Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Cindy’s Pizza is Stillwater’s home for fresh, handmade New York-style pizza, Take & Bake pizzas, and Oklahoma’s largest 30-inch pizza. Our dough is hand-stretched daily, our sauce is award-winning, and every pizza is made with the highest-quality ingredients. Whether you’re looking for the best pizza in Stillwater, fresh frozen dough balls, take-and-bake pizzas, or locally made sauces and spices, Cindy’s Pizza delivers unmatched quality. Family-owned, crafted in-house, and proudly made in Stillwater since 2008. Stillwater pizza Pizza Stillwater OK Best pizza in Stillwater New York style pizza Stillwater Take and bake pizza Stillwater Handmade pizza dough Stillwater Fresh pizza sauce Stillwater Frozen pizza dough balls Stillwater
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 4–8 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3507 S Husband St, Stillwater, OK 74074
Website: http://cindyspizzas.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cindy’s Pizza Stillwater OK | Brick Oven NY Style Pizza
Located in the heart of Stillwater, Oklahoma, Cindy’s Pizzas is your go-to destination for authentic New York pizza.
Cindy’s Pizza | Stillwater OK – Facebook
Cindy’s Pizza. The best NY style brick oven pizza in Stillwater, Oklahoma. Pizza place · $$ · (405) 780-5123. . Follow …
Menu – Cindy’s Pizza Stillwater OK
Explore Cindy’s Pizzas menu featuring homemade dough, take-and-bake options, and delicious variety for every palate. Let’s dive into our menu.
Last Updates
Reviews
Andrea Strader
My family absolutely loves Cindy’s Pizza! The pizza is always so delicious, it has enough of everything, the thick crust is my favorite part!! I highly recommend and it doesn’t upset my families stomach which most all pizza does for us!
… moreErik Spielvogel
Our first order was a bit of a mistake… but my wife really liked it… so that’s what we get now. We really like the pizzas, very nice people… super to where we live in the country, so we really enjoy the short drive, nice people and great food!
… moreGrace Gordon
Been told to try this place for weeks and finally got around to it! So worth it! It’s the perfect pizza and being from the northeast it’s hard to find that but finally did!
… moreBrooke Holloway
Absolutely amazing pizza!!! The garlic breadsticks are also delicious! Cheesecake is amazing as well! 10/10 recommend!
… moreDeuce
Best pizza I’ve had in a while!! Also super nice people. Highly recommend coming to eat here
… moreBillie Hall
Wow! Cindy’s Pizza is the real deal. True Italian brick oven pizza that completely blew me away. The crust is perfection—charred, airy, and addictive. The ingredients taste so fresh, and the flavors are perfectly balanced without being heavy. It’s like a little trip to Italy in every bite. Can’t recommend it enough!
… moreKristina –
As a native NYer and former Chicagoan, I’m a pizza snob. My family is dairy-free and we’ve had to go to OKC or Tulsa for dairy-free pizza (or make it myself) until now! We kindly asked Cindy to carry vegan cheese and she agreed to give it a try. Her crust and sauce are absolutely incredible and we are very impressed. The cheese is Violife vegan mozzarella; it melts and stretches, and the taste is spot on. We are so happy to finally have a local option, and it’s amazing!
Update: the vegan cheese is no longer offered. ☹️ Luckily there’s another option in Stillwater now, but we wish it was an option at Cindy’s!
… moreUpdate: the vegan cheese is no longer offered. ☹️ Luckily there’s another option in Stillwater now, but we wish it was an option at Cindy’s!
Jesse Prickett
Best pizza I’ve had not just in Stillwater but in Oklahoma!
The order was ready at the exact time estimated when ordered.
The staff was also extremely friendly!
We have a new favorite weekend pizza place!
… moreThe order was ready at the exact time estimated when ordered.
The staff was also extremely friendly!
We have a new favorite weekend pizza place!
Ry Hollo
Wonderful pizza and cheesecake! Great staff and owner!
Food: …
… moreFood: …
Michael Madsen
Top notch everything. Ordered a pizza w/pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom, very delicious and I didn’t feel bad after eating it like the other pizza places. Also got some cheesecake . Don’t get pizza from anywhere else in town, definitely come here. Best to order in advance because everything is hand made and cooked to order, all ingredients are proprietary and you can taste it. Will return!
… more