Vanessa Grano
You guys just delivered a pizza fit for the gods. My husband and I both gasped when we opened the box. I’m pretty sure I involuntarily whispered “oh dear God, it’s beautiful” and if I didn’t, I was thinking it. I reviewed you on two platforms over how impressive this pizza is. Great job!
… moreMatt Levesque
Wicked Slice is a place to get a great pizza. That said, is a SMALL char char binks (hot honey meat pizza) a $25 pizza? Of course not. Its not a ripoff, it’s just excruciatingly expensive. If you’re ok with buying 2 small specialty pizzas with a small tip for $53 don’t let this salty review stop you.
Staff is efficient, but dry. It’s not their fault, I get it, you make your seating area look like your back room and no one will dine in. This makes the employees no longer care about the customer because they only have to deal with you for 2 mins.
Only thing I don’t enjoy about the pies are the crouton crust, but otherwise the thickness is perfect and the flavors are all there.
If the prices get better, I’ll certainly update this review. For now, this is Wicked Price.
… moreDonna Bruneau
I was born and raised in the New Haven area and moved to Hebron in 2023. I have been searching for good pizza since I got here. Last night we ordered from Wicked Slice and was thrilled with the pizza. Crust, cheese, sauce all on point. I have found my new favorite pizza place!
… moreMillie Falero
Our campground raved about Wicked slice pizza. So today we decided to try it. We did a takeout order. My husband had a calzon and I had a pizza. The calzon was excellent and the dipping sauce my husband absolutely loved, that was a surprised to me. The pizza was awesome. Thin crust golden brown lots of flavor. Really gooood pie. We will definitely go back to try some of their other unique pizza specialties.
… moreHannah Bassett
As someone who’s eaten at all the New Haven pizza joints, I have to say wicked slice is as good as, if not better, then Pepes, Modern or Bar. A good thin slice with great flavor and always hot
… moreCarl Neubauer
Hands down the best local pizza joint in the area! You can’t get anything closer to New Haven style pizza that’s this good anywhere else!
… moreMMRP Director
Stopped in for a quick slice. Hot and delicious. If you are someone who loves garlic, this is your pizza. Stupid delicious. Crust is delightful.
… moreKatie Cardwell
Ordered a calzone (very reasonably priced i might add) which “spilled its guts” in the oven, so the chefs made us another one and to apologise for the wait, gave us two free of charge. Both delicious!
… morekris heger
Really burnt pizza, this isn’t the first time I had issues with wicked slice. Unacceptable. When they cook pizza right they do a good job, you just never know what your going to get when it comes to quality.
… moreNathan C
Would help if they advertised that delivery stops at 8pm – but good food
… more