Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Borino’s Pizza – Verona, NJ
Borino’s Pizza is the place for delicious, local pizza cuisine. With a variety of food, there’s an option for everyone, so you and your family will never …
Order Authentic Pizza Online | Borino’s Pizza – Pickup or Delivery …
… Borino’s Pizza has a seamless way to get you what you want when you want. Location. Borino’s Pizza. 557 Bloomfield Ave, Verona, NJ 07044 · 9738571888. Pickup.
Borino’s Pizza – Verona, NJ – 557 Bloomfield Ave – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-8:45 PM; Shop address is 557 Bloomfield Ave, Verona, NJ 07044557 Bloomfield Ave, Verona, NJ 07044; (973) 857-1888.
Reviews
P R
FROM WOW to TOXIC
What was, for me, an unprecedented public enthusiasm for Borino’s pizza quickly turned into deep regret after every subsequent experience.
The first red flag regarding customer service occurred when I called Borino’s specifically to offer praise and appreciation for a delivered stuffed pizza I had enjoyed. The employee who answered the phone and received my enthusiastic feedback responded with audible irritation. Her tone and clipped, dismissive “uh-huhs” made it clear that my call was an inconvenience. The subtext was unmistakable: customer engagement was of no interest to her.
That same initial delivery revealed a second red flag regarding integrity and basic professionalism. The pizza had been fully paid for at the time of ordering. Nevertheless, the young delivery person insisted that I come to the front door and demanded cash. When I explained what I had paid, how, and to whom, he asked again for money—this time explicitly for a tip. I gave him a five-dollar bill. He pursed his lips, sighed, and said, “Don’t you have more?”
“No,” I replied, beginning to close my door. He stood motionless in the doorway. I said, “Thank you. Good night.”
The second delivery of stuffed pizza was made by an older man. He, too, made it clear that he believed he was entitled to a larger tip.
The pizza itself was… meh.
The third—and final—order bore no resemblance to food at all. Receiving it was akin to being handed hazardous material.
The pizza reeked of sour garlic and spoiled fish, emitting a nauseating odor that permeated every room in my apartment, including rooms with closed doors.
The pizza tasted bitter and sour. The garlic knots in the crust had a vulgar fish flavor and smell. I spat out my first bite. I attempted another bite from a different slice and had to spit it out again. My dinner companion had eaten most of a single slice; shortly afterward, he reported feeling nauseous, unwell, and on the verge of vomiting.
This pizza was either contaminated during preparation by residue from other ingredients—or intentionally prepared to be inedible for reasons unknown.
Given the overwhelming odor and taste, there is no possibility that this condition went unnoticed during preparation, baking, or delivery. This was a willful disregard for food integrity and customer safety.
What a shame. That first pie was perfection or a fluke.
… moreWhat was, for me, an unprecedented public enthusiasm for Borino’s pizza quickly turned into deep regret after every subsequent experience.
The first red flag regarding customer service occurred when I called Borino’s specifically to offer praise and appreciation for a delivered stuffed pizza I had enjoyed. The employee who answered the phone and received my enthusiastic feedback responded with audible irritation. Her tone and clipped, dismissive “uh-huhs” made it clear that my call was an inconvenience. The subtext was unmistakable: customer engagement was of no interest to her.
That same initial delivery revealed a second red flag regarding integrity and basic professionalism. The pizza had been fully paid for at the time of ordering. Nevertheless, the young delivery person insisted that I come to the front door and demanded cash. When I explained what I had paid, how, and to whom, he asked again for money—this time explicitly for a tip. I gave him a five-dollar bill. He pursed his lips, sighed, and said, “Don’t you have more?”
“No,” I replied, beginning to close my door. He stood motionless in the doorway. I said, “Thank you. Good night.”
The second delivery of stuffed pizza was made by an older man. He, too, made it clear that he believed he was entitled to a larger tip.
The pizza itself was… meh.
The third—and final—order bore no resemblance to food at all. Receiving it was akin to being handed hazardous material.
The pizza reeked of sour garlic and spoiled fish, emitting a nauseating odor that permeated every room in my apartment, including rooms with closed doors.
The pizza tasted bitter and sour. The garlic knots in the crust had a vulgar fish flavor and smell. I spat out my first bite. I attempted another bite from a different slice and had to spit it out again. My dinner companion had eaten most of a single slice; shortly afterward, he reported feeling nauseous, unwell, and on the verge of vomiting.
This pizza was either contaminated during preparation by residue from other ingredients—or intentionally prepared to be inedible for reasons unknown.
Given the overwhelming odor and taste, there is no possibility that this condition went unnoticed during preparation, baking, or delivery. This was a willful disregard for food integrity and customer safety.
What a shame. That first pie was perfection or a fluke.
Elizabeth Brady
The food arrive a bit cold. Upon inspection it looked pretty good. However, the pizza dough was chewy and the cheese wasn’t very tasty. The eggplant had too much bread crumbs and the same cheese as the pizza. The salad had a musty taste. Overall not great. Will not be ordering from here again.
… moreChuck Mound
Scouting Pizza for the Pizza Hunters App. Parking can be a challenge when visiting this Pizzeria. Keep your head on a swivel. Very nice at the counter with Customer Service. Very polite and were all about service. They recommended the upside down Sicilian slice. It was good, but the top sauce was cold. The regular slice was an average slice. Enjoyed the Pizza and would try them again.
… moreDebbie Ryan
Love this place for takeout. All my food was absolutely delicious. There was a delay in delivery and the owner personally delivered the food. He was so sweet and apologetic. They are definitely my go to place for Italian takeout.
… moreUnice Wang
Best pizzas in NJ! We love the cheesey old grandma pie and the meat lovers with tons of toppings. Must try! You can order one pie with half grandma and half meat lovers.
… moreSamantha Guadalupe
I must say I do enjoy there pizza. Plain slice with the just the right amount of sauce, cheese and most importantly the crunch. Fair price and good food. Can’t complain.
… moreMichael Gray
Ordered supreme. Crust was bland tasted like an unsalted matza. big chunks of jalapeno s with stems intact. Box was a bit crushed when it got to me. Been in the Midwest having what I thought was bad pizza and was looking forward to finding a new place but it seems really odd to me this place is so highly rated.
… moreNaima
Very bad customer service, they seem always they are in bad mood, 10/08 we were send coupons 25% off from the town to support local businesses, everywhere else we were offered discount( restaurant, candy store…) only at Borino we were given attitude because we asked for discount and again that’s because they are always giving the bad customer service.
… moreNova Garita
Customer service 10/10, they are very friendly, welcoming, nice. The Sicilian pizza was warm and the supper delicious, definitely the best one I have tried!!
… moreDebbie Dynan
Borinos has gone downhill in the last year. New
owner took over. They can never get my order right. Pizza sauce was so salty, couldn’t eat it. Original owner from 2017 was so much better.
… moreowner took over. They can never get my order right. Pizza sauce was so salty, couldn’t eat it. Original owner from 2017 was so much better.