Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Pickerington, OH, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Pickerington pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Pickerington or stop by 1201 Hill Road North for carryout to order the best pizza in Pickerington, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1201 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147
Phone: (614) 864-7272
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
1201 Hill Road North – Pickerington, OH – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
Order from Papa Johns Hill Road North for the best takeout and food delivery in Pickerington. Order online, visit or call for pizza, wings, sides and more!
Pizza in Pickerington, OH | Papa Johns Hill Road North
For pizza delivery in Pickerington, call us at (614) 864-7272 to order, or stop by 1201 Hill Road North in Pickerington, OH for carryout.
papa johns stores in pickerington, oh
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Pickerington, Ohio to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Last Updates
Reviews
Amanda Villeda
My kids really loves Papa John’s. We get it every Friday night. Today we tried the new Pan Pizza. I DO NOT recommend. Toppings slid off the pizza and the dough was chewy….not in a good way. Going back to our usual pizza.
… moreDon Nunn
First time I stopped in there. Have a screen up above counter of the pizzas they have. No prices. Asked if they had a menu. Girl points up. No shit. I can see that.If it wasn’t for my girlfriend wanting P J’s s I would have just walked out. Alot of better pizza places all around there. Did I say it was the first time there. It’s the last time as well. Pizza Hut across the street their better anyways. Go there!!!! Hell Little Caesars is too.. I’m back, well not here. Cross the street at Pizza hut. Asked for a menu,and got one. You won’t find that kind of customer service at the Hill Rd. Papa johns. Man, I’m glad I boycott PJ.’s.
… moreCarmen Smith
I ordered a medium pizza around 3pm it did not arrive until 5:40 pm. Cold by a door dasher. He stated he did not receive the delivery until 5pm. I was told the pizza would be delivered in 34 to 40 mins. Around 3:41
I called the store and some guy answered I tried to explain to him that we paid by credit card and that it had been one hour. He began to yell that it’s Halloween and that I need to check a website. As I tried to tell him I did n
… moreI called the store and some guy answered I tried to explain to him that we paid by credit card and that it had been one hour. He began to yell that it’s Halloween and that I need to check a website. As I tried to tell him I did n
Tony Daley
I never order pizza from Papa John’s because usually I’m more of a flyers guy. I took a chance today and ordered some and a man named Craig gave me a really good deal on a really big pizza and was really friendly and remembered that I asked for garlic dipping sauce and gave it to me when I got there. He is doing a great job in there.
… morelatonya barner
I asked for half cheese and half pepperoni… this is what I received, after I was told they will not honor wings
… moreRebecca Hammond
We love the Papa John’s on Hamilton Road, but live further away now so we went to this one. Pizza tasted so bad. The crust was too thin for Papa John’s, sauce was really sweet which I’m not a fan of nor used to from them and just overall tasted a bit old and gross. Would not come back to this one.
… moreDavid Bailey
Overall usually things are great but today (7/26/2024 around 3p) I order a XL pepperoni and the pizza came in as if someone legit threw the pizza in the box. But not just the pizza but as if they threw it in the box piece by piece.
… morejohn macari
Thought I was biting on a piece of overcooked crispy crust……turns out it was a shard of metal baked into the pizza. Better ingredients, is it?? This is unacceptable, negligent, dangerous, and just utterly disgusting!! Thankfully, I never swallowed it!! Appalling standards Papa J!!!
… moreAntique Shopper
Good location, nice employees, great tasting pizza!
I always order carry out through the Papa John’s app. Most days, I receive emails for 40% or 50% off large pizzas or any pizzas. I never pay full price for Papa John’s pizzas and I love it!
… moreI always order carry out through the Papa John’s app. Most days, I receive emails for 40% or 50% off large pizzas or any pizzas. I never pay full price for Papa John’s pizzas and I love it!
Madison Cordle
Pizza and cinnamon pull aparts were baked fine. Didn’t have any of my sauces I paid for in the boxes though and I had to go back inside and get them. I paid for 3 cups of the cream cheese icing and they gave me these 3 sauce containers filled about a 1/4 of the way each
… more