Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
In-house catering and banquet rooms available, call (715) 696-3493. Located in Spread Eagle, WI (even though the address shows Florence) on the curve on the border of MI and WI. CALL FOR RESERVATIONS (online reservations are NOT available). WE WILL NOT HONOR ONLINE RESERVATIONS MADE THROUGH GOOGLE. We are known for our famous Italian food, perfectly cooked steaks, and fresh seafood. We serve quality Italian food in an enjoyable atmosphere. All of our pasta, sauces, bread, meatballs are prepared by hand in our kitchen. Our steaks are USDA choice steer. Since all of our Italian dinners and steaks are cooked to order, it may take a little longer for your dinner to be completed. This assures that you are getting the freshest possible food.
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 695 US-2, Florence, WI 54121
Phone: (715) 696-3493
Website: https://elcapitansupperclub.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menu for El Capitan Supper Club
695 Highway US-2, Florence / Spread Eagle, WI 54121. Menu. In-house banquet room available, call (715) 696-3493. Please call for all pricing due to the rise …
El Capitan Supper Club in Spread Eagle, Wisconsin
El Capitan Supper Club is famous for our Italian food, perfectly cooked steaks and fresh sea food. Our banquet room has a private bar and seats 60 people.
El Capitan Supper Club | Spread Eagle WI – Facebook
El Capitan Supper Club, Spread Eagle. 1718 likes · 17 talking about this · 47 were here. Authentic Italian Food.
Reviews
Dan Lentsch
Had a fantastic dinner, was shocked how good the grilled tuna was. Who knew they brought in fresh tuna up here. Homemade gnocchi was quite tasty as well.
… moreErin Kelley
Italian influenced menu with good nightly specials, family friendly and decent prices.
Most recently (July 2025) with our large family of 10, great service and food from Jesy (server) and Ginger (bar), awesome martinis.
Be sure and make a reservation!
… moreMost recently (July 2025) with our large family of 10, great service and food from Jesy (server) and Ginger (bar), awesome martinis.
Be sure and make a reservation!
Leena Hawk
ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTED AND DISAPOINTED. I was browsing resturants in Spread Eagel for my upcoming trip and saw disturbing reviews. This one man, had said that they gave him expired shrimp, he said that the shrimp had a strong fishy taste/smell thats not normal shrimp smell. He even had to spit it into the napkin! Nothing was freshly made. In his salad the tomatoes, lettuce, were soggy. He also had pasta and said that it was very raw flowery taste. Another person that posted a review said how he explained that he has a dairy allergy and that they didnt cook the steak in butter but put cheese on his steak… My sister and brother in law said that they’ve had bad experiences with the food aswell! Such as it being expired, even said that their food is smothered in grease, NOT in a good delicious way. Please save your money and do not come here, the food is way too expensive to be this TERRIBLE!!
… moreKelsey Allen
i’ve eaten at El Capitan for 12 years now and i’ve had nothing short of positive experiences. The homemade gnocchi and homemade bread pair beautifully with the authentic homemade red sauce. I am always greeted with smiling faces and superb service too. I highly recommend El Capitan!
… moreLeena
My family and I came to eat here, it took a while to get our food out. The food was not good. I heard from a reliable sourse that their hot water turns off often and the manager still makes the dishwasher employees clean the dishes in cold water which is a heath hazard. The atmosphere is nice, very well kept clean. The waitresses are nice as well, however, the food and the rumors(no hot water) not so much…
… moreBen Frost
We got to El Capitan right before they needed to serve a big wedding. To make sure we got our food quickly, they told us about this so we could plan accordingly. The drinks were mixed perfectly. The food was great and the service was absolutely amazing! Can’t wait to go back.
… moreRobert Snapp
Our extended family met at El Capitan Supper Club for dinner and enjoyed a nice meal with great service. The wait staff was experienced in mature. Numerous Italian pasta dishes to choose from, fresh salad, and good bread. This restaurant has been open for a number of years serving the local community. We enjoyed eating there well in town.
… moreEarl Lakia
Had a fillet, baked potato and a salad. Fillet was great and potato were great. Presentation was marginal, fillet on top of a piece of bread. Plate seemed stark, could have put potato on the same plate instead of an additional plate, offer a nice vegetable, instead of lettuce with three cherry tomatoes. Not a bad experience and I hope it was just a one time experience.
… moreKristi Vaught
This place is fantastic! They had a couple parties happening at the time we walked in, but you’d never know as everything was wonderful from the service to the drinks to hot food!
Our server was wonderful and explained everything in detail as we had never dined there. The pasta is made fresh every day and the sauces are made to order.
My only recommendation is to make reservations before going(or you may not get to eat!) We didn’t know this and just walked in. However, we were the last walk in they could take and it was 530 on a Sunday afternoon.
… moreOur server was wonderful and explained everything in detail as we had never dined there. The pasta is made fresh every day and the sauces are made to order.
My only recommendation is to make reservations before going(or you may not get to eat!) We didn’t know this and just walked in. However, we were the last walk in they could take and it was 530 on a Sunday afternoon.
Lukas Medwed
Unassuming restaurant on the street. Service is very courteous and caters to the customers’ wishes.
The staff is friendly and always strives to ensure satisfaction.
The food is very tasty. We had baked garlic bread with a special sauce for dipping. The main course was pepper steak with mushrooms and fettucine, which was a real explosion of flavor.
… moreThe staff is friendly and always strives to ensure satisfaction.
The food is very tasty. We had baked garlic bread with a special sauce for dipping. The main course was pepper steak with mushrooms and fettucine, which was a real explosion of flavor.