Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Black Iron Burger Theater District, we’re all about burgers done right. That means handcrafted patties and lots of tasty sides, plus cold drinks from our full bar. We’re in the heart of the Theater District, so we’re perfect for grabbing a meal before or after a show. But any time’s a good time for a burger! Not into takeout? Stick around to catch the game—we’ll make sure you never miss a play.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 250 W 54th St, New York, NY 10019
Phone: (646) 906-9977
Website: http://www.blackironburger.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.comopentable.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Black Iron Burger | Nobody Beats Our Meat | Order Online or Dine …
BLACK IRON BURGER. a close up of a sandwich on a plate. MIDTOWN WEST. 245 WEST 38TH STREET. NEW YORK, NY 10018. Theater District. 250 WEST 54TH STREET. NEW YORK …
THEATRE DISTRICT | Hours + Location | Nobody Beats Our Meat
Wherever You Join Us In New York City, Black Iron Burger Will Always Feel Like Home … Hours & Location. 250 West 54th Street, New York, NY 10019 · 212-447 …
BLACK IRON BURGER (@blackironburger) – Instagram
#1 Best Burger in NYC by @zagat & @tripadvisor Midtown | 245 W 38th St. Theatre District | 250 W 54th St.
Last Updates
Reviews
Raquel Parra
Black Iron Burger is a great spot if you’re looking for a cozy place with really good burgers and a relaxed atmosphere. The restaurant itself is quite small, but that actually adds to its charm—it feels warm, welcoming, and comfortable rather than crowded or noisy.
The star of the place is definitely the food. The meat was excellent: juicy, flavorful, and clearly high quality. Everything tasted fresh and well prepared, and the portions were very satisfying. You can tell they take their burgers seriously. The overall menu is simple but very well executed, which is always a good sign.
The service was another big plus. The staff were extremely friendly, attentive, and fast, which made the whole experience very smooth and enjoyable. A detail that really stood out is that an 18% tip is already included, so you don’t have to worry about doing any calculations at the end of the meal—very convenient, especially if you’re visiting from abroad.
The atmosphere is pleasant and relaxed, and they also show sports on the screens, which is a nice touch if you’re into that. Overall, great food, great service, and a very comfortable vibe. Definitely a place I’d happily return to.
… moreThe star of the place is definitely the food. The meat was excellent: juicy, flavorful, and clearly high quality. Everything tasted fresh and well prepared, and the portions were very satisfying. You can tell they take their burgers seriously. The overall menu is simple but very well executed, which is always a good sign.
The service was another big plus. The staff were extremely friendly, attentive, and fast, which made the whole experience very smooth and enjoyable. A detail that really stood out is that an 18% tip is already included, so you don’t have to worry about doing any calculations at the end of the meal—very convenient, especially if you’re visiting from abroad.
The atmosphere is pleasant and relaxed, and they also show sports on the screens, which is a nice touch if you’re into that. Overall, great food, great service, and a very comfortable vibe. Definitely a place I’d happily return to.
Adem Mecit
The atmosphere was excellent and perfectly captured the essence of a classic American bar. From the décor to the overall vibe, it created a very enjoyable and authentic experience. Naturally, we decided to try the hamburgers.
Alongside the standard burger options on the menu, there was also the option to build your own burger by choosing the ingredients, which added a nice personal touch to the dining experience. We created our own burgers, and they turned out to be among the best flavors we experienced during our time in New York. The quality of the ingredients, the taste, and the overall presentation were outstanding.
The beer selection was also impressive, with a good variety of both draft and bottled beers available. The service was excellent—friendly, attentive, and efficient—exactly what you would hope for in a high-quality American bar.
I would highly recommend this place to anyone looking to enjoy a great hamburger in a lively yet comfortable atmosphere, especially those who appreciate an authentic American bar experience.
… moreAlongside the standard burger options on the menu, there was also the option to build your own burger by choosing the ingredients, which added a nice personal touch to the dining experience. We created our own burgers, and they turned out to be among the best flavors we experienced during our time in New York. The quality of the ingredients, the taste, and the overall presentation were outstanding.
The beer selection was also impressive, with a good variety of both draft and bottled beers available. The service was excellent—friendly, attentive, and efficient—exactly what you would hope for in a high-quality American bar.
I would highly recommend this place to anyone looking to enjoy a great hamburger in a lively yet comfortable atmosphere, especially those who appreciate an authentic American bar experience.
Mind Set On Travel
What a great atmosphere and amazing food. Make your own burger is a great way to take your tastes to the next level. The fries and onion rings are great complements to the burgers. We were able to get seated right away however could see this place filling up fast on the weekends when the musicals are going through the weekend.
