Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 276a N Broadway, Sleepy Hollow, NY 10591
Phone: (914) 373-2788
Website: http://horsemanbagels.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Horseman Bagels (@horsemanbagels) – Instagram
Artisan Bagel Shop and Carvel Ice Cream! open 7am-5pm for bagels and 9am-9pm for ice cream! These egg sandwiches were next level @horsemanbagels …
Horseman Bagels Delivery Menu | 276 North Broadway Sleepy Hollow
Order delivery or pickup from Horseman Bagels in Sleepy Hollow! View Horseman Bagels’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with …
Horseman Bagels | Cozy Spot for Colorful Bagels & Morning Joy in …
Address : 276a N Broadway, Sleepy Hollow, NY 10591, United States. Phone : +1 … Stepping into Horseman Bagels in Sleepy Hollow feels like discovering …
Reviews
amanda eagleston
We absolutely loved visiting Horseman bagels. They are freshly made and delicious. The bagels had the perfect amount of chewy and crispy, crackly crust. My husband got the lox spread and said it was fresh and tasty. The building itself is very small, with limited seating.
… moreDavid Garcia
Wonderfully made fresh bagels. I came on a Saturday for a breakfast sandwich and the service was excellent with little wait time. The small seating area provides pleasant views of a busy intersection in Sleepy Hollow and it’s a great place to admire the sunrise. Highly recommend.
… moreZachary Debottis
Not your typical bagel spot. You can tell the cream cheese is made here fresh – don’t forget to ask for toasted!
As a side note, their bacon is really good.
… moreAs a side note, their bacon is really good.
Mei Deng
BEC was too salty. Looks better than it tastes. Tried friend’s lox bagel – better. Not worth the long line
… moreMelanie Mengüş
Had a lunch here during my first visit to Sleepy Hollow. I was intrigued by the logo. They have a lot of choices for the flavours and the bread type. My husband and I both got smoked salmon bagel with pumpernickel bread for him and onion for me. Both were generous and delicious. Also the price was very good for the quantity and quality. Service was very friendly and quick. The only downside was that there wasn’t any toilets inside.
… moreCassy Marx
Came in because we saw some t-shirts in the window and to check out their baked goods. Cookies were good, and the staff was friendly. If your looking for some t-shirts they have a nice selection as well.
… moreKate
Small spot with some seating inside and out. Was a bit disappointed that they ran out of plain bagels fairly early for lunch around noon. Got a BEC on garlic bagel instead and the garlic was a little overpowering for the sandwich but decent.
… moreNaomi Wolski
The staff member was super nice and very helpful with making decisions and giving suggestions on what to get! The food was delicious! We are from out of town but would recommend to everyone who is visiting as well!
… moreCharlotte Campbell
Absolutely amazing bagels. They are in Tarrytown New York so you expect a bagel to be great because New York bagels are the best, but these are exceptional. They have the most amazing choices. I recommend you give them a try and if those that you are with would prefer something a bit more sweet, they share their shop with a Carvel!!
… moreGfan
Really good bagels. A good variety of flavors as well as cream cheeses and other add-ons.
For parking go up the hill road to the right of the building and the first left is a good sized lot with a staircase down to the front entrance.
Staff is friendly and quick.
Good food anytime of the year
… moreFor parking go up the hill road to the right of the building and the first left is a good sized lot with a staircase down to the front entrance.
Staff is friendly and quick.
Good food anytime of the year