Martins Pizza

  4.2 – 199 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery Martins Pizza 53572

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Order: Order online

order.toasttab.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Martins Pizza located in Mt. Horeb, WI

Martins Pizza has you covered, pizza, wings, loaded subs and appetizers! Delivery available to Mt. Horeb and Blue Mounds!

Martins Pizza 1213 Springdale St – Order Online

… Martins Pizza 1213 Springdale St. 1213 Springdale St, Mount Horeb, WI. Pizza. Appetizers & Tots. Jumbo Bone-In Wings. Boneless wings. Sticks. Roll ups.

Martins Pizza | Mount Horeb WI – Facebook

1213 Springdale St, Mt Horeb, WI 53572-2016, United States, Mount Horeb, WI, United States, 535… Links. . martinspizza …

Reviews

Lisa Buchner
Great pizza and great service from a local family run pizza spot in Mt Horeb! I have used them several times for work events and my staff has enjoyed everything!
… more
Emily Hansel
Look, I never got to try the pizza cuz the ordering experience was so terrible. Their website says they take online orders. But click the link and guess what – nope! Not accepting online orders after all! So we call and confirm right up front that they offer delivery in-town – yes! We get through placing our entire order only to find out, at the very end of a very inefficient call, that actually they’re too far behind on orders and aren’t offering delivery.

I wasted like 30min trying to order from this local spot. Don’t say you take online orders or do in-town delivery if it’s not actually true, guys. Guess I’m going with pizza hut.
… more
Venugopal Reddy
We tried meat lovers pizza, calzone and sweet knots all are fantastic especially the New Yorker pizza with the topping pepperoni was incredible, the crust was perfectly crisp on the outside and soft Inside, with just the right amount of chew .
They delivered just in time Hot and fresh.
Keep it up guys
… more
Shawn Lennix
Oct 2025
This is the only place I go for barbecue chicken pizza! We are a big fan of the margherita pizza as well.

May 10 2023 update…
Formerly hip hop pizza now Martin’s Pizza. Resident of Mount Horeb for almost 20 years. I really really want to support local businesses. Order was pricey. Pizza was only okay. Cheese was a little too salty. Garlic knots were, uh, interesting. I’d prefer real butter with crushed garlic over the garlic powder these were made with. Keep trying guys. See you in a couple months for try #2.

3 years prior under different owners and name…
Really good pizza. Prompt delivery, but $28 for a thin crust, meatless pizza is a bit much these days to warrant another order.
… more
Peanuts Jelly
Really good food! I recommend this place, they have good pizzas and wings. Best place!
… more
Kyle Cupp
The food was absolutely fantastic! We had “the Garrett”, meat lovers, garlic twist, cinnamon twist, wings, and puppy chow it all hit the spot. Great local family owned restaurant.
… more
Sarah Sutter
Excellent pizza! Love your new traditional sausage! Had the perfect amount of kick to it. Quick service, great value.
… more
Ellen Walton
We tried three different pizzas, two of them were gluten-free. They were all absolutely delicious! I think they’re gluten-free crust is probably the best I’ve ever had!
… more
dana Jacquin
I highly recommend PipPop Pizza. The pizza was fresh and absolutely delicious. The store was clean, the crew was fast and very friendly. If you need delicious pizza and some awesome appetizers, this is your place!
… more
David Pellas
Excellent crust, flavorful sauce, and a generous portion of buffalo mozzarella. If you crave a Jersey-style pizza, this is the best I have had in Wisconsin.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment