Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Evansville, IN, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Evansville pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Evansville or stop by 5436 East Indiana Street for carryout to order the best pizza in Evansville, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Hours
| Monday | 10 AM–12:30 AM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–12:30 AM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–12:30 AM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–12:30 AM |
| Friday | 10 AM–1:30 AM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–1:30 AM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–12 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5436 E Indiana St, Evansville, IN 47715
Phone: (812) 473-5200
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
4204 North 1st Avenue – Evansville, IN – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
Order from Papa Johns North 1st Avenue for the best takeout and food delivery in Evansville. Order online, visit or call for pizza, wings, sides and more!
Papa Johns Pizza North Weinbach Avenue.
Call us for pizza delivery in Evansville or stop by 303 North Weinbach Avenue. for carryout to order the best pizza in Evansville, along with breadsticks, …
Papa Johns Pizza Delivery & Carryout – Best Deals on Pizza, Sides …
Enjoy the ease of ordering delicious pizza for delivery or carryout from a Papa Johns near you. Start tracking the speed of your delivery and earn rewards …
Last Updates
Reviews
Amanda Barnes
Takes a long time. Never staffed appropriately. Always using door dash.
Tried them again, I dont know what I was thinking. Tiffany is narcissistic and hung up on me after gaslighting me bc the store was busy. Refused a refund on my order.
… moreTried them again, I dont know what I was thinking. Tiffany is narcissistic and hung up on me after gaslighting me bc the store was busy. Refused a refund on my order.
Abigail Dowell
This is the worst papa John’s locations I’ve ordered from. They mess up my order every time to the point I stopped getting food from here. I’m pregnant and have been craving their pizza so we decided to try it again but again they never bring the extra sauce I ordered. Every time I never get my extra sauce even though I pay an extra $7 for it all I’ve even picked it up multiple times and had to walk back in to get it because they forgot. I understand once or twice but every time I order is ridiculous.
… moreDaniela Solano
This is our usual go-to for pizza. Lately, the food has been subpar at best. On today’s order, we wanted to try the New York style crust. The photo on the website shows topping and sauce almost to the edge of the dough. What we got were two MEDIUM sized pies (if even that size) that had more dough than toppings and were cut by an apparent toddler. Before my coupon, the price was close to $50 for these tiny dough balls. I wish I had photos of them in the boxes before the kids got into them. Photos of a styrofoam plate with two slices is attached. Usually, one slice of PJ large pizza takes up the entire plate. This is unacceptable and we are sorely disappointed.
… moreSarah Hartman
Takeout was delivered in the time expected, made as ordered, and tasted amazing. The garlic breadsticks were off the chain.
… moreShayla Norris
Restaurant is great, hard working staff, good pizza. Yet the Ai voice order taker sucks big time.
… moreBrittany Bradley
I’m from Indianapolis and currently staying in Evansville for work. My coworker took me out for sushi at a local restaurant she recommended, but unfortunately, it wasn’t what she remembered, and we barely ate. Back at the hotel, we decided to order Papa John’s since it was late, and they delivered.
Let me tell you—this was not only the fastest delivery I’ve ever experienced, but it was also the best Papa John’s pizza I’ve ever had. In fact, it was the best pizza I’ve ever eaten from a food chain franchise! And that’s saying a lot because my family owned 11 Little Caesars locations in the Indianapolis area.
It was so good that we ordered it again the second night, and it was just as phenomenal. The consistency was truly impressive! I even called the store to share my compliments, and the manager, Dylan, was incredibly kind.
Thank you, Dylan, and your amazing team for the outstanding service and top-tier pizza. P.S. Please consider relocating to the Indianapolis area—we need your magic there!
… moreLet me tell you—this was not only the fastest delivery I’ve ever experienced, but it was also the best Papa John’s pizza I’ve ever had. In fact, it was the best pizza I’ve ever eaten from a food chain franchise! And that’s saying a lot because my family owned 11 Little Caesars locations in the Indianapolis area.
It was so good that we ordered it again the second night, and it was just as phenomenal. The consistency was truly impressive! I even called the store to share my compliments, and the manager, Dylan, was incredibly kind.
Thank you, Dylan, and your amazing team for the outstanding service and top-tier pizza. P.S. Please consider relocating to the Indianapolis area—we need your magic there!
Wowostyle Productions
Great Service ordering online. 4 Stars only because they gave me Banana Pepper rings instead of the Pepperoncinis that I ordered…and the driver got lost and had to call me. He was a super nice YOUNG man, but said he was “old school” and didnt use GPS. Just seems like GPS would be an easy given this day in age for any pizza delivery person that might not know where they were going with a hot pizza.
… moreMark
Used to be a good place to order from, but the quality of the pizzas has gone downhill. I’ve received pizzas where the sauce, cheese, and toppings were quite a distance for the edge. Not good when you pay so much. Not sure I’ll order from this store again.
… moreNathan Byers
Everything was good but they didn’t square cut the pizza like I asked
… moreScott Wilk
I’ve ordered a number of pizzas from this place over the last 4 months while I’m in town on job. Now honestly papa johns ain’t my favorite pizza but they deliver so there’s that. Now the foods not bad don’t misunderstand me ok. I’ve only 2 complaints and the first being if I order extra cheese they sometimes don’t cook it long enough it’s soggy but only sometimes not always. Now my big complaint, the pizza is almost never cut all the way through. Trying to tear and rip then cut it with a pocket knife on a motel bed trying not to cut through to the mattress is a pain. Outside of those 2 things I never had an issue. I’ve ordered 2 or 3 pizzas a week for the last 4 months so it’s consistent.
… more