Kevin George
When we moved up to Westminster about 2 years ago, this place became our go-to pizza spot because it was consistently good. Over the last few months, I don’t know what changed, but it was swift and not for the better. We ordered and received a pizza that was basically uncooked. No one is perfect, so we tossed it in the air fryer. No love lost.
Welp, time after that, the same problem occurred. Not particularly smart, we ate some of it before getting upset stomachs and just tossing the rest. Against my better judgment, we tried one last time and got the most uncooked pizza so far. I was stretching the crust. Keep in mind, we asked for well done every time.
We gave up on ordering from here so much that we started driving over the line into PA to pick up pizza. Welp, tonight I paid for being lazy and not wanting to drive. Tried ordering again, and I even called after placing the order online to verify that we wanted the pizza extra well done so it wouldn’t be doughy at all.
Welp, yet again, we got a barely cooked, blond-looking pizza. Most of the cheese was barely melted. The toppings looked like they had been placed on after baking. Not to mention, the toppings were wrong.
So, this is pretty much the nail in the coffin. I just don’t see us ordering from them again, especially when a pizza now costs $30.
The picture is with NO cheese. That was the dough under the cheese the time I said I could stretch it.
… morematt baird
I had a great experience tonight thanks to the server Kara that was on the receipt! She took my order with such a positive attitude and was extremely polite from start to finish. After taking my order, she went straight to the back to start preparing the food, which I really appreciated. My order came out in about 10 –12 minutes perfectly timed. The food was hot, fresh, full of flavor, and it looked phenomenal when it came out. You can tell she really cares about her work and her customers. Excellent service all around!
… morejessica mehaffie
I order sub with spinach (had to pay extra) did not receive spinach on my sub.
Order a salad had to pay extra for extra dressing. Didn’t receive not a single packet of dressing!!!
… moreArthur Finneyfrock
Moved to Westemeier over a year ago … they where the first spot we hit for delivery, the pepperoni and cheese …. always killing it. We live 12 minuets away delivery times are always reasonable . In over a year of service there the most reliable hands doesn’t
… moreMegan Hopkins
I ordered a Tuscan CHICKEN salad. I came home to open my promptly and kindly served to go order, and open my well deserved and longing desire for a well seasoned salad with chicken to find a salad, with what could be described at best as well processed chicken. Seasoning? Non existent. Chemical processing and rubber texture? Abundantly clear. No where on the menu was there an astrix to indicate “chicken substitute”. The fact that you haven’t been sued for false advertising is astonishing. You have Captain Farms within walking distance who contributes to the community by raising fresh chicken. Travel 10 more miles and you’ll find an abundance of your neighbors offering real food. Do better.
… moreDana Bandell Schaeffer
Pay xtra for peps and onions. Peps loaded. One slice had 2 onions on it. Cheesy bread dry and overcooked and weird it didn’t come with dip sauce.
… moreJanice F
Ordered around 8:45 at night, carry out, and the food was great! Ready, correct, hot, and tasty! Just what we wanted! Ordered pizza, chicken tenders, and wings. Service with a smile close to closing time, much appreciated!
… moreDylan
My breadsticks and cookies were great and the cashier was very nice. Pretty nice inside.
… moreJordan Black
We typically order carry-out, but chose to dine in with family recently. The dining room is basic & the booths have no cushioning. Their food is usually decent, but the steak stromboli seemed a bit dark & they had to remake our cheese sticks. Prices r a bit steep & other local pizza shops offer a wider menu, but my partner enjoys their pizza & their spinach mushroom rolls r my fav for a quick bite.
5/29 – Such awesome service 2day! The chocolate in their house baked cookies is delicious. Decent place for a quick bite for two ❤️
… moreRyan Davis
Love their crust, tender with a good chew. Got a couple breakfast pies this time. Why don’t more places do this?! They were so delicious and my wife didn’t think I was a weirdo for ordering pizza at 9:30 in the morning. Win, win.
… more