Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Mario’s Italian Restaurant in Edgerton WI is operating with new owners, recognized as of 2025 and performing with the same pizza dough and sauce recipe provided by the previous owner, accompanied by an entirely new concept in menu items. The new menu highlights fresh ingredients used to craft made in house dishes. Features of Wisconsin products such as wine and ice cream. Atmosphere is quiet, casual, family friendly. Services include dine in, pickup, delivery, catering and room rental for large parties. Expect quality food and service. Ramp accessible in the back of the building entrance. Pickup order window located at the back entrance; front door opens to dining room. Approximately 40-person capacity with tables, booths and bar seating.
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 205 W Fulton St, Edgerton, WI 53534
Phone: (608) 561-6312
Website: https://www.facebook.com/people/Marios-Italian-Restaurant/61575934426567/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mario’s Italian Restaurant | Edgerton WI – Facebook
Mario’s Italian Restaurant, Edgerton. 1570 likes · 19 talking about this · 27 were here. New owners Aubrey and Benjamin Van Galder – Rinehart bringing…
Mario’s Italian Restaurant | Travel Wisconsin
Mario’s Italian Restaurant is a popular spot in Edgerton. The menu features dishes made in-house with fresh ingredients.
Mario’s Pizza (@MariosPizzaEdgerton) – Facebook
Mario’s Pizza. 1014 likes. We are a locally family owned and operated restaurant known for great pizza, Italian & American cuis.
Reviews
Scotty Brown
This place has outstanding food. All ingredients are premium and fresh. Truffle fries, hero Italiano sandwich, and the Super Mario pizza is all superb! We live an hour drive 1 way and is definitely worth the trip
… moreThomas S
The food and service were absolutely fantastic. Tonight was our first time stopping by, but we will absolutely be back.
My wife and I went here for a date night and the appetizer (cheese bread) was so delicious that we were very excited for our pizza to come – which was outstanding. They were even kind enough to make stuffed crust pizza for us which wasn’t on the menu! 10/10 would highly recommend for any occasion.
… moreMy wife and I went here for a date night and the appetizer (cheese bread) was so delicious that we were very excited for our pizza to come – which was outstanding. They were even kind enough to make stuffed crust pizza for us which wasn’t on the menu! 10/10 would highly recommend for any occasion.
Rosemary Williams
I am really enjoying the menu of Marios under new ownership. The pasta dishes are rich and delicious, and look as special as they taste. Even the side salad was pretty. The Margherita Mama pizza is delightful and the focaccia is amazing every time! Tonight’s lasagna and tomato bisque were perfect. Our server was attentive and friendly. If you’re looking for a delicious meal of the Italianin variety in a very low key, small town diner then this is your place.
… moreTony Arbisi
We called for a delivery order and my wife happen to tell the person taking our order that I had just had my wisdom teeth removed and couldn’t have red sauce on my pasta. The food was excellent and they even threw in one scoop of chocolate ice cream with “Feel Better “ written on it. Thank you so much.
… moreShannon White
This is the first time since Mario’s re-opened up again that we have ordered. We wanted calzones and wow. This was fantastic. Not just hot on delivery, but very delicious as well. We had calzones recently from a place with good reviews in Milton- you guys passed them up easily.
Delicious and by far better quality from Mario’s. Glad you are back! Keep it up. Excellent!
… moreDelicious and by far better quality from Mario’s. Glad you are back! Keep it up. Excellent!
marilyn bray
Had dinner tonight with friends. The food was excellent! I had the Cesar salad, and it was really good. Not over powered with garlic. Main course was the lasagna. Very hearty. The sauce was really tasty. Service was excellent. Will definitely be back. Can’t wait to try the pizza.
… moreD Rock
The pizza is very good and, honestly, the fries…yesssss! Pizza is very cheesy, sauce with a hint of sweet, and generally airy crust but the cheese can make it soggy (which, whatevs, it’s still good!). Very welcoming and friendly staff. Excited to try other dishes! Will definitely be coming back often!
… moreNicole Simle
Good food and great service! We ordered delivery which took about an hour to arrive. The delivery driver was very kind, confirmed our order, and told us to enjoy our dinner. The food was good, especially the truffle fries, which were tasty and crispy.
… moreDenise Barlass
My Husband and I had dinner here last week, it was delicious! I ordered the Vodka Cream Farfalle with chicken breast. I will definitely tell all my friends to go here
… moreJon Gulbrandson
Just tried Mario’s for the first time and my wife and I were blown away! She had the tortellini Alfredo and the sauce was incredible! Delicious cheese stuffing too. I had the Shrimp fettuccine and it was also very delicious with the slightest bite of red pepper and hint of lemon. Service was excellent and welcoming – our server even ran out to get us when we mistakenly left our to-go boxes. Oops! But we’re definitely going back! Highly recommend.
… more