Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 30 N White Horse Pike, Hammonton, NJ 08037
Phone: (609) 878-3744
Website: http://www.costellospizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Costellos Pizzeria and Wings | Galloway | Hammonton | Smithville
Welcome to Costellos Pizza with three convienant locations in South Jersey.”
Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings – Hammonton, NJ – 30 N White Horse …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-8:45 PM; Shop address is 30 N White Horse Pike, Hammonton, NJ 0803730 N White Horse Pike, Hammonton, NJ 08037; (609) 878-3744.
Costello’s Pizzeria and Wings | Hammonton NJ – Facebook
Costello’s Pizzeria and Wings is located on The White Horse Pike in beautiful Hammonton, NJ. Pizza place · $. . Follow. Details.
Last Updates
Reviews
Jackie Steinbronn
PROS: Located right in Smithville. Beautiful view of the lake and picnic tables outside. They have a large menu and a variety of huge slices to choose from when you want a quick bite. They have daily dinner specials. Their spinach and artichoke dip was delicious. They gave it to me as a to-go order by accident but it came out very fresh and I think that’s the secret to this place.. order everything to-go even if you plan on sitting. The girl behind the counter was very sweet, patient, smiled and made recommendation. They do bring the food to your table instead of calling you back up to the counter.
CONS: I am a buffalo chicken pizza connoisseur as I get it everywhere I go. I can’t stress enough how many buffalo chicken slices I’ve had in my life. Unfortunately, it wasn’t good at all for me. I wish my review was different as they say they’re known for this type of pizza. The buffalo sauce was sweet, the chicken was chewy and the slices were very limp. I did not expect the sweetness but kept an open mind about it. When I was almost done eating my slice, I couldn’t finish it because it was too sweet for me. I can appreciate how they put a spin on it like (sweet heat.) Lastly, I know flies are annoying and hard to handle in the summer, but several of them swarming around our table was ridiculous. Eating while swatting flies off our food and face the whole time was not my idea of dining in.
Overall it wasn’t that bad and I might give it another try one day.
… moreCONS: I am a buffalo chicken pizza connoisseur as I get it everywhere I go. I can’t stress enough how many buffalo chicken slices I’ve had in my life. Unfortunately, it wasn’t good at all for me. I wish my review was different as they say they’re known for this type of pizza. The buffalo sauce was sweet, the chicken was chewy and the slices were very limp. I did not expect the sweetness but kept an open mind about it. When I was almost done eating my slice, I couldn’t finish it because it was too sweet for me. I can appreciate how they put a spin on it like (sweet heat.) Lastly, I know flies are annoying and hard to handle in the summer, but several of them swarming around our table was ridiculous. Eating while swatting flies off our food and face the whole time was not my idea of dining in.
Overall it wasn’t that bad and I might give it another try one day.
Rita L
Hammonton location severely lacks in consistency of quality.
Wings can be awesome or be shitake. Same with pizza, never know what you’re going to get.
Tails are somewhat consistently decent.
Makes me hesitant to try other items from them i.e. cheesesteak, eggplant parm or salads. People work hard for their money, don’t want to waste it just for the food to go to waste cause no one cares to finish it.
The only reason I bother ordering from them anymore is because of the slice app honestly
… moreWings can be awesome or be shitake. Same with pizza, never know what you’re going to get.
Tails are somewhat consistently decent.
Makes me hesitant to try other items from them i.e. cheesesteak, eggplant parm or salads. People work hard for their money, don’t want to waste it just for the food to go to waste cause no one cares to finish it.
The only reason I bother ordering from them anymore is because of the slice app honestly
Kenny Brady
Pizza was good, but the Buffalo Mac & Cheese bites were horrific and the dough tasted off. Not to mention, you get two egg rolls for the price of $9, and there cut in half in the container. That’s robbery #1
Robbery #2 is the smallest little slice of Cheesecake for $8.99?? Actually ridiculous this place gives a slice the size for a child.
Won’t be returning
… moreRobbery #2 is the smallest little slice of Cheesecake for $8.99?? Actually ridiculous this place gives a slice the size for a child.
Won’t be returning
Lee Blackburne
My go to for lunch, not only is the staff amazing but so is the food. Large authentic portions and nicely priced. Absolutely I adore the young lady in the front she is such a doll. Favorite is their pizza next to their salads !
… moreDrew Stanley
Very nice and attentive staff! Food is delicious and worth it as well!
… moreSpeedy
3 stars just because it was okay .. i ordered a cheesteak and it barely had any cheese on it ..
… moreHood TV
Now ima be honest, I got Pizza And Wings Last night and everything was disgusting The wings was nasty and sitting in to much sauce, the blue cheese taste like Mayonnaise, Pizza taste like it had a chemical on it like you smell in wood shop. But they Burgers and fries are very good, and that’s all I will order from them for now on. I gotta find better Pizza and wings around here.
… moreBrant Goose
Everything you ask for you say they don’t have it. I go in there. I said the app isn’t working from the slice app to get the free pizza and then as I’m leaving I see a rewards card thing. I could have used when I bought the pizza. I ask them you have a little cup? We could give the dog some drink. They don’t have it, I ask them. Do they have any dipping sauce for the pizza? No. Way way better than Domino’s.
… moresidneyvicious11
Ordered a salad and tails. Nearly broke my teeth on the tails they were so hard. The chicken in the salad was also hard as a rock. Spent $25 just to throw it all in the garbage. My dog wouldn’t even eat the chicken out of the salad and he loves chicken. Will not be going back here again. Save your money because the food w
Is horrible.
… moreIs horrible.
Shannon Hammer
Got the buffalo tails and they were delicious! Chicken was very moist!! Will definitely be back!
… more