Chuck Mound
Sussex County NJ is making a strong comeback for Pizza in 2025. This was a home run. Started with the Grandma Pepperoni with Hot Honey. The star of the show was the crust. A nice crispy crust that was full of flavor. It was so good, I had to try a regular slice for the Pizza Hunters App. The crust on the regular was softer, but it worked in harmony with the cheese and sauce. Fantastic. Cannot wait to go back and send some other Pizza Hunters there to give it a try. Great job Edgar and staff. 5 Pie Yas
… moreGun Slinging Gringo
The pizza is like a mix between dominos and a local pizza joint. The slices are a decent size, sauce is 50/50, and the crust is decent.
… moreUlla Vinkman
We ordered catered food for a special 90th birthday party and Tuscana’s was wonderful to work with. Food was abundant, delicious, and reasonably priced. They were easy to work with and helped us to order what we needed. Will definitely order from them again!
… moreMichelle Murphy
Best food in the area!!!
We have had our Christmas dinner catered from Toscana for the past 3 years. Our family and guests always look forward to coming to our home every year because the food is so good. Edgar the owner always accommodates all our needs and the prices are very reasonable.
Thank you to everyone at Toscana.
The pizza is also amazing!
… moreDavid zapata
Went there for the first time tonight to order a pie with extra sauce. As I went to Pay, I wanted to make sure that the girl was charging me for the right pie And she looked like she got offended. She had the pizza man ring me up instead. I was hoping to enjoy my pizza and I realized that the pizza sauce Obviously I came from the can .I understand they all do but this particular sauce was horrible. I went there to try it for the very first time and I’m not sorry to say I won’t be back.
… morejustin seibert
I’ll start with the good: I’m a local and I eat here frequently. The food is always good and I never wait more than a few minutes when ordering something for take out. I have never gotten a wrong dish and it has always been hot, fresh, and quality.
My only complaint (and this is an incredibly small one) is that if you dine in, service is a tad slow as the same staff waiting on you in the dining area is also manning the counter; the counter/ to-go business is always booming and is understandably a priority to keep things moving.
… moreJason Cunas
Delicious pizza and great add to the neighborhood. The sauce is delightfully sweet and pairs perfectly with their choice of cheese. Order their zeppoles. Close your eyes on the first bite and they’ll transport you to your favorite moment down the shore or at the fair. The inside is all new decor. The staff is friendly. There is ample parking space. Looking forward to visiting again.
… moreJames Reinhardt
First visit ordered a couple slices with pepperoni and a couple of beef empanadas. Both were awesome in fact, the next day picked up whole pie. Again it did not disappoint, The crust was perfect and crispy the sauce was good and had the right amount of Pepperoni. Good food decent prices definitely recommend to everyone.
… moreamanda walsh
I cant say enough how horrible the service is. Tonight, I got a chicken roll, got to the middle, saw raw dough brought it to their attention, he argues its cheese. Im a baker and have been baking for 15 years, its not cheese and its not the first time.
The biggest issue, Absolutely never when they screw up can they admit it or just say sorry. I’ve given them a few chances after tonight and being the 2nd time I would love to call the health dept because of the nasty glares I get from the “manager”.
Best of luck and you wont see a penny of my money again.
… moreDes KF
Found this spot and decided to get lunch. I called in my order of the shrimp and broccoli with white sauce lunch special. When I arrived I parked in the plaza lot. I walked in and grabbed my food. I already paid over the phone. When I dug in the meal was good. It was seasoned nicely. The broccoli was nice and soft. I enjoyed my meal.
… more