Robert Grant
Lia’s Pizzeria is hands down the best pizza on Long Island! Every time I visit, I’m blown away by the quality and flavor. The crust is perfectly crispy, and the ingredients are always fresh. My absolute favorite is the Margherita pizza – it’s simply divine! The balance of tomato, mozzarella, and basil is perfection. If you’re looking for an authentic pizza experience, Lia’s is the place to go. Highly recommended!
… moreBilly Guarton
Do Not Order from this restaurant. Absolutely the worst pizzeria I’ve ever dealt with. Walked in to pick up an order, one regular pizza pie, that should’ve been ready and was immediately told “10 more minutes.” Fine. I leave, come back, and suddenly it’s “another 5 minutes.” Then somehow—miraculously—they manage to completely ruin the pizza *after* taking it out of the oven. Like, not salvageable. Total failure.
Instead of owning the mistake, I’m told by the the guy that he now needs **20 more minutes** to remake it. This was at 3 PM, with no customers or other orders. If this is how they operate when it’s slow, I can’t imagine the disaster they turn into during any semblance of an actual rush.
Zero organization, zero urgency, zero respect for anyone’s time. The man in the front behaved in a hostile, dismissive, and unprofessional manner, resembling someone who was intoxicated and/or under the influence. When I finally said I was done wasting my time and walked out, the response from the guy was “never come back.” Trust me—that won’t be a problem. If this is how they run their business, they won’t be around long anyway.
Avoid this place at ALL costs unless you enjoy waiting forever, watching incompetence in real time, and leaving empty-handed. Complete joke of a pizza shop.
… moreM Wat
Wide variety of pizza to choose from. So far every slice I tried tasted good. Pizaa slice are on the pricey side.They aren’t any can sodas only 20oz, not a deal breaker. There is inside seating, big plus if you’re doing lunch with a colleagues.
… moreJohn Doherty
Lia’s Pizza is hands down the best pizza spot in Syosset! The crust is always perfectly crisp, the sauce has amazing flavor, and the cheese is top quality. Their specialty pies are incredible — especially the grandma and the buffalo chicken. The staff is super friendly and welcoming, and you can tell they really care about their customers. Whether I’m grabbing a quick slice or ordering for the whole family, the food is always fresh and consistent. Highly recommend if you’re looking for authentic, delicious pizza!
… moreLisa F.
Lia’s Pizza in Syosset is our little treasure. It’s clean and reasonably-priced. The pasta dishes are delicious and never overcooked as other pizzerias do. The owner is Italian and makes all the sauces. The paninis are excellent, and the grilled chicken with vegetables is so tasty and yet, lean. No other pizzeria in the area comes close.
… moreIrox Rox
This Place …… Is AWESOME. I did order chicken mushroom pizza slice. It was superb. The taste is phenomenal. And here the place is super clean. It’s really good for a quick pizza picked up. They already have pizza made and they Owen it and gives you within 5mints. And the customer service is extra ordinary. If you want they have plenty of pizza options. Here people are very friendly. And the dining place is really nice. Good for a family dinner or lunch too. Plenty of parking outside the store. I will go here again if you passing by syosset don’t forget to go here and enjoy some delicious Italian pizza. One pizza slice is more than enough for one person I paid around $3 some cents it’s really worth the money you paying.
… moreBrian Kupchik
Came here on recommendation for a pizza party after my 4 yr olds birthday. The pizza was delicious and so was their grilled chicken salad. The guys even brought out a carvel cake (that we brought in) and helped us make it fun for the kids. Great experience
… moreAnthony De Ingeniis
Friendly staff, fresh ingredients, and they open early compared to some of the other places in the area. Great variety of slices but really the sausage crumble vodka slice is to die for. Super thin, tasty and hits the spot.
… moreTony Donald
I buy two slice Regular p cheese normal price around 6$ this place the guy charge me almost 9 dollars, rip off !!!!
The guy asked me how you pay for the two slices. I told him cash, The guy still charge me sell tax even didn’t add this in the Cashier registration so the guy collect tax without to give any receipt to any customer, this place should be reported To IRS and Business bureau, To report this place to shut down. to all customer, please ask receipt and stay away from this location…
… moreMike_rochtikls
Expensive. Menu online is half the price what is actually.in store. Walk right out and went 20 feet to Mc donalds. It just simply isnt worth it…. how is a chicken parm hero almost $15, Do you owe money to the mob?
… more