Katrena Love Lanzetta
This spacious venue is perfect for any size event. The lighting and seating were cozy and well-lit, creating a warm atmosphere. The acoustic environment was excellent, allowing for both intimate conversations and addressing the entire group. Our attentive waitress ensured that our pizza and wings were delivered promptly and perfectly timed to our event. They have an apple dessert pizza and they serve a whole spread for their lunch buffet. MUST TRY AGAIN !!!
… moreNick Zak
5 stars when they’re good, 2 when they’re not. There’s a real consistency problem with the wings and for what places charge these days they should be great every time. When made fresh and cooked properly these are my favorite take out wings. But probably 50% of the time they are undercooked and/or under-sauced. Today was a trifecta of double cooked (precooked earlier in the day and then flash fried), under cooked and not enough sauce. BTW – I order crispy and saucy every time. On top of that there were a few gross ones in the mix. For $55 I’d expect better quality. From now on I’ll order pizza only from here and get my wings elsewhere.
… moreVictoria “Vee” Underwood
First time there today. We sat in the seating area in the back. Which I never knew was there. We had pretzel boy appetizer, it was good. Then had large cheese and pepperoni pizza with 20 wings half hot half barbecue. Pizza was amazing the server gave us options. What kind of sauce we wanted I am personally not a fan of sweet sauce so we got the other kind. Pepperoni ratio to cheese was on point. Wings you know when a place selling good wings when they are not glossy.
… moreDonna Wlosinski
Went on a Saturday afternoon for a get together with former co workers. We had plenty of room for our gathering at the bar area we had maybe 15 people there. The bar tenders were great we were there long enough for a shift change great service by the staff . My daughter ordered the lemon pepper wings was crispy full of flavor she loved them . Kiddos on the home made blue cheese was a hit. She wished it came with some celery though maybe next time she will ask if she could get some! I had some pretzels with cheese dip they were nice and warm and buttery. a co worker ordered pizza for everyone looked and tasted great nice pepperoni and great cheese but the sauce was sweet wasn’t expecting that but I prefer not sweet! Overall had a great time I wanted to come try the pizza and wings before I’ll come again in the future I’m not that far from there
… moresteve c
It’s a nice place, but it’s been a nice place for a long time, when it was Mooney’s and whatever it was before that, and whatever it was before that. Papa‘s pizza is pretty legit. Sweet sauce stands up to the test similar to Molinaros in Lockport. I personally couldn’t eat more than one slice of the sweet sauce, as it’s almost like a dessert pizza. Certainly worth the experience. It was between shifts or something so the service wasn’t all that great, the girls working there made you feel like you were annoying them. So not a great first impression. Launch special two slices and a Coke for under 10 bucks. Most surprisingly the pizza came out looking good, instead of looking like it had been under a heat lamp for three hours.
… moreDanielle Bagarozzi
I typically always order from my favorite places because I’m very picky with my food.
For my daughters 13th birthday we decided to try a new place and chose Papa’s pizza. Normally pizza places have their own delivery services. They didn’t, and I had to go through a 3rd party. Long story short, the door dasher robbed us all and stole my food. Papas not only made me aware, but remade the food instantly and delivered it personally to me to make it better.
It wasn’t even their fault and they actually gave a shit. The food was phenomenal. And the way they treated me after such a shitty experience that wasn’t even their fault, was A1. I will choose Papa’s pizza each and every time we go to order pizza and wings from now on.
If you want not only great food, but awesome customer service to go along with it, this is the place for you.
Thank you Papa’s for being what all businesses should be.
… moreJett Y
We heard good things about the pizza here and couldn’t wait to come here. Unfortunately it was a disappointing experience. We came in at 6pm, ordered pizza and wings at 6:15. Didn’t get our food until 7pm. There was only 2 other tables with customers. Not busy at all. Parts of the underside of the pizza was burnt. The waitress never stopped by to see if we needed anything.
Sure the pizza was still good, but this is Buffalo – there’s a ton other great pizza joints that serve great pizza with better customer service.
… moreSa’Lena W
We were searching for a new place that has authentic ‘Buffalo’ pizza, and we found a new favorite!! We ordered takeout for half double cheese and double pepperoni pizza and even had the choice of sweet or traditional sauce, and we chose to mix the two. It was delicious and the mild wings were great too with lots of flavor and extra crispy. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreJeremy Lang
Recently opened up in the new Mooneys on Union in West Seneca, since opening I’ve ordered two pizzas and 90 wings the last 2 weeks, everything has been fantastic. I highly recommend the Cajun Honey Mustard double dip charred wings, 9.6/10.
… moreRobert Hausrath
While I don’t find myself in the Buffalo southtowns often, I was down there this past Thursday and grabbed a large cheese & pepperoni pizza and an order of fingers and fries to take back to the office to share with everyone.
The commentary was plentiful, frequent, and all positive!
It started from the moment that I walked in the door with people asking what smelled so good.
The pie, with a mix of Papa’s sweet and regular sauces looked like a masterpiece!
Their sauce gives the pizza an unapologetically unique and delicious taste that all four that tried it loved. It was absolutely delicious!
An odd comment that I have to make is that this seems to be the only pizzeria that actually knows how to cut their pizza! It comes apart as it should, without ripping it to shreds.
The cheese is great and offers a nice pull. The cup & char pepperoni is the perfect topping for a simple, everyone’s gonna love it, pizza.
Papa’s fingers were also fantastic! Ordered medium, they were not overly sauced and had a very light amount of seasoning, perhaps pepper, added.
Give Papa’s a try, you won’t regret it! Just apologize to your current favorite shared of time!
… more