Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
weinischsdeli • Instagram photos and videos
Smithtown NY Family Owned Establishment since 1983 · Photo by weinischsdeli in Weinischs Deli with @maplecommons_smithtown. WE DID IT!
Weinisch’s Deli – 300 Maple Ave, Smithtown, NY, 11787 – MapQuest
Weinischs’ Deli is a popular deli located in Smithtown, NY, known for its delicious sandwiches and friendly staff. With a reputation for being one of the best …
Weinisch’s Deli – Deli in Suffolk County – Website
Nestled in the heart of Smithtown, Weinisch’s Deli stands as a beloved culinary gem known for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional service.
Reviews
Nicholas Ragoo
Not sure if these reviews are from bots but this is by far the worst hero’s I ever ate and the most expensive price I paid! $30 for egg and turkey hero. They didn’t even add any lettuce, mayo, nothing to the hero’s. Not even toast the bread. Would not recommend.
… moreJason M
First note: Everything was extremely clean, if a bit scattered and hard to focus on. Their menu is on full-size paper sheets taped to the wall all over, so if you get overwhelmed just ask your a paper menu which will be a lot easier to order from.
I got a number 1, a hot pastrami on toasted rye(I think). And I also ordered a number 7 which was an Italian sub and a number 11 which was a turkey BLT wrap which could have used more veggies which is about the first time I have ever felt that way about a deli wrap. Everything was fresh and tasty, but flavor fatigue hits hard. Pro-tip: order for 2 or more, and share halves of your sandwiches. Variety is the spice of life, isn’t it?
The employees were extremely helpful, and even checked the expiration date on the shoestring chips I picked out which no deli has ever bothered to do for me before. A lot of them are VERY happy to sell you treats that expired 4 months ago, but not this one.
This is a CASH ONLY business at least at the time of this review. I saw the sign only after placing my order and that could have been a big oopsie.
Overall I really feel Weinisch earned that 5/5.
PS: The sweet tea is extremely sweet. Next time I go I may ask them to make me a semi-sweet tea by mixing sweet and unsweet.
… moreI got a number 1, a hot pastrami on toasted rye(I think). And I also ordered a number 7 which was an Italian sub and a number 11 which was a turkey BLT wrap which could have used more veggies which is about the first time I have ever felt that way about a deli wrap. Everything was fresh and tasty, but flavor fatigue hits hard. Pro-tip: order for 2 or more, and share halves of your sandwiches. Variety is the spice of life, isn’t it?
The employees were extremely helpful, and even checked the expiration date on the shoestring chips I picked out which no deli has ever bothered to do for me before. A lot of them are VERY happy to sell you treats that expired 4 months ago, but not this one.
This is a CASH ONLY business at least at the time of this review. I saw the sign only after placing my order and that could have been a big oopsie.
Overall I really feel Weinisch earned that 5/5.
PS: The sweet tea is extremely sweet. Next time I go I may ask them to make me a semi-sweet tea by mixing sweet and unsweet.
Eric Mullins
First time in NY and I had the absolute best bacon, egg, cheese, roll with s&p, and ketchup. The crew was absolutely the friendliest and the food was everything I expected. I’ll be back and will eat everything!!
… moreBrian Em
This deli always serves great food! I have also ordered a large hero a couple of times in the past and it tasted amazing! The employees are very nice! This business is cash only. Highly recommended.
… moreSarah Gletty
Amazing food & people! After growing up on Long Island but moving out of state due to work I have been missing a good deli. Weinish’s was exactly what I was missing and more. The family that owns this deli is beyond generous, warm & friendly! My husband & I both loved the food, their sandwiches were amazing & warm fresh baked muffins were delicious as well! Couldn’t recommend this place enough!
… moreJames Cummings
I’ve been coming to this deli since I was a very young man with my family who are great friends with Artie and has entire family. Always the most delicious food. Always the kindest people and the most pleasing experience. Coming to this deli represents some of the fondest memories of my childhood.
… moreRianna Schwartz
I can’t say enough good things about Weinisch’s Deli! Every time I stop in, the food is fresh, flavorful, and absolutely hits the spot. The buffalo chicken salad is one of my favorites—it’s perfectly balanced with just the right amount of kick, super tender chicken, and that creamy goodness that makes you want to eat it every single day.
Another standout is the shells with feta. It’s such a simple dish, but the way they do it is next level. The pasta shells are always cooked just right, and the feta adds that tangy, salty bite that ties everything together. It’s comfort food with a touch of freshness that keeps you coming back.
Between the great food and the friendly service, Weinisch’s really feels like a gem. If you haven’t tried it yet, the buffalo chicken salad and the shells with feta should definitely be at the top of your list!
… moreAnother standout is the shells with feta. It’s such a simple dish, but the way they do it is next level. The pasta shells are always cooked just right, and the feta adds that tangy, salty bite that ties everything together. It’s comfort food with a touch of freshness that keeps you coming back.
Between the great food and the friendly service, Weinisch’s really feels like a gem. If you haven’t tried it yet, the buffalo chicken salad and the shells with feta should definitely be at the top of your list!
Ryan Loper
Wonderful deli with delicious food. The ladies behind the counter were great. The food outstanding. The atmosphere, like walking into your grandma’s kitchen. I can’t say enough good things about this place. The Bacon, Egg, and Cheese was delicious. We decided to eat on the trunk of the car and by the time we had finished, went back in for another one. Will definitely go back if I am ever in town again.
… moreMike Perrotta
Their egg sandwich is one of the best around. Tammy is always there with a smile to take my order. The place is clean and service is spot on. You can call in orders for pick up.
… moreMichael “UxorialCobra14” Abbazia
Amazing deli and friendly staff. I got a chicken salad wrap soooo good. Nice variety of sandwiches and great beverages to choose from. 10/10 will be back.
… more