Amanda Caldwell
Usually love this place but come on with the portions for the price?! My husband brought home what they packaged/charged me as “2 scoops” and I opened this. How is this two scoops? What a ripoff.
… moreNick McLeod
The place itself is a real treat! Great menu and service, the parlor looks like it’s been transported from a lost era of history. Ice cream was fantastic, will definitely get the Dutch baby or Belgian waffle next time! 5 out of 5 sugar cones.
… moreNani Shubladze
The ice cream is amazing, the environment is amazing, and the many options for ice creams, cones, cups, and add ons are also amazing. It’s just the employees who are kind of rude here. It’s not all of them, but there was a blonde woman who didn’t pay attention to my order, she messed multiple things up, and she really didn’t care about giving the customers the best experience they could have, it’s more like she was rushed and wanted to get out of there quicker.
… moreJo-Ann Orsini
Skookie is the best! Even with 1 scoop, it’s still a meal! Delicious chocolate chip cookie dough baked in a cast iron pan, topped with ice cream, a topping of your choice, whipped cream, and of course a cherry on top!
… moreMichelle Rynkewicz
They are still decoratin inside after reopening, but are very cute. The old time parlor feel is special and I’ve never seen an ice cream place that looks like this one.
The options were very cool and authentic. I got my son strawberry ice cream and it had actual pieces of strawberry in it. I got Raspberry Truffle and it was fantastic. Raspberry was swirled through it and so were actual truffles. I can’t wait to go back with my family.
… moreJon Walka
Old fashioned ice cream shop feel. Always amazing flavors and amazing ice cream. Haven’t had anything I wasn’t in love with there.
… moreDominic vallejo
Very good ice cream loved it various flavors and super good
… morebklyn11217
The ice cream was delicious! And they were open later than everyone else so we had to check it out. Serving size is beyond generous and the price is right. Clean store, friendly service and I noticed you can host parties there too
… moreCharles Santomero
Best ice cream by far in the entire area! Love the old time feel of the place. A bit bare bones on the inside, but I love the classic cartoons that are continuously projected on one wall, and the elevated toy train track running overhead. My wife and I are very picky about our ice cream sundaes, and we so appreciate the quality ingredients Nellie Bly’s uses. So delicious!
… moreDereq
It’s a throwback looking ice cream parlor, quite quaint. Service was good. The freshly made waffle sundae was delicious. It was my first time eating peanut butter swirl ice cream, very tasty. I’ll have to bring my family back to have some.
… more