves
Excellent pizza! Great flavor and fresh. Traveling through on a road trip and everything else in town was closed on a Sunday. Only thing missing on the menu is Beer/wine and a GREEN salad (no iceberg).
… moreKelly Lay
Absolute gem of a little local pizza place! This is everything you want but never get at larger franchise locations. Super crispy, high quality toppings, amazing cheeses. Service was very attentive and the menu is very personable and funny. 12/10 this is my new favorite place to eat!!
… more