Caroline Erb
Had a buffalo chicken cheesesteak made special by the owner and it was genuinely the best one I’ve ever had in my entire life. Just picked up pizza and cheesy fries tonight and they were kind enough to add bacon at pick-up. They also have a free arcade cabinet to play retros while you wait for your food—overall a great vibe, great food, and great service. Will be dining again!
… moreGabby Cook
AMAZING PIZZA, sauce is out of this world. Fast & amazing customer service. Support this family owned business!!!!!
… moreBridget Laudermilch
Excellent food and service! Pizza has the best crust and taste. Their subs are on wonderful, fresh rolls and packed full.
Highly recommend this place! Check them out….
… moreWilliam Lindsey
I’ve had this pizza fresh, “there’s pizza in the breakroom” hours old, and at”nobody wants the last two slices” hours old. It holds up.
When I went there, I was just another random guy adding a to-go order in the mix, so I sat around long enough to notice some important things. The place is kept clean, even when they’re busy. They have all the basics your average south central Pennsylvanian needs to feast on a day when nobody feels like cooking- local chips and sodas in the cooler (including Mexican Cokes in glass bottles).
At the time that I’m writing this, the place hasn’t been open for long. They just took over from the previous owner. My first impression was a good one, and I’ll be back.
… moreJennifer Troup
Hugh fans of Gargano’s and really want to give this place a fair chance. We went to order pizza for take out and ended up waiting over a half hour for sub par pizzas. Not sure if this is their first rodeo but the man cooking the pizza consistently kept opening the oven door evee 2 minutes which led to the crust being way too hard.
… moreKimberly Keenen
The food is great. Our first visit was great so we went back a second time. My only complaint with our second experience is the fries and onion rings were packaged in a tin foil pan with a lid and both were soggy and lost all their crunch. Our first visit the fries and such were in paper bags and the crunch was perfect. I suggest going back to the little paper bags to keep the deep fried yummies nice and crunchy.
… moreMathew Batista
Genuine good pizza, I suggest grabbing a slice if you have a chance. They were attentive and quick with providing service.
… moreBrenda Person
The food was truly fantastic and exceeded my expectations in so many ways. The meals were prepared in a timely manner, which made the entire experience even more enjoyable. I really appreciate when a restaurant is able to deliver quality food without keeping you waiting too long. And let me tell you, the pizza was out of this world—definitely some of the best I’ve ever tasted! If you’re looking for a delicious meal, you’re in for a real treat here. You won’t be disappointed!
… moreEvan Birch
Phenomenal! The pizza was great with an excellent crust. Lived in LanCo for a while and this is hands down the best pizza. Great quality for an even better price. They are a must try and an asset to East Petersburg.
… moreLJ Cruz
Really good pizza joint. We went to try it out since it was recently opened. Was surprised at how good the pizza and stramboli were. If you dont have a strong appetite dont get a stramboli for yourself its huge!
… more