Katharine Shelah
If you haven’t been yet, Polpetti is a must! My family and I are from NY and we LOVE it! Chicken cutlet sandwiches are hard to come by and we feel like we are back in NY every time we eat them at Polpetti. The FDNY is our absolute favorite! We have ordered sandwiches, bought fresh pasta, ordered catering and cookies, and had a large event at my office catered. Everything is amazing. Pete, Georgia and their team are the sweetest and you always feel welcome.
… moreNicole Decenick
Hands down the most authentic and delicious Italian subs I’ve had in a long time. The bread is perfect, the ingredients are fresh, and every sandwich is packed with flavor. You can tell a lot of care goes into what they make.
But honestly, what makes this place even better is the owner. He is incredibly kind, welcoming, and truly passionate about his shop.
If you’re looking for a real, no-shortcuts Italian sub and great service to match, this place is an absolute must. I’ll definitely be back!!
… moreMatthew Wallace
Captains log star date 2/13/26
Week 2 of trying every sandwich on menu until we find something we dont like.
Henry Hill sandwich on Brooklyn Rye and the Italian cutlet on seeded roll were both superb. No notes.
Peter’s conflict resolution with unruly customers? Fantastic.
We really enjoyed the sandwiches, and Peter continues to impress with his customer service. Being greeted like we had been there a hundred times felt welcoming.
… moreCake Phosk
You’re not going for the atmosphere, you’re going for the food and the people.
Wish we had taken a photo of the food but we literally were too excited to eat! Ordered a Balboa on a sesame seeded roll and a Grinder which was a bunch of great Italian cold cut staples a fresh piece of Foccacia.
The owner? (Peter??) was sooo nice and knowledgeable. He came out and talked to us while stocking their fridges and gave us a sample of their Pastrami.
Love when staff is passionate about their work and the products they sell. By far two of the best sandwiches we’ve ever had !
It gives DiNick’s a run for their money as far as hot roast porks go!
… morePhillip Dillulio
Polpetti Italian Deli is hands down my favorite spot in Richmond. The sandwiches are unbelievable—exactly like the best Italian delis I grew up with back in New York. The chicken cutlet sandwiches are my favorite and never miss. Do yourself a favor and add the long hot peppers to just about any sandwich.
Peter and Georgia, the owners, are fantastic people, which makes the place even better. This is a true local, family-run business that’s absolutely worth supporting. The food is phenomenal and genuinely New York–style Italian deli quality.
Don’t skip the desserts either—the rainbow cookies and cannolis are outstanding. And if you’re catering, the kids’ mac and cheese is a guaranteed crowd favorite for both kids and adults.
If you’re looking for a real New York–style Italian deli in Richmond, Polpetti is the place.
… moredoug budryk
Had what I feel may be the best sandwich in the the area. The Italian is so well balanced, fresh and flavorful. Would absolutely hold its own among Italian delis up north. Wow!
… moreAnne Marie Afrasiniei
Headed up to Richmond for a day trip and decided to stop by Polpetti after looking up some of the local deli spots. With such great reviews, we had to give it try. SOOO glad we did because I think I found my new favorite sandwich!!! Got the Soprano (add banana peppers, no mayo) and it was probably my favorite sandwich ever!!! It’s been almost a week and I’m still thinking about it. My only regret is sharing it with my husband LOL!! From the sesame seeded bun, to the tang of the olive spread/vinaigrette/banana peppers, and then the heartiness of the meat trio, it was perfect! Can’t wait to come back, have another Soprano to myself, and try more of their great food!!!
… moreBrandon Ellis
Seriously, Some of the best sandwiches in Richmond. Peter is super consistent with ingredients and presentation. It always taste how you expect.
… moreChelsea Swann
Stopped in with some friends to grab lunch yesterday. Super friendly owner, there were about 6 people ahead of us but service was quick and he kept the line moving. All of the sandwiches sounded great, but I ordered the Henry Hill on the seeded rye bread and was blown away! Definitely one of the top 5 sandwiches I’ve ever had. Loaded with pastrami, and the Cole slaw gave it a really satisfying crunch.
I made my way through half of the sandwich eating in at the counter by the window, and decided to save the other half for dinner. I’ll be back soon! Excited to explore the menu.
I heard that for Super Bowl Sunday he’s bringing in bread from Philly for some classic cheesesteaks- I trust Polpetti to do it right.
… moreChristopher Robin
Yeah this place is hands down the only place to get a real italian sandwich in Richmond. Packed with quality ingredients on fresh, crusty bread. So much flavor in every single bite! Tasted just like the sandwiches I used to get in Italy. It is so legit that The Soprano made my italian born and raised boyfriend emotional to smell and taste it! Service is a little slow but well worth the wait knowing they’re a small family owned place that puts alot of care into their food. We will definitely return to try every other sandwich they have and will be happy to wait any amount of time for them 🙂
… more