Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Big Jim’s Pizzeria – New Milford, NJ – 281 Main St – Hours, Menu, Order
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Big Jim’s Pizzeria in New Milford, NJ. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Big Jim’s Pizzeria | New Milford NJ – Facebook
Enjoy BIG JIM’S Large Pizza for just $12.99 plus tax! Add your favorite toppings for only $3.75 each. This special offer is available Monday through Thursday …
Big Jim’s Pizzeria (@bigjimspizzeria) · New Milford, NJ – Instagram
435 followers · 41 posts · (201)-262-4600 Call Us ⬆️ Order online.
Reviews
Jeff T. Critic
Big Jim’s
279 Main St.
New Milford, NJ 07646
Rice Balls
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
The rice ball was packed with peas and chopped meat, but it could have been a tad bit bigger especially since the marinara cup actually looks bigger than the appetizer itself.
But the taste was pretty good and it was great starter to the meal.
The wrap did have a good chicken to lettuce ratio. The best part of the main course was the sauce, especially the large chewy chunks of crumbles in the blue cheese dipping.
#bigjims #riceballs #buffalochickenwrap #newmilfordnj
… more279 Main St.
New Milford, NJ 07646
Rice Balls
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
The rice ball was packed with peas and chopped meat, but it could have been a tad bit bigger especially since the marinara cup actually looks bigger than the appetizer itself.
But the taste was pretty good and it was great starter to the meal.
The wrap did have a good chicken to lettuce ratio. The best part of the main course was the sauce, especially the large chewy chunks of crumbles in the blue cheese dipping.
#bigjims #riceballs #buffalochickenwrap #newmilfordnj
anthony mekhail
The chicken bacon ranch was delicious. But the worker used his bare hands to put my slice in the oven. I trust his hands were clean but I prefer gloves or utensils
… moreMichelle Sawicki
I ordered a grilled chicken Ceasar salad and a pizza. I’ve gotten the salad from them a few times, and the best thing about it was the croutons. My husband picked up the order, and when I opened the salad, there were NO croutons! When he called to complain, he was asked, “Did you say that you wanted croutons?” Seriously! I never had to ask for specific ingredients before! I’m not going to order from them anymore.
… moreD Mac
Been getting pizza from this place for 40+ years, and the food is good most of the time. Biggest issue is their hours. 7:30 on a Monday night and you can’t get food delivered to your house. Gone are the days of ordering a late night snack, now you can’t even get dinner when you get home late from work.
… morePatricia Stein
Don’t bother. Ordered a pizza and was told 35 to 45 minutes for delivery… It came almost 2 hours later and it wasn’t hot. Also, there was hardly any tomato sauce on the pizza. Worst pizza we’ve ever had.
… moreDana Rubin
I have been coming to Big Jim’s for over 40 years and the owner Jimmy was always reasonable and fair. New ownership must be very petty.
I ordered a pizza with Spinach topping and it was very little. Spoke to the guy (John) who made the pie and he says that is the standard amount he puts on (see attached photo). His response was if you don’t want it then don’t pay for it. Very poor customer service and very petty.
… moreI ordered a pizza with Spinach topping and it was very little. Spoke to the guy (John) who made the pie and he says that is the standard amount he puts on (see attached photo). His response was if you don’t want it then don’t pay for it. Very poor customer service and very petty.
Y C
I honestly don’t see the hype. The pizza dough the taste the sauce nothing feels special. I believe it was better years ago unfortunately. I bought a pie yesterday and I really wanted to give 4 stars but I couldn’t I eat pizza almost everyday and if I was to rate it 1 -10 it would be a 6.4 pizza review @daveportnoy.
… moreJ Lachica
I have been going there for years! If you love ham and cheese calzones, I highly recommend Big Jim’s.
… moreBell McGough
I ordered calamari and it was horrible. I was chewy and and nasty. I was afraid to eat it bec it seems like not a real food. The thin Pizza was not thin at all. Was so unhappy. Not coming back ever.I can’t even put a star bec the food was that bad.
… moreMike Delancey
This is my all time favorite neighborhood pizzeria, over multiple decades and towns. At first, I planned on talking about how good the crust is, for this review. But then as I ate a pepper and onion slice, I decided I wanted to talk about the awesome sauce. But then I ate a plain, and decided the cheese was what I should mention. So it’s all good, I guess I should just say lol
Their Pizza Sale is a recognized ~6 week holiday in our home every year, and it’s going on now!
… moreTheir Pizza Sale is a recognized ~6 week holiday in our home every year, and it’s going on now!