Alexander Winfield
Pretty decent pizza place. The pizza is pretty good, but what I liked about it was it wasn’t very greasy. We got take out so can’t say much about the restaurant, but it looked like a fun place. The cheese bread was better than expected and the pepperoni pizza was exactly as expected. Obviously popular because when I went to pick up it was pretty busy. The staff seemed a little overwhelmed when I came in but it was around 6pm on a Friday though. I’d definitely come back.
… moreChristine Melicia
I love the gluten free Margherita pizza ! I actually just found out it’s called the Manresa pizza. It’s delicious and my ten year old granddaughter and five year old grandson both love it too.
… moreNapoleon Navarro
Stopped by to grab a slice as I passed through Monterey on Highway 1. The pizza is filling for one slice and has a fair amount of toppings. It taste fresh and the crush texture is firm with a soft, chewy bite. I got the D’Lex Chicken and Bacon, it’s similar to a chicken bacon ranch with mushrooms, green onions, and garlic. If I’m in the area I’ll be stopping by again!
… moreVincent Estrada
very friendly staff. pizza was ready pretty fast. very delicious. lots of different pizzas to choose from or creat your own. we got pepperoni, mushrooms, jalapeños and hot honey.
… moreHoward Pettet
Good pizzas and if you only want a slice they can accommodate. Place can get busy but worth the wait. You can call ahead as we did and skip the waiting.
… moreJim Gloeckler
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Pizza My Heart in Monterey absolutely delivered. We ordered the 18” Rockaway BBQ Chicken pizza and a round of wings, and both were fantastic. The pizza had that perfect balance of smoky BBQ flavor, tender chicken, and a crust that hits the sweet spot between crispy and chewy. The wings were just as impressive — flavorful, hot, and cooked perfectly.
Every time we come here, the quality is consistent and the food hits the spot. If you’re craving great pizza in Monterey, this place never disappoints.
… moreEric Bell
This is our goto place for pizza on the Monterey Peninsula. Pizza is consistently good and our favorite is the Big Sur. The garlic is not off-putting and everything is always fresh. Our next favorite is a traditional pepperoni. The Greek salad is also very good. ❤️ Pizza my Heart!
… moreChelley M
We went on a Monday night, before a trip to the cinema. Ordered a 12 inch pizza, told we could get an 18 inch for the same price (Monday to Thursday). Enough pizza for the next day- breakfast, lunch and dinner! LOTS of toppings . Really nice pizzas. Friendly staff. Nice to have a takeaway pizza that you can sit and eat in. Much cheaper than eating in a restaurant. Salads available and drinks.
… moreleslie lancaster
Been going to Pizza My Heart for about thirty years now and always a great slice! Last time I was there I got pies to go and they were ready as soon as I came to pick them up, and service was very pleasant. An area classic worth the trip!
… moreTeena Malicsi
My granddaughters and I are having a wonderful time in Monterey, and we accidentally found this amazing pizza place! The pizza was incredibly delicious, and the crispy crust was just perfect. We really enjoyed our meal there!
… more