… moreYanira Rosario
First of all, the freaking music is hot!!! Amazing! Nice mixes!! The it comes the drinks and the food. Wow! I could come here every week. Got a very good burger and yuca with guacamole, a strawberry basil martini, and a few more things. Thx to all the staff. They sure work in fast forward because they’re so quick in delivering everything. God bless them!!
… moreSean D
True NYC Burger Legend: Perfection on a Bun! Black Iron Burger absolutely delivered on its reputation. This was, without a doubt, one of the best burgers I have ever had.
I went straight for their namesake, the Black Iron Burger (two patties), cooked to a beautiful medium well. The beef was incredibly flavorful and juicy, perfectly complemented by the savory, sweet caramelized onions. Every bite was rich and satisfying.
On the side, the onion rings were the ideal companion. They had a light, crispy crust and were cooked to absolute perfection–no greasy sogginess here! To wash it all down, the fresh strawberry lemonade was tart, sweet, and genuinely refreshing.
The entire experience was seamless, with service to match the outstanding food quality. If you’re looking for a top-tier burger experience in NYC, stop searching and start eating here!
… moreI went straight for their namesake, the Black Iron Burger (two patties), cooked to a beautiful medium well. The beef was incredibly flavorful and juicy, perfectly complemented by the savory, sweet caramelized onions. Every bite was rich and satisfying.
On the side, the onion rings were the ideal companion. They had a light, crispy crust and were cooked to absolute perfection–no greasy sogginess here! To wash it all down, the fresh strawberry lemonade was tart, sweet, and genuinely refreshing.
The entire experience was seamless, with service to match the outstanding food quality. If you’re looking for a top-tier burger experience in NYC, stop searching and start eating here!
Lexi
Fabulous. Fabulous. Fabulous.
One of the best burgers I’ve ever had. Clean bathrooms. A layout that makes sense for the space. The music was at a reasonable volume to have a conversation. It’s in a prime location. They had a cutie patootie at the bar. It was fabulous. It was great.
My one constructive feedback would be: leave the hot young guys at the bar. As a single woman in NYC, I don’t come and sit at the bar and eat by myself because I love looking sad. I’m out here for the action and the hottie bartenders. Let’s be real.
Plus, this kid was actually good at his job. He had an amazingly accurate pour- just the right amount, almost to the rim but not enough for it to spill. I was not gypped on the alcohol in my drink. Left there feeling quite nice but not trashed. Excellent work team!
… moreOne of the best burgers I’ve ever had. Clean bathrooms. A layout that makes sense for the space. The music was at a reasonable volume to have a conversation. It’s in a prime location. They had a cutie patootie at the bar. It was fabulous. It was great.
My one constructive feedback would be: leave the hot young guys at the bar. As a single woman in NYC, I don’t come and sit at the bar and eat by myself because I love looking sad. I’m out here for the action and the hottie bartenders. Let’s be real.
Plus, this kid was actually good at his job. He had an amazingly accurate pour- just the right amount, almost to the rim but not enough for it to spill. I was not gypped on the alcohol in my drink. Left there feeling quite nice but not trashed. Excellent work team!
A Bansal
Black Iron Burger in the Theater District is a great spot for a quick bite when you are short on time. It is a nice, casual place with solid burgers and really delicious Cajun fries. The servers were very warm and quick to bring out the food, which makes it perfect before a show. Overall, it is a decent place if you just need something fast and satisfying.
… moreS Sullivillain
Loved it. Had a reservation and was seated promptly and ordered within 10mins of being seated. Food came about 10-15mins later. Delicious. Cajun fries were awesome. I’d consider returning. Would skip the milkshake tho.
… moreKristopher Klenotiz
I stopped by Black Iron Burger after a day at the park, and it was the perfect choice. The staff was incredibly welcoming and attentive from the moment I walked in. I went with their most popular standard burger, and it was absolutely delicious—definitely lived up to the hype!
The service was remarkably quick without feeling rushed, and the overall vibe was great. If you’re looking for a tasty meal and friendly faces, I highly recommend this spot. I’ll definitely be back!
… moreThe service was remarkably quick without feeling rushed, and the overall vibe was great. If you’re looking for a tasty meal and friendly faces, I highly recommend this spot. I’ll definitely be back!
Gato Amarillo
Ok, let me just say this…I actually own a high-end bar and restaurant in another state and this was by far one of the most amazing experiences my wife and I have had in many, many years. Everything was superb! The server “Junior” was top notch and the manager, “Franklin” was terrific! Excellent experience, truly! The burgers are next level and so is the fish sandwich! You won’t be disappointed, I promise!
… more