Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Middletown, DE, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Middletown pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Middletown or stop by 386 East Main Street for carryout to order the best pizza in Middletown, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
386 East Main Street – Middletown, DE – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
Order from Papa Johns East Main Street for the best takeout and food delivery in Middletown. Order online, visit or call for pizza, wings, sides and more!
papa johns stores in middletown, de
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Middletown, Delaware to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa Johns Pizza Delivery & Carryout – Best Deals on Pizza, Sides …
Enjoy the ease of ordering delicious pizza for delivery or carryout from a Papa Johns near you. Start tracking the speed of your delivery and earn rewards …
Last Updates
Reviews
Reneé C.
This location is really hit and miss when it comes to accuracy. For example, this particular papadilla in the photo was supposed to be no bell peppers, and where’s the meat?? For whatever reason they are ALWAYS out of all dessert; out of the several times I’ve ordered dessert they only had it twice and one of the 2 times they only had the new salted Carmel brownie, which I took as a replacement and it was not bad. Food usually tastes good though and service is fast, I’ve never had to wait for my pizza after arriving.
… moreJeff R.
I decided to stop at Papa John’s in Middletown to get the Shaq pizza or they call it Shaq a Toni.
The service was good. The personnel was very courteous and helpful.
The pepperoni pizza was very delicious .
… moreThe service was good. The personnel was very courteous and helpful.
The pepperoni pizza was very delicious .
Nicholas
This is a real human here – not some spam bot (leaving bad reviews). Straight up – best pizzas I’ve had anywhere in the US. *** Consistently. Have never left a review in my life – but the quality of my past orders, and seeing a bunch of Trolls leaving negative reviews, has prompted me to leave one. This particular location works magic in their little 700sf of a work shop! I’d honestly rate these guys an A to A+.
… moreJames Combs
I just picked up a door dash order. The girl behind the counter was hollering and cursing, she was rude to the customer ahead of me. She never asked ” who is the pick for” just hollered ” Name” to him and them to myself as well. She slammed my pick up order down on the counter, and said ” Here, get em” when I went out the door she was still screaming. The other two employees, just held their heads down in shame. She should have went home, just lock the door and leave!
… moreAlok Nanda
Was a fan of PJ’s pizzas back in India. Not disappointed here either.
Pizzas – delish.
Chicken nuggets – good. Especially with that dipping sauce.
Bread sticks – not so much. Chewy and flavorless.
But I will go back for their pizzas for sure.
… morePizzas – delish.
Chicken nuggets – good. Especially with that dipping sauce.
Bread sticks – not so much. Chewy and flavorless.
But I will go back for their pizzas for sure.
Kyllie Gibson
I usually have a good experience with this location. But it has taken over an hour and I’m still currently waiting for my food to arrive. The app said they were here 30 minutes ago and I called 20 mins ago called again a few mins and got put on hold for almost 10 minutes to only be told they one have one driver and lost my order. This is completely unacceptable. Update: I got my food at it was completely cold and my food looked horrible. I got the pepperoni roll ups and they were inedible pictures below. I called back and the person who answered said they have been having Issues all day. He said they would remake the pepperoni roll ups and I called at 9:52 it’s currently 10:33 so 40 minutes and still waiting. If it doesn’t show up tonight I will call and ask for a refund for that item. This was a terrible experience and I don’t think I will be ordering from this location again
… moreHaroon
I called this place and place an order or 2 large pizza 50% off the lady who took my order was nice and friendly. I asked her the total she said 20.99 I went to pick up the pizza and the price went up to 23.99 I asked the guy that I talked to the lady over the phone and confirmed the price why it’s now 23.99 can you call her out and confirm with her. I guess that hurt his EGO and he refused to call her and insist me buying at 23.99. very rude attitude so I walk out. Never again
… moreadinia bailey
My first and last time ordering from here. My pizza toppings were scattered everywhere. I had to use my pizza cutter to cut the pizza. I ordered bone in wings with blue cheese but received boneless wings with ranch. I called to speak to someone and no one answered the phone.
… moreDestinyWorldzz
I had a frustrating experience with my order. I tried calling to get it fixed and waited for 10-15 minutes, but no one answered. It’s really annoying to have spent so much money and not get a response. The pizza was dry, unappealing, and the sauce had spilled all over the box, making it a complete waste of money.
… moreDae Park
This place is a solid 4.. possibly 4.5 stars.
The only reason I didn’t give it 5 stars was because the girl couldn’t figure out how to put the order in… so I ended up doing it myself online. Still she was very friendly.
The crew here look like they work together very well. They’re fast and efficient.
Oh.. lastly, my pie came out a bit thin. I’ve had Papa Johns in the past, and I’ve never gotten a pizza that was close to paper thin. Too thin to eat without folding it.. this was odd to me.
… moreThe only reason I didn’t give it 5 stars was because the girl couldn’t figure out how to put the order in… so I ended up doing it myself online. Still she was very friendly.
The crew here look like they work together very well. They’re fast and efficient.
Oh.. lastly, my pie came out a bit thin. I’ve had Papa Johns in the past, and I’ve never gotten a pizza that was close to paper thin. Too thin to eat without folding it.. this was odd to me